Dale and Ryan discuss the feeding of supplements to stock show animals.
Episode overview
Dale and Ryan take a critical look at how much money show families spend on supplements. They agree some targeted products help when an animal is deficient or when a specific goal, such as available amino acids for muscle, is clear, but argue that supplements cannot fix poor structure, genetics or management. Dale explains that unregulated products let families use price as a stand-in for quality, and that peer pressure and fear of falling behind keep the cycle going, along with the belief that a winner owes its success to whatever it was fed. He warns that feeding supplements in amounts approaching the feed itself can unbalance amino acids, minerals and the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio, and that ruminants and single-stomached animals respond differently. He reviews the basic nutrients and suggests asking what a product is meant to do, how it works, and whether it was tested in the species. Q&A covers balancing fun and preparation for a judging team, and how hair length is trending on wether goats.
Sponsors in this episode
SenseHub by Merck Animal Health ▶ 54:25Show Circuit Online Sales ▶ 11:25Show FresH2O ▶ 12:11
Key takeaways
- Before buying a supplement, be able to say exactly what it should accomplish and how it works in the animal.
- Do not assume a higher price means a better product; compare ingredients and ask a nutrition consultant to review labels.
- Feeding a large amount of supplement relative to feed can throw off the balance of amino acids, minerals and the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio.
- Do not feed every animal the same supplement; use targeted products for the specific issue you are trying to address.
- Genetics, balanced nutrition and daily management move the needle far more than any supplement.
- Keep animals well hydrated rather than pulling water, since muscle is largely water.
Chapters
Read the transcript
0:00 Opening: news and current events
0:00Welcome to Beyond the Ring, a podcast that covers all things in the stock show industry from the informative to the insane, starring Ryan Rash, Red Bull isn't cutting it anymore. I need a chew on a power line. And Dale Hummel. You cannot supplement your way out of poor management or bad genetics. Now on with the show. Welcome to Beyond the Ring. This is Dale Hummel, along with co-star Ryan Rash.
0:40Hello, hello, hello. Ryan, 36 days. Yes, I'm very well aware. And I did. It's probably going to be a disaster. I had AI help me with this, looking at some of the different polls out there. And if you combine all of them, it appears as though the most likely outcome is 49 seats to 51. In favor of who? We don't want to say that. We don't want to talk about it. Lovely. They can hope for a 50-50 split, and then your boyfriend breaks a tie.
1:21That's our best scenario. Maybe that happens. I'll take it if it does. Right now, I would take a 50-50 split and call it good. But if you look through here, and I went through state by state, it's a problem. And those swing states right now, we really need to get lucky. But there's some of the polls that will give you as high of a likelihood as 58% that the Democrats will win the Senate. There's others. There are none that I've found that basically favored, and I shouldn't say none, there are not any in the top five or so polls that favor the Republicans winning the Senate.
2:07The best we get is a tie. I didn't even get to the House. I think that's going to be much worse. I don't know where you're getting your information, but there was somebody on Fox this morning, and I don't even remember who it was. and he seems to think that the Republicans are going to have 53 senators, but whatever. I can only hope it's like the Trump polls, how far off they are. My fear is what we talked about last week. They just aren't going to show up. They aren't going to go out and vote. I think it's going to be a disaster. I'm convinced. That's why I'm not watching much news or anything. When there was no polling, no polling, no polling forever, I was like, they're not giving any polling information because it's bad.
2:56Now you and your AI, whatever, have convinced me that this is a disaster. So I'll watch election day. But other than that, I'm not participating. Because as I said, I have talked, I've probably talked to 10 people about this subject just since we recorded last. I get it that you are not happy about $6 diesel or whatever and what he did with the beef and I'm not saying the man is perfect I will say this and I will continue to say this, there is nothing that that man in the White House is going to do that will be as detrimental as if the other people get control of the House or the Senate and so I get you're frustrated. I get you're upset.
3:54Bite it and go out there and vote Republican and hope and pray that they keep a majority. And then at least he can get some of the stuff that good stuff that he wants to get around passed. Otherwise, the next two years, nothing's going to happen except impeachment. That is that is exactly right. Impeachment. Nothing. There will be zero. Nothing will happen except impeachment. That's all the next two years will be. No, I couldn't agree more with that. I just pulled up here, and there's what they call five toss-up states. Do you want to know that Texas is in the toss-up state? Yes, I'm very well aware.
4:36I do not believe that man will win. but we had in the Republican side, we had terrible, terrible choices. I mean, horrible, but I thought you were going to run for a Senate seat. Right. Yeah. That'll work out. Maine, Texas, Ohio, Iowa, and Alaska. Well, Alaska is not going to go Republic. Let's take that off. I don't know. Maine would shock me, but I'll take it if we can get it. Ohio should go Republican. I think to get... I judged enough county fairs in Ohio this year.
5:18You Ohioans get the hell out there and vote, okay? You owe it to me. There. Of those five, the Republicans only need two to hold the Senate. I mean, I can look at it that way, and I have a little more hope. You're going to tell me we get Texas. Yes. I, this state is way too red and they, they have done this with Beto and all these other people, whatever, and it never is as close as it seems. And literally this telejack ass, whatever his name is, he is the worst that they've ever put up. But Ken Paxton has a, I don't even know how to describe his past, but he's got some baggage.
6:06We'll just go with that. But I do like what the man says. I'm not going to say that he can get what he wants around, but I do think the things that he talks about to make things more affordable and all these other stuff that he's spouting out there on the campaign trail as his rhetoric. I like it. I just know that his past isn't great, but the one he beat was just terrible. That sitting senator, he was just, it is hard for me to say that there's somebody worse than Ted Cruz. That's been a Senator in Texas. And that man was, so I was glad he got beat. Yeah.
6:46I've not followed that whatsoever. I just hope two of those five fall this direction. I didn't pull up the house because I gave up on it. I hope I'm wrong on that. I do know that if we would get as motivated to vote as we were just a couple years ago, this would not be a problem. And I do understand that people aren't exactly happy right now. But this is, and I will say this again, and you'll probably hear this every week till the midterms happen and it's a disaster. Republicans get upset about one thing. maybe they don't like the candidate maybe they don't like something the president has done one little thing they get their panties in a twist over it and then they just stay home and this is why we have problems because the Democrats will literally rise people from the dead literally to get them to vote and they will bust people in they will do all this other stuff and they're just going to vote and they don't even know who the candidates are They just go in there and hit Democrat.
7:57So y'all can't stay home because I promise you, all you're going to get is two years of impeachment. Just like we had before. A mess. An absolute mess. Well, let's go to something more positive and talk about the screw worm. Oh, there's something positive about screw worm. There is. There are very few of them. Remember, we talked about it's going to be a multi-year process, and it still could be. and I don't know if the testing is skewed. I don't know what it is, but it doesn't seem logical according to all the research that I did prior to the screw rumor once it came in because they're up to a total confirmed in the U.S.
8:39to 47 cases. That's not bad. That's up like, no, that's not. Three new cases in August brought it up to 47. So it's not climbing. They've lifted some livestock movement restrictions in New Mexico. Texas, the sterile fly program report zero wild flies caught in traps alongside tens of thousands of some of the sterile flies. So it appears as though the sterile fly saturation is working. It appears as though very few flies entered the U.S. to begin with. I have no idea what that number is, but according to the traps, maybe they're just smarter and they don't get caught in the traps.
9:23I don't know. But as they go through, and I don't know what their life cycle is, three to four more life cycles, basically three to four months. I think a life cycle is about a month. They feel pretty good with the current population of sterile flies. They're not saying there'll be zero, but they will have it continue to keep it in check, which is pretty dang impressive because we talked about ramping up sterile fly production, all of these things to be able to push them back out. And if they would have gotten a foothold on a numbers situation, it would have been very difficult to get them out. It would take a lot of sterile fly production. I hope the plant there in Texas that was supposed to be completed here by the end of the year to make more sterile flies.
10:11I hope they continue with that because I don't see this being the last time the screw worm crosses the border. Or for us to be able to get it. They just don't think that they've got this handled and we're just going to... Yes. That that would be bad. That would be. So, bottom line, containment trending positive. Still active. There are a few there. There are some restrictions still in Texas. Does that impact you at all when you're traveling around going to shows that you've felt? Oh, I mean, we have to have a vet certified that animal doesn't have screw worm and all this other stuff.
10:51It was, and all those kind of things. But I mean, you still got to go get health papers to get to these shows anyway. So, I mean, do we have to take our animals more now? Yes, but it's way, way, way better than what I thought it was going to be. Like, I thought they were going to tell everybody in Texas, screw you, you don't get the show anymore. Next. So, I'm fine. No, and that's, I think we both were on that. Thank God it's not. Because it appears that things are going in a very good direction. So, I appreciate that. Well, this episode is brought to you by SC Online Sales. For years, buyers and sellers across the country have turned to SCO because it works.
11:35Tried, true, tested, trusted. customer minded with the integrity leading the way check out the record number of fall cattle sales happening now spring sheep and goat sales are booking reach out to any sco team member with questions they are happy to accommodate thank you sco for setting the bar and bringing the greatest number of buyers and sellers together in the history of the stock show world brian why are animals not drinking in Dallas. Chlorine. Only Show Fresh H2O neutralizes and have and they have three patents to prove it. You can purchase Show Fresh H2O at your local supply trailer or at swampfox.com.
12:00 Supplement spending versus proven benefit
12:17Yes. Ready for the title that Ryan came up with years ago. No, last night. Oh, God. Supplement Shuffle. Supplement Shuffle. Why do you have to keep picking on the supplement people? I'm not picking on them, but literally, we're going to unload a steer in Dallas in a number of hours here. And I just thought about last night that I am going to watch people unload, and I am going to see more supplements than feed sacks in some people's stalls. See, and I usually point the finger towards a pig ring for more supplements than feed, but you're saying even in the cattle arena and steer arena.
12:59There will be some. I mean, not as many as in the pigs, but there will still be some. And I'm not going to call out any supplements by name. I'm not going to do anything with that. I don't think we've ever... I mean, we've talked about this, but I don't know if it's ever been a topic before. but we just need to discuss the benefits of supplements or some of them and maybe talk about how to not go crazy. Well, I think this is good and we've talked about this a lot and I've probably received as much hate mail over supplements and me being a little negative in general as anything And I want to be very clear before we get started.
13:49There are supplements out there that serve a purpose. There are supplements out there that are huge if the animal is deficient in that area and they can accommodate getting it back into balance. There are supplements there, for example, amino acid supplements, that if we're truly in a muscle building stage and that animal genetically has the capability, we understand how to get them on a track or a treadmill or whatever we're going to do in the sheep and goat world and then provide biologically available amino acids slash protein. There are benefits to these things, but right now the supplement spend is what I'm going to call it in the show world. The amount of money spent on supplements in the show world has gotten out of relative to what the products can actually prove they do.
14:39And that's the key. They prove they can do relative to how much money is being spent on supplements. People talk about how expensive show feed is. I'm going to state on the record right now, most families are probably spending more on supplements than they are the actual feed. Yeah. And disclaimer, we do use some supplements. probably not nearly as many as most people, but we do use some. And I'm not here to call out anybody and say that this supplement's shit and this supplement is wonderful. But I do think that there needs to be a discussion about it because I think a lot of people...
15:23Because, for example, at the show this weekend that I judged in Florida, several, and when I mean several, I'd say at least a dozen or more kids or their parents came up to me after the show and said, you know, you said this about my sheep or this about my goat or this about my steer tell me a supplement that will fix that and this could be something about the goat that's broke behind his shoulder most of it was structure Sure. And so that is every single one of those people said, tell me a supplement that can fix that.
16:05This is the problem. We think we can supplement our way into a fix. That is my point right there. I'm not against supplements. I'm not saying that I'm a big rah-rah for supplements. I have to. I'm sorry. I got to stop. I should have done this in current events. But anyway, best line I have heard in a Grand Drive speech of all of this year, I was watching the World Beef Expo open show. Chris Effling gets on the mic. And if you know Chris Effling, you will love this as much as I do. He gets on the mic and says, hey, I'm just going to tell you I'm not a big rah-rah guy. I thought it was the best thing I've heard all year.
16:46I loved it. But anyway, so I'm not a big rah-rah guy in the words of Chris Effling on supplements. But you cannot fix everything with a supplement or 50. That's my point. Agreed completely. So we have a situation where the mindset in general that these supplements can do almost anything. And I think there's something else driving that. I'm going to relate it to our exotic cat business, the Savannas, that we helped create this breed many, many years ago. They're very difficult to breed. We don't get a lot of the first generation cross, but when we do get them because they're hard to make, we can put a price tag on them that's significant because there's not many out there and a lot of people want them.
17:15 Price as a signal of quality
17:35Once we breed down the next generation or two generations, it progressively gets easier to make those. But we have still kept our price point very high. And if we're the highest priced ones out there in this Savannah cat world, and we've been doing it the longest, we have a professional website. Hopefully my wife's responding with intelligent answers and very quickly when somebody reaches out. We give them every reason to see that we've been doing this a long time. We understand what we're doing. we have a quality product, but the number one driving factor, there are cat shows, we don't go to them, but the biggest driving factor for a pet is price. Everybody has personal preference in what they like, but price leads them to presumed quality. So families in the show stock world, similar, increasingly treat price as a market of whether they're doing enough to compete, not whether the product is doing anything, but some of those high-priced supplements, they must be that high-priced in their mind because they're making a difference. And if we don't do that, we're not doing everything we can to get ourselves in a position to win or do the
18:48best we possibly can. And this isn't a story about gullible people. I'm not going down that path. It's a story about smart people using the wrong signal because they don't have the right information. The supplement world is not regulated in any manner, and I'm good with that. But when there's not regulated in any manner, think about some of them that come out and say they can fix everything. Then you put a pretty high price tag on it. And sometimes we fall down that path a little more quickly than what I would like. So it's interesting to me. when people can't independently verify a product's actual efficacy, they use price as the proxy for quality.
19:33If it's high priced, it must work. Nobody can run a controlled trial on a small number of animals in the show barn. Here's some on this supplement. Here's some that aren't. So you have an $80 bag of supplement and a $25 bag of supplement. Same active ingredients, same in general purpose. they're going to lean towards the $80 one because it must have something in it that does a better job and they could be the exact same thing. So we've got to be smarter about it. We've got to think through it. We can't let panic drive us to assume that if we're not spending this money and not feeding all of these supplements, we're not giving ourselves a chance. When in all actuality, when you get to the fugate stage of supplements and you're feeding more supplement than you are real feed, you're not only not doing yourself a positive, you're going backwards on many of our ratios. And I always talk about the calcium phosphorus ratio and we get that out of whack.
20:31That's inhibiting absorption and biological function of that animal. Consequently, we're going to go backwards. So we have real money leaving family budgets for products with no species specific dose control proof behind them. In other words, there is no research. We're not sure, we're not all nutritionists, so we can't read what's in there and think, well, how does that play a role in how that animal is going to put on fat, put on muscle, loosen up joints, whatever that may be. So we have a situation that creates pressure and guilt for families who can't afford to keep up, even though there's a situation here that if they spend more, the thought is we're going to do better.
21:20And if we spend more and don't win, well, what would have happened if we didn't spend it? We could have been almost further down in that class. So there's lots of distractions from things that actually move the needle. And we're going to talk about genetics, nutrition fundamentals, and daily management. Those three factors are going to move the needle far further than any supplement ever can. And when I say supplements, we're talking about basically feed, nutritional. I'm not talking about the beta agonist. And when I say beta agonist, we're talking about Zilmax, Ractopamine, Xperior. You can go all the way back to the old days when people were going to jail over glimbuterol.
22:03Those type of supplements, if you want to say that, and several of those are perfectly legal to feed in the commercial cattle world. Not all shows are going to accept that. Those will change how muscle and fat is deposit on the animal dramatically. So I'm not referring to those. We're going to take the beta agnes and set them aside because there's no question they will make a difference. Not always for the better because we tend to think a little's good, more is better. And that causes some issues. But in general, we've got to be a little smarter about it. I have made the statement on here many times. If you don't understand how that product is going to work or how it biologically will impact that animal, I just wouldn't feed it.
22:50I tell people that, and I've done this on the podcast for a long time, we use some supplements and we'll continue to, and I will continue to advise clients that buy from us to use some supplements. But many of the things that we use, I can go to Walmart, pick up a couple carton of eggs, I can get some cake mix or sugar and come up with a similar situation. We can get some lactated ringers. We can get some dextrose. We can go to the baby aisle, whatever electrolytes they're using to hydrate young children and do a lot of the same that we're doing with the supplements that we're paying much more money for in our industry.
23:31And please, I'm trying not to beat up on the supplement business because if we understand it and we use some of those properly, there's some benefit to it. well and the two points that i want to make and are number one dale already brought one up uh there there is a point where you're going to be detrimental and i don't he's way way deeper into this than i am i just common sense things a lot in terms of feeding, but there is a point when the percentage of supplements that we are feeding, it's going to be detrimental to the animal because it is going to get things out of whack. And he brought that up. And if he wants to go into more detail on that, that's fine. But that's the number one thing that I wanted to bring up about this.
24:29And you don't even have to know anything about nutrition. Just use some common sense on that one. And like I said, Dale's way into the nutrition side of things, and he can probably give you exact ratios and all this other stuff. I just know by common sense when we're feeding things, there's no way that equal parts feed or supplements or not even to that extreme is going to work out. It's just not. And then the other thing, and probably just as important, the other thing is supplements. And again, I'm not calling anybody out by name. I'm not doing anything like that. There is nothing that can fix everything or be beneficial to every part of that animal.
25:19So my advice in the supplement thing is normally when supplements are more targeted that they can help or they can be beneficial to a very specific thing, those are normally the ones that work better, in my opinion. Okay? And we use supplements. I'm not going to name them. I'm not going to do all that. But the ones that we use, they are to target one certain thing that we think on that animal needs worked on.
26:00And so, therefore, we don't feed the exact same supplements to every single animal. And a lot of people just do. And it's crazy. It is. It is. And they're marketed. They are marketed to push them to do exactly that. Right. And then the other thing that I want to say about this is because I know Dale's going to get some hate mail. I'm going to get some hate mail on this, all this other stuff. I can say we stand behind what we say here because I promise you, I know Dale and I have had multiple, multiple, multiple, multiple supplement people want to advertise on here and do all these things.
26:41and we just kind of pushed them off because we don't believe that product works. And we're not going to allow something to be advertised on this podcast that we do not think is beneficial. And so I can say we're putting our money where our mouth is or whatever. That's probably a bad analogy. Losing money where our mouth is, maybe. And not even as much that we know they're not going to work. It's rather either there's not a good biological theory on why they're working and or you or I have not had any experience with that product. So we have no way to get behind it and say, hey, this is where we're at.
27:00 Psychology and peer pressure behind supplements
27:24So there's a lot of psychology that goes into this and that I think continues to loop ourselves as stock show families into this game. And once a family has spent real money and time on a regime, whether it's what animal we're buying, how we're setting our barn up, how we're feeding them, they're psychologically committed to believing this is going to work and it's working. Win or lose. If the animal wins, the supplement gets the credit. If the animal loses, we always think, well, imagine how much worse we would have done without it. Because we're in that justification loop.
28:05we're bought into this situation, the cost creates a narrative that protects itself from being beat up on. And that sounds crazy, I know. But once we are so invested in that, we don't want to say, I just spent a shitload of money on something and it did absolutely no good. That's not human nature. We don't go that way. So people aren't buying supplements hoping to win. They're buying an insurance against the regret of not doing everything possible and losing anyway. So what if the other kid used the supplement or the other family used the supplement? We didn't is a much stronger driver than this will definitely help.
28:50So if we see others using it, we see that the show, it feeds upon itself. Almost fear-based marketing. Don't let your competition out-prep you. outperforms the benefits of just normal, here's what's in our product, here's why it works, here's the biological explanation. It's much more driven by watching somebody else feed it, almost fear-driven. Wow, they're feeding it and they did better than we did today. It has to be that. No, it probably comes back to genetics, daily management, and actual nutrition. But that's, for some reason, a concept that we're not absorbing into our mind and looking at it in that manner.
29:36And he's right. And I love to tell this story. And I've probably told it. I know I've told it on the podcast here before. But it's really good at this particular topic. So many, many years ago, we were at the State Fair of Texas, in fact. And had a steer, and it was the first time that I had brokered a steer that won Dallas. And anyway, we were there all week. Steer wins the show. Yay. We're excited. We're pumped. All this other stuff. So there had been a guy that was stalled, not stalled with us, but stalled around us all week.
30:00 A steer that won on feed, water
30:20He never said anything. He just always watched everything. And I watch people when they feed. So, I mean, I didn't think anything of it. So he comes up after the show and tells us congratulations. I said, thank you. I appreciate it. And all this other stuff. And he says, so, and you could just tell that this conversation was going to take a weird turn. I said, so I want to know where you're hiding all the stuff. I said, excuse me? he says where are you hiding everything I said I guess I don't know what you're talking about sir he says I've watched you since y'all pulled in and unloaded all week I've watched every single time that you have watered that calf fed that calf all you have done is put water and feed in front of that calf all week I said uh huh he says I want to know where the secret stuff is I want to know what made him win where are you hiding all the stuff I was like we're not hiding anything.
31:24Our show box has been open all week. You can look in it. And this guy got mad because he thought I was just lying to him. And that particular calf was such a standout animal. He didn't need anything but feeding water. That's all he needed. And this man literally, almost to the point of getting violent, was just convinced I was lying to him and that we had been hiding secret things that we had been feeding the steer all week, and that's why he won. I've heard you tell that story, and that is real. And sometimes they're not going to come up and make those comments, but in their mind, they're thinking, well, when are they giving those supplements or how is this possible?
32:10They just won without it. Let's flip it the other way, where somebody is giving supplements and they do go out there and win. Maybe because the supplements helped, maybe because it was just a damn good animal, but show families are tight, visible. We have a very visible peer network. And if the winning family in that barn is using product X, everyone else infers that animal won in part because of product X being used. And nobody wants to be the family whose kid doesn't have every advantage. And if that product X is giving us an advantage, even though it is $185 for a little bitty five pound pail of it, we're going to use that because we're already invested at this level. We're not going to stop now. And it just continues and continues to feed upon itself. A product endorsed by a well-known judge, a breeder, an insider, influencer, borrows, I mean, that gives credibility that's earned because of that person getting behind it.
33:14And that's fine. And if that person believes in it and they've used that product, hopefully it's taking you down a good path. But we very rarely have a supplement that says, okay, we've tested this on X many animals under a controlled environment to truly decide if it makes these changes we're claiming. And Ryan said it earlier, if it tells you it can do everything, we're going down a path that's not possible to begin with, period. And then if that supplement works similar and it's a feed, an ingested supplement, if it's going to work similar in a monogastric and a ruminant, these are two totally different digestive systems. Supplements are not universally going to act the same in a ruminant as they would a monogastric. Think about a pig as a monogastric. They have a very similar digestive system to ours. So those of you in the pig world, Mr. Fugate, listen up.
33:45 Ruminants versus monogastrics
34:12I've given you this speech many times. If you want to know what purpose this supplement serves or to truly find supplements that may work, go to the human side. Look at some of the research. There's a little more on the human side, but it's wide open as well. And why would we take that? how is it working in our body? How are we digesting that? Is it an available source of amino acids that we can actually pull under our body? I talk about not looking at crude protein on feed bags. Crude protein is an accumulation of all the amino acids and they're added together. But if they're very weighted on one or two amino acids and limiting on others, the ones that are weighted are going to get pissed out. They're not going to be used because we have to have a balance. Whatever that weakest link is, everything else drops down to. So we've got to be careful of those things. And it weighs on me a little bit because we don't stop and think, okay, why are we using this supplement? What are we trying to do? And how is that actually working in the body? How is it doing that? I always go back and I hope it's not even on the
35:27market anymore because I don't want to get anybody in trouble. But there was a product in the swine world that would supposedly clean up the jowl without taking fat off the rest of the body. And these things just aren't possible. They're not physically possible. I know we have some things in the cattle business and we have fed some to try to clean the front ends up on some females. And it will. And it basically does it in a reverse manner, some of them, where we bump the amino acids so high in one area that we're throwing things out of whack and we're burning fat to excrete the extra amino acids, if that makes any sense whatsoever. When we have an excess, it takes energy to get those out of our system because we can't absorb that much of it.
36:14And if it takes energy, we're burning fat on that animal and we're cleaning them up, but fat's not just going to come off of one part of the body. It may come off faster in one area than others, but it's not going to be just one specific area. So we have to be smart about it. It's a complex situation. You're not going to get away from it. You're going to find those supplements that work for you, and there's nothing wrong with that, and there's always going to be a situation, for me anyway, even if I look at what the ingredients are, I'm going to question those things more than most. And that's probably not a good situation either because over the years, we have not used some supplements that I think probably did serve a purpose.
36:45 Basic nutrients and supplement misuse
36:57I did not because either the ingredients weren't listed or I didn't take the time to truly read it to think, well, hey, there might be a true advantage here. I tend to shy away from it quicker than not. So I'm guilty of it as well. But if we break things down and we talk about the basic nutrients, and I'm going to stay very brief here. Water, cellular function. We obviously have to put water into them. And there was a time across species, Ryan, that I remember we would pull water fairly hard going into a show because we wanted to get the bellies off. As soon as we pulled water to get the belly off, and it would take some off, we're pulling water out of the muscle.
37:40and muscle is 80% water. So we're losing muscle mass every time we pull water. By today's standards, there's not very many species that I wouldn't tell you that I want to push water, push, push, push. If we're allowed to drench the sheep and goats at the show, I'm going to drench excess water into them more than they would normally drink to make sure we get what I call super hydration, that that muscle is as fully hydrated as we can possibly get to. So on a science level, without water, nothing happens. There's no cellular function. So that's easy. We have to have that in there. Carbohydrates, that would be our energy in the feed.
38:21In cattle, sheep, goats, pigs, primarily corn up here in the Midwest is a high energy carbohydrate that we're going to use. Makes perfect sense. If there's carbs in the diet, they're getting energy. They can put on weight. protein is nothing more than amino acids, but realize there's a huge variation in available proteins, biologically available proteins. I tell people the egg that you can go buy at your grocery store is going to get you a very high quality protein at a very, very low cost. You can go buy the human amino acid supplements, individual amino acids, but remember, you've got to keep it balanced. You've got to go across the board. Don't just throw a bunch of lysine at them.
39:06Before I understood things well, I threw handfuls of synthetic lysine at some of my nephew's showpigs, Cades actually. And I mean, we leaned them up because we had to burn so much fat to get it out of the system. We had one of them that I had on such high levels, the darn thing, and that couldn't see out of one eye or maybe both of them because we're so out of whack. So protein is amino acids, but remember, there's a lot of differences there. Minerals and vitamins, we have to have them at a minimal level. But be careful on the mineral side that if we go too high, we can run into toxicities. So there is one thing that most show feeds and for sure commercial feeds are very balanced in all of these nutrients and particularly minerals and vitamins.
39:51And they know that window, what we need without going too high. But as soon as we start putting more supplements in, we're throwing that out of whack. We're throwing the amino acid balance out of whack. And the last one we can talk about is fat. And we hear that in the diet all the time. Well, we want a higher percent fat because we want to put fat on the animal. It's the most energy-dense nutrient, no question. You could feed a pound of fat that has more energy and more capability of putting fat or excess energy into the animal. And think of it this way. When we are feeding an animal, it has to meet its maintenance requirements first. That would be heartbeat, breathing, minimal movement to get feed and water, basically life function.
40:32and then we're going to go into any physical activity. I shouldn't say physical activity for growth purposes. If it's an animal that is still growing, we're going to go there next. And the very last thing you could have exercise in there, you can have all these other things, but we have to meet all of those requirements and go beyond those requirements in terms of the energy that animal's taking in. And then excess energy can be stored as fat. And that's just how it works. There's no other way around it. We can't store fat while an animal is still growing really well without going off the charts on what that energy intake is. And we can get an animal, if we bump that fat up in that animal's ration too high, the brain signals to the animal, hey, this is very energy dense.
41:21We don't need to eat very much. We can actually go backwards. So find that balance. And more times than not, we can get more energy in them through carbohydrates because of increased intake than we can exceeding normal levels of fat that the animal's able to process. So it goes a lot of different directions. And Ryan, this is good. I hope we don't get too much hate mail for this. I hope you don't get bombarded. I don't check mine maybe or see it as much. So that works for me. Yeah, and I mean, again, I'm going to say we use supplement. I've tried lots of supplement before, and we use them every day.
42:03I think the big key things that I wanted to put out here on this is, number one, you can't feed as much supplement as you do feed. It just doesn't work. Number two, there is no cure-all supplement that's going to make everything better. Number three, I will stand by this. the supplements that are targeted that specifically are there to enhance or to make better very specific things. I do think those work because there's more biological or whatever Dale wants to say and behind that like he's like when he refers to the products that try to take chest out of heifers and steers. Yes, they work. Do they take fat out of everywhere yes but those things do help some so think about it that way uh but again we use them i think they're beneficial i do think that just because the grand champion goat at kansas city was on xyz does not mean that your goat needs to be on xyz
43:25and just because that sheep needs to be improved in this one area does not mean you need to feed the other 12 sheep in your barn that same supplement. That is where I think we get really mixed up in terms of the supplement stuff. And some of those winning, Ryan, they're maybe using some supplements for a specific purpose that truly does work for that animal. You mentioned earlier that we don't... We're not using them at all. Yes, and we don't want to use the same supplement on every animal. And that's the disappointing part is we see somebody do it, so we use it rather than understanding what the purpose actually is.
44:14And here's the narrative gap in terms of the science behind some of this. Livestock supplement claims are almost never backed by what I call peer-reviewed, species-specific, dose-controlled trials. And we have to have multiple numbers. It just isn't going to happen. That's not being done. I'm not saying ever, but very rarely. I reflect onto the dairy industry if I want to see a supplement that is being, if there's a supplement or something being used in the dairy world, I will look at it much more closely because the dairy people can feed something and their results are almost instant in terms of their milk production. They can measure those things and they're not going to feed something.
44:56The margins are tight enough that doesn't give back. So if there's something there, I will look at it because here's actual results behind it that can be measured. So the regulatory bar for supplements, there really isn't one compared to other products such as drugs that we take or medications. Those have to be tried, true, tested in a situation that they're peer-reviewed and they have statistically significant numbers to prove this is doing something. We don't have that situation in the supplement world. So it's a big gap there. And parents aren't being irrational for reaching for something in this realm. They're responding sensibly to a lack of real information. It's the best way I can put it. Just with the wrong signal, when you think about price as a signal, driving you to think that must be good instead of the right mode of action or actual dosage or the actual ingredients or visiting with a nutritional consultant that can break that supplement down and say, well, I don't think it's going to harm you, but that $100 a bucket really isn't going to do anything for you. The next product you bring to that nutrition consultant, yep, it looks like
46:09we have very biologically available amino acids. It looks great from a lysine perspective. We're probably bringing X, Y, and Z amino acids up a little bit. So our levels of absorption should be a little higher. If we're working that animal, we're probably going to build a little more muscle because we have the available amino acids to do it. So there are some reasons for using many, many supplements. So we have to think about that. What I think families should be asking, what is the active ingredient and how much should I be feeding according to this animal size or stage of maturity or even more so, what do I want to accomplish with this supplement? If you can't tell me exactly what we're trying to accomplish and how it's doing it, I don't think you need to be feeding it. Has this supplement been tested in species-specific situations or do we just blanket throw it out there. It works across livestock broadly. I have a big problem there between ruminants and monogastrics and some of the supplements responding that way. In general, we put a high quality protein in a ruminant, in a steer, that rumen, the microbes in the rumen are
46:30 Questions to ask before buying
47:23going to destroy those, break down those amino acid chains where they're no longer biologically available as it goes into the further digestive tract. So be smart about that. what's the mechanism supposed to be? Not just the marketing language. In other words, does it increase energy? Does it give us more vitamins and minerals? Is it dense in fat so we can get more energy, more calories and a smaller amount of feed? Think about those things and where we're at. If a nutritionist can't break it down and explain it, it's hard to really justify it.
48:03I had a good friend, a college roommate that went on and received his PhD in monogastric nutrition, swine nutrition, working with one of the lead science-based companies in our industry, more on the commercial side, but also in the show world. And I kept in contact with this person. and when I would come to him with a feed ration or a supplement that I was trying to do, he would look at it and just shake his head that, wow, you're pushing the limits on almost everything. That doesn't seem logical and then I'd have to present it to him that I'm not as worried about cost, but I want to maximize amino acid intake or amino acid absorption, or I want to maximize the amount of calories I can physically get into this animal.
48:52he'd take a step back and say, yeah, you're probably getting that. But he would come back and say, you're still just wasting money. It's not logical. So there's a lot of things to kind of look at and try to sort through. It's not easy. And I don't expect it to be easy because everybody's not getting their PhD in nutrition. Everybody's getting fed different signals, price point signals. The family next to us fed it. They won. There's a lot of things pushing human nature and the human psyche in a direction that we want to follow the crowd. Maybe it goes to that. Let's not be a sheep that just automatically jumps off the cliff. Let's be that sheep that stops and looks over the cliff and think, what is the possibly positive outcome of this?
49:37And I think we can think through those. So this isn't, I'm not trying to shame families for spending money buying supplements to give their kids an edge. We want to do everything we can for our kids. It's more so pointing at the things, the questions you need to ask and look at real information instead of a price point. I talked about it. We use a price point in our exotic cat operation. If a Justin Beaver is looking to buy one of these exotic cats, I can assure you that his personal assistant ends up landing on us for, in part, we're the most expensive. If it's the most expensive, they must be the best. Same thing in the supplement world.
50:17There is a price point on those. The feed companies will tell you, we make a very small margin on feed. We make a huge margin on supplement and it's self-promoting for them. The higher they make that price, the signal to those people buying it, gosh, dang, this is expensive. It must work. Be careful with that because I'm not going to go down that path. I understand how it works, but I'm not going to go down that path. remember genetics, balanced nutrition, and I use the word balance in a very strong way that we want to keep everything in check and a good daily management plan. Hair, skin work. I mean, there's a lot of things that we can use on the hair and skin, and I will call it supplements, if you want, that are phenomenal. And again, use what works for you, but be smart about it.
51:09Don't just blindly do things. One last deal, because this is getting long, and I knew Dale would get long on this topic when I brought it up. But anyway, just because you go on your phone on Facebook and see that the grand champion something supposedly was on this, I'm going to say this. I cannot tell you the number of times that I have gone up to somebody and said, hey, you really fed that animal this? No, Ryan, we didn't feed that one that, but we bought that supplement.
51:49And so I'm assuming because we bought it before, they're just using that KF because we have purchased that supplement and used it before, but it was not on this one. And I'm not shaming the companies for doing that because every time that family that I've asked that, that family says, yes, we have purchased that product. But more times than not, and when I mean more times than not, I'm talking like 90% of the time, they told me that that animal that's standing at the backdrop that's in that advertisement was never fed that supplement. So just think about that every once in a while. I agree. And we're kind of beaten up on things, But hopefully you understand that the point is, let's just use some logic.
52:38Let's follow science to some degree, not the Dr. Fauci degree, by any means, the fake science. But there are principles that apply that we can use to help guide us through the supplement world. And there are more supplements coming out every year. And the reason there are more is that's where the profit margin is. And I'm not, I love entrepreneurs. I think it's great to get out there and make money. Please, supplement people. Keep doing what you're doing. If I could give you some advice, put a little bit of science and thought into it that it's going to make a difference in how that animal actually feeds from a practical or a basic animal nutrition biological standpoint.
53:24That's a lot, right? Uh-huh. Well, before we get into question and answer, we have a couple sponsors I would like to acknowledge. To start with, we have a sponsor this week, again, from north of the border. I would like to welcome Ty D. Livestock from Alberta, Canada, as a sponsor. When Ty reached out, I took the opportunity to check out their cattle on Facebook and social media. Functional, real-world cattle that has some show ring appeal. My kind. No question. tidy livestock is hosting a backdrop online female sale on dlms farmgate the sale opens october 9th closes october 10th the sale features percentage scimitol females genetic opportunities along with a few steers the cattle are show broke ring ready like them on facebook tidy livestock annual bull sale the end of february i would also like to welcome back our longtime sponsor merc animal health. Anyone in our industry knows that effectively managing your time and hitting breeding windows are crucial to success. SenseHub CowCalf for Merck Animal Health gives you the ability to improve on both. With 24-7 monitoring, SenseHub CowCalf helps save time spent on visual
54:38checks and delivers data you can use to detect heat and make informed decisions on reproduction and timing for AI and embryo transfer. This changes everything. Learn more at sensehub-cowcalf.com. Question and answer. Hi, Dale and Ryan. Love the podcast. I need this question to be anonymous. I didn't read the name, did I? I did well there. Attaboy. I'm going to have to paraphrase. This is a very long one. so from a coach's perspective why do you always pick the questions that are novel it was the very first one that was on facebook messenger when i when i pulled it up just before we started recording and i didn't dig through the others i may have been running a little late because you have us recording at 6 a.m today so how do you this is coming from a livestock judging team coach's perspective, I believe. How do you balance making a livestock judging experience fun for the 4-H member while also instilling the work ethic preparation needed to compete at the national level? That's a good question. I can tell you early on in my coaching career, I worked day and
54:45 Q&A: fun versus preparation on judging teams
55:54night and pushed those kids so hard, it probably became self-defeating. Later on, we were finding ourselves taking an hour or two nap the day before the contest to make sure we're caught up on the sleep we didn't get from driving all night and all those things. But the question is much longer than that. We recently had the opportunity to take a small county judging team to a national contest. And in essence, they were preparing hard at home, preparing en route. And then we had some parents say, hey, we need to give them the 4-H experience of going and doing fun things. And the coach is thinking we need to stay focused. We're trying to win a national contest. I would rather make sure we're fully prepared than go to Churchill Downs or wherever they're at. I don't even know where they're at. And there's a little bit of controversy between the coaches and maybe the 4-H parents. So their question is how do experienced coaches motivate kids to take ownership of the preparation where they're good with just focusing on the job at hand?
56:56what point do you let them decide that, hey, we're prepared enough, we can go do some other things? I can go back and answer this part, and then I want Ryan to totally cut loose on it. I don't know that there was a coach out there that pushed any harder than what I tried to push some of those students. But after the fact, some of these students we would travel to as many places across the country. We had a very lucrative budget where I was coaching. so we would go to cow palace we go to los angeles county fair we we'd make sure to hit some of these places and in preparation and prior to the contest very focused very serious after the contest i would take i know it when we're at phoenix and at los angeles i would take that judging team i shouldn't even say this people are gonna think i'm crazy we would go to tijuana to show them the other side of the border. Give them that life experience. We'd go to Nogales when we're at Houston or Phoenix. We'd cross the border. Give them some life experience. We'd go to Galveston and go fishing for drum. Do anything in that area that might be kind of unique that maybe they would
58:06not experience again, but we would do it after the fact. Ryan, I know where you're at on this, so unload. Y'all aren't going to like my answer. I'm going to like your answer. I'm fine. I did not do judging until senior college. Just to sum this up. So one year. So all I know is our experience or my experience. We talked reasons every night. We worked out multiple times. We went to, and this was in college. We talked reasons every night. We went to multiple facilities during the week. when we were on the road after the contest was over and normally back then the results were the next day next morning we got to go to a bar now the night of the contest before the awards banquet right after the contest before the awards banquet we got to go to a bar I mean we were all 21 and that was it there were no field trips.
59:17There were none of that. Now, I will say after we won Louisville, Skaggs took my team to, I think, Churchill's Downs and all this other stuff. I literally left the banquet, stripped off my clothes in the car across the street and went to show semis. So I didn't do any of that, but they did. This all, oh, well, we need to go to Six Flags. If you're there to win, you can schedule an extra day after the contest is over to go to Six Flags or go get you a Louisville Slugger baseball bat, all this other stuff. If that's what you're worried about, that before the contest is, what are we doing to have fun?
1:00:00 Q&A: longer hair on wether goats
1:00:02You're not going to win anyway. Because there are going to be teams that aren't. Yeah, there's going to be teams that do not care if they go to anything other than to that awards banquet and walk up to the front and claim the ultimate title. And so if this is your mindset, you're not going to win anyway. Next. Next question comes from Jonathan. I appreciate all you guys do for the junior livestock industry. I just returned from the Exarbon Livestock Show. I just came back from Exarbon. I was there. I stay to my little corner most of the time. Maybe one day I'll get to go. And I noticed wether goats are shown in much longer hair than I've ever seen in the past.
1:00:46When did this happen and why is it happening? You've seen it, Ryan. I'm sure the shows you're judging. No, I mean, yeah, it's happening. And I guess Exarbon doesn't have a hair roll? Nope. Not that I'm aware of. It didn't. I mean, if they have one, we darn sure weren't. Nobody was paying attention to it. I don't think they have. Well, I mean, I'm assuming, well, I don't know why I assume with you because you don't read. I did not read. I did not. We were not personally showing there. That's in my defense. But you wouldn't have read them anyway. But no, and we just had somebody. I've had several people ask me because, you know, the hogs have gone to all this hair and kind of clip on them like stairs and all this other stuff.
1:01:26I've had several people ask me, do you think that's where the goats are headed? Because they show the does like that already. I really don't think so. I could be wrong, but I don't think so. But I do think that where we're going in the GOAT deal, where we're leaving it a little bit longer and we're clipping it tighter and blending things and all this other stuff, instead of just taking a guard and from the hock up, you know, slicking them off. I think it's cool. I think it's great. you're in the wrong state to be promoting that i i realized that i know you weren't you didn't let me finish i said i don't think texas will ever come around to this way of thinking but i go back to and again you got to take texas out of this because we even slick sure our stairs but I go back to this.
1:02:22I can't ever think of a rule at a haired cattle show that told you how you could clip or how much you could leave on or how much you could take off or any of this other stuff. Is there rules about fitting and painting and all that other stuff? Absolutely. But not about the clipping part. And so I don't understand why we have rules about the other animals. Let them clip them to the best of their ability and let them blend things and whatever. I mean, if the judge doesn't like, I can use me. You bring one in that's twined, I'm going to get pissed off and I'm going to tell you it sucks and I don't like it.
1:03:05And I have never beat one because it has been twined. But I promise you, if I am ever in a situation where it is close and one is twined and one is not, I am going to use the one that is not twined. And so from a judging perspective, there's been a lot of times that I've seen cattle that I don't like the way they're clipped. Does it affect their placing? Yes. That can happen in the goats. That can happen in the pigs. That can happen in the sheep. I'm all for this. I think it's great. I think you should let them clip them and do whatever they want to them to make that animal look the best.
1:03:45So, yeah, I'm all for it. No, and I think where there's not rules in place that regulate how they're clipped, and I like your analogy, Ryan, that in the steer show or the cattle shows, there's rules on whether we can put fake hair on, paint, all those things, but there is nothing that says, here's how you have to clip them. Exactly. And shockingly, most of them are going in kind of the same direction because that's what's most appealing to the judge. So if you don't have a hair rule in the books and you have them too long-haired and the judge doesn't like that, you're not going to get along. And guess what? You will adjust to what the current judges want to see or you're not going to get along.
1:04:30And let that dictate. That's a lot easier than trying to enforce all these rules because it's a mess. It's difficult. I don't know that we need as much hair on the weather as what we see on does. I don't know that they need to be shorn with cover coats or fines or whatever. I think we're probably going to land somewhere in between. And we always think where we're at currently is where it should be. And that's kind of where we are. We're leaving a little bit longer, but we're actually taking it tighter in their chest. We're taking their tops down tighter. Just as Ryan mentioned, kind of like a steer or heifer, we're blending things to make them look the best they can.
1:05:07Does that require somebody that can clip a little better? Yeah, it does. But that's all part of it. We're trying to advance and make that animal look as best possible. And I'm telling you, some of these goats, if we can leave a little hair here or there, it's going to enhance their show ring appeal, period. Now, if a judge comes in there, they're not comfortable with the extra hair. They haven't judged a show that way. It may bite you right in the ass. But the trend outside of Texas, especially in this part of the country, I mean, they're just flat out leaving more hair, period. It takes away from that muscular expression. And I'm kind of an old school.
1:05:48I like to see muscle expression. I think a lot of our judges now aren't as concerned about that as they are just width and volume. So we don't need to see each muscle crease. And in general, when we see that, those animals are pretty lean. If they're pretty lean, they're probably not blending as smooth because we don't have the fat. Fat smooths everything out, makes transitions much, much better. So we can use the lamb show ring. There's fat now maybe as they've ever been, but they look round bodied and they look damn sure smooth enough. And the showmen are able to get them things stuck. The feeders are able to feed them. So they still have what I call an acceptable touch that you don't call them as fat as what they'd actually open up.
1:06:30So yeah, this is good. I think you're going to see it. there's going to be shows that implement different lengths of hair. So stop and read the rules. I do not, but you need to do so. Don't follow my lead and not read it, but read the rules and know where you can be because you don't want to get yourself on the wrong side of that and not be able to show. The final question comes from Kate. I noticed that you two will be doing a live broadcast at the Arizona National. Ryan, the date of that? December 29th, 5 p.m. Swine Arena, as long as the Swine Show is over for the day. And I don't know what's going on in the cattle, goat, and sheep barns.
1:07:12Hopefully there's not a lot going on at 5 p.m. I'm going to say that I did contact Arizona National and I asked them for the time that would be best, that everybody would have the greatest chance to participate in this and they came up with 5 p.m. Thank you Arizona National for assisting me on that because they know their schedule and when things get done way better than Dale or Haidt. Agreed. So the question is, will you guys be available for pictures or autographs before or after recording? I plan on going before to do all that because I'm assuming that the recording is going to be an hour to an hour and a half.
1:07:57That's going to put me at 6.30, and I got to judge very early in the next morning. So I will be jetting out as soon as it's over. But he will stay around. I will make sure he sticks around to get some selfies, to give some autographs. I'm going to be there like an hour early to try to do all that. But maybe they're still turning in wait cards or something. You don't know. We are going to have to do them before. OK, Chase, Chase is going to be there, I believe. He can go out of the audience with the microphone. There's there's our person to get the questions. so it'll be good I hope it'll be good and yes that I will make sure Ryan State is there early he can stay until 10 11 that night no I cannot I have to judge so anyway I will be my plan is to be there by 4 and y'all can picture and autograph and whatever you want all before I would if you want those things I would really appreciate it if we could do it before because as I said I do have to judge the next morning.
1:09:00I'm not saying that I'm going to have a bouncer, you know, throwing small kids over the aisle on the way out. But if possible, I would like to do it before. Fair enough. I look forward to that. That'll be good. We haven't done a live broadcast in a very long time. And thank you, Arizona National, for accommodating such. With that said, this is a good, this is, I've enjoyed this morning, even though it's 6 a.m. and there's a lot of things on my plate to get done this morning, but this was enjoyable, Ryan. This was a good topic. Thank you. Yay, me. Until next week, be safe. Y'all come back now, you hear? Thank you.
Enjoying the show? A quick rating helps new listeners find it.