Dale and Ryan discuss genetic diversity or the lack thereof.
Episode overview
Dale and Ryan take up the concern that heavy use of a few popular sires, artificial insemination and embryo transfer is narrowing the gene pool in show animals. Their position is that the worry is more serious in commercial production than in the show industry, where inbreeding coefficients are unlikely to reach levels that hurt fertility or growth, and where hot sires eventually fade as trends change. They note that selection pressure can reshape animals even from a limited genetic base, that the same sire produces both standouts and poor ones (the poor ones just are not promoted), and that new sire options keep appearing. They discuss genetic defects, using the spider gene in sheep as an example of a problem that was identified and worked through, and the loss of true purebred diversity in swine and sheep. Listener questions cover the history of livestock shows, why shows became youth-focused, slick-shearing leg wool on sheep, and structure and muscle in show cattle.
Sponsors in this episode
Key takeaways
- A small group of popular sires does not by itself signal an inbreeding problem; the risk depends on whether the inbreeding coefficient climbs high enough to reduce fertility or growth.
- Judge a sire by the whole set of offspring, not only the ones promoted online, because the same sire also produces average and poor animals.
- Selection pressure on a limited genetic base can still change how animals look, so breeders keep room to move toward a new type.
- Use genetic testing and open reporting to identify defects early; heavy use of a carrier sire exposes a problem faster and it can then be bred around.
- Outcrossing half of a lined-up program and returning to the home herd can open up a program without losing its consistency.
- If show officials dislike an advantage such as leg wool, hiring judges who can see through it addresses the issue better than rule changes that penalize exhibitors for hard work.
Chapters
Read the transcript
0:00 Opening: news and current events
0:00Welcome to Beyond the Ring, a podcast that covers all things in the stock show industry from the informative to the insane, starring Ryan Rash. The world needs a hero. So now I have to have a costume change. And Dale Hummel. Your problem, your animals, your decision. Now on with the show. Welcome to Beyond the Ring. This is Dale Hummel, along with co-star Ryan Rash.
0:41Hello, hello, hello. How about you start us off with current events today? I don't have any. I do. I do. Imagine that. It's going to be about, I'm not going to call them aliens. I'm not going to call them UAPs. I'm going to just call it something that we do not understand. something that fly with impunity through our restricted airspace. Our government is aware of it. I don't believe they can do anything about it, or to my knowledge, they cannot. So it's no longer a question, are UAPs real? But rather, who built them? Who's flying them? How long has the government been aware? How long have they been on this planet?
1:23The technology is clearly beyond what we have, including China and Russia's technology. These things are an absolute at this point. We're no longer questioning that. I'm not saying it's from another planet. I'm not saying anything other than there is a situation where there are craft that we cannot explain from a physics standpoint in restricted airspace, period. Right now, Congress has requested 46 videos be released from the Pentagon that will add to this database. And at this point, I don't need any more. It's there. I don't think the average person walking around is aware that the government has, for the most part, announced that there is something that they're unaware of.
2:07And I don't know if they're lying. Maybe they sit down and had negotiations. I have no idea. But I can assure you there is something there. There have been even presidents that haven't been briefed in this. There's certain segments of the government that are holding tight to this information for whatever reason that certain presidents, I think, were aware, maybe chose not to be briefed on it. So if they asked a question, they didn't have to lie about it. So my question is, what will it take to prove to the masses that something's there, Ryan? How do we prove it to, not you, I think you're kind of there. I think Klifton's probably there. How do you prove to the average person walking around that there's something going on?
2:50What will it take? Video? I think we have that. We have it not only video, but we have it from our military and radar video. We have all of those things. Maybe not that. I don't know that you'd believe a cell phone video that you'd assume it's AI or something like that. The government has never released a video of an alien, sir. Not of an alien. of the craft and what the crafts, how they're moving. They have, yes. So maybe we just bring a craft, if we have anything like that, and just set it out for public viewing. That'd do it. Then they'd say it's fake. I don't know. At this point, I think there are people out there that no matter what you present to them, they aren't going to believe it.
3:33And that's fine. I'd rather have that than mass hysteria. Wonderful. I don't think you're worried about these crafts invading our restricted space. I'm going to tell you again, like I've been telling you, I'm not saying they're not there, but they ain't screwing with us. So why do you care so much? If I was an alien and I looked down at planet Earth and saw what all these people do, I would fly by so fast and be like, I'm getting the hell out of here. I think they've been here or been back and forth for a long time. And if you think about it, if they've been here for thousands of years, that explains a lot of our jumps in technology.
4:19There are things that we have discovered, invented, whatever you want to put to it at an accelerated rate that should not be possible. But the pyramids, a lot of other things are explained if there were some other presence assisting with that technology to mankind. on this planet. So I'm not overly concerned about them. I just would like to know the truth. And if they're keeping the truth from us for a good reason, kind of like the moon landing problem, I'm not going to be upset about it, but I think it's time. I did see something pro-Trump. There's not a lot of that right now, so I thought I'd share that.
5:02Fox News had a reporter. Maybe they copied it from another station. I don't know. but there was somebody walking the streets of Venezuela. I believe Caracas, maybe I'm not sure where just talking to random people on the street. And they obviously could edit it. They could do a lot of things. They could go through a hundred people and only put two of them on. There was more than two. Actually, the people they interviewed were genuinely praising Donald Trump for, for saving their country. There you go. And that, that, that news story is not getting out that I'm aware of now. And that's something that probably needs to. If that's as it appears, as face value, that is a great thing.
5:48That those, they say this inflation there is still outrageous. There's a lot of problems still, but at least there's a path that they have hope. That they will have a country back and they can live a normal life. Anything going on in the Iran war? I'm sure a lot. But I believe they fired on some of their allies or their neighbors yesterday. Maybe fired towards our ship. Did we take out a couple ships? I really don't know. I can't even keep up with it. But I do believe that Iran is struggling with that blockade, shutting everything off on them. Well, we intercepted six ships testing the blockade yesterday, I think, is what I remember.
6:30Iranian ships, I assume. so yeah the blockade's still in place we're pretty sure that any any other news like are you driving from texas to maine to judge a show tomorrow or anything like that uh driving to cleveland and then from cleveland to you're driving to cleveland from cleveland texas oh cleveland ohio no then from cleveland to springfield and springfield to kansas and Kansas home. Yeah. My thoughts and spirit canceled their, their airline service and all your flights you had booked on spirit. Now you have to drive. Never been on spirit airlines. Unlike you.
7:11I've taken spirit to Florida at least four or five times. Never. And a good percentage of times they were delayed or canceled. I just think the funny thing is that Elizabeth Warren's getting blamed for spirit airlines closing. I don't know why, and I don't care, but I love it when she gets blamed for something. I saw something about that, but I, like you, do not recall what it was. I think blocking the merger or encouraging blocking a merger. She encouraged, yes, she encouraged blocking the merger, yes. And now she's blaming it on Trump that Spirit failed. Her clap back is that gas prices is what closed down Spirit Airlines.
7:52I am sure it did not help, but the merger would have saved them. And I don't know that they need saving if they can't. All the money that went to the airlines and all the money that goes to big company bailouts from our tax dollars, I am not confident that I'm okay with it. I do not know enough about it, but I don't feel great about it. You know, I just don't know what you're going to do. You're not going to be able to fly anymore, but you'll figure it out. No, I remember Ethiopian Airlines. Oh, that's true. And I do have a round-trip ticket booked on Ethiopian Airlines, trying to book another one. Why? We moved our African trip from late May because the Serengeti is horrendously flooded, and I thought I would be getting stuck in the vehicle nonstop in the mud and the quicksand and everything else.
8:44So we moved it to July, which I'm not a fan of because that's peak season. There'll be too many people there. It'll be like driving through Yellowstone Park, but it'll be fine. And so Chase and I, we looked at Zimbabwe. We have a little window in late May before our sales start that it is, there's no lodging. It's just you take your vehicle, sleep in the vehicle, sleep in a tent, whatever you need to do. And you're right in the middle of the most densely concentrated, large animal viewing, safari-like viewing in Africa. And yeah, trying desperately to get that to work here in the next couple of weeks. But running into some problems with camping sites being available and just vehicles available, it's a little challenge.
9:29But Ethiopian Airlines is the only one that can get me there and back in a reasonable amount of time at a reasonable cost. So don't be picking on some of these lower-cost airlines. Okay. I would like to acknowledge our sponsor, Showfresh H2O. You've heard me talk about the benefits of keeping show stock on water. short of hauling water from home. This is clearly a low-cost option with a huge return. Show Fresh H2O can be purchased at your favorite show supply trailer or at swampfox.com. The next one, some may take offense to, Ryan. The topic. Oh. I don't know. Shallow gene pool.
9:45 Shared sires and the gene pool debate
10:10This has been a hot topic on social media as of recent, and Ryan says it's time to talk about it. Well, no, actually, a young lady in Missouri, I just showed Missouri a couple weeks ago, and she brought this topic to me, and she said that she had messaged you with it, and you replied with the thumbs up, but it never happened. And so she's like, I don't know. And I was like, well, I will bring it back up to you. I do not remember that. I'm just telling you what she said. I may have, and I'm capable of forgetting things. Yeah. But anyway. What would she like us to talk about today? what I just said that shallow gene pool everybody's using the same sires and there's no diversity well if those are the sires that are producing animals that win why would you not use them this is your topic do you like it I like it from a genetic puzzle standpoint and yes and I'm kind of being sarcastic here about this in the beginning but there's no question across the show species that we deal with, goats, sheep, cattle, and hogs, that there has been a very strong movement towards using fewer and fewer sires, increasing use
11:29of AI, and that's been happening for a long time. AI is an artificial insemination, not artificial intelligence. And now embryo transfer in the small ruminants, large ruminant, not in this pig jet. And obviously they have multiple pigs born or used to, maybe not the show pigs nowadays, but they used to have litters of six, seven, eight, nine. Now we're probably less than that, but they're giving birth to multiple pigs. So there has not been a lot of work done on the bureau transfer on that side of it. But what it's the technology combined with, I guess you can say accessibility to the elite, to the ones that have been winning is definitely narrowing the gene pool.
12:13And I have to be careful here because in every animal breeding operation that I've been involved with, I have used inbreeding, lion breeding, however you want to define it, to my advantage in theory. And I think it's worked. So what we have to be careful with saying, well, we're using the same animals. Is that a bad thing? Well, there are situations, genetically speaking, that if we get to an inbreeding coefficient that is reducing fertility, reducing growth rate, reducing some of those things, well, from a production standpoint, a real-world standpoint, those are serious problems.
12:45 Inbreeding, fertility and the show-versus-commercial gap
12:54but I think we could use the club pig industry right now as an example. If you've got a gill that's won a lot or bred right or whatever you want to refer to her as that is very likely of producing extremely valuable offspring, do you think those swine producers are okay if she only has two or three pigs if they're worth a fortune? I think they're fine with it. Are they going to get rid of her because you didn't have a big enough litter? No. No. No. So in that sense, if those two or three pigs still generate X amount of dollars, it works for what they're doing. If you take the show industry and completely separate it from the real world, which, Ryan, you'll make that case every day, correct?
13:43Definitely. There is no connection. If that is the situation, our concerns over the narrower gene pool from an impact on commercial world, then it obviously doesn't happen. So in the commercial world, and I'm not saying it doesn't happen there because we can use the dairy industry as an example, artificial insemination took off in the dairy industry well before the other species that we're talking about. And I believe right now you can trace a lot of the high-end dairy cattle or the high-producing dairy cattle back to two bulls if you go back far enough. So there are issues even in a commercial sense, but I see less of an issue than it seems like a lot of people are making a big deal of it right now within the show stock industry.
14:31If we look at that as its own industry, and I don't like to do that, but as its own industry, we're not to the point where we're going to hit that inbreeding coefficient that's decreasing fertility. If we decrease growth rate, isn't that an advantage anymore or a disadvantage, Ryan? I couldn't be honest with you. Two things on that. Number one, on the breeding side of things in the show industry, the age them back so far, it doesn't matter anyway. And number two, in the market thing, everything is older and slower growing. So I don't see that. So I don't even know that in the breeding show, I think people still want them to grow or they wouldn't back age them.
15:17But I think that cancels it out. That's what I'm saying. It doesn't matter anymore. So I don't know. I mean, I don't think that anybody in the show stock industry wants decreased fertility. but if prices are still high enough on the few that we get, I think it's okay. The pig industry has proved that. Even the rest, I'm sure that the lambs and the goats, we've decreased fertility to a certain degree. So when I go back to the genetic side of it, for us to get to that point where that inbreeding coefficient is truly impacting things, it's going to be difficult to get there. I mean, I've done this in several species, and I'm not saying that I haven't found that threshold, but it takes a lot to get there.
16:03So I think more of the concern is you hear people talking about, well, if all the genetic bases and all the pedigrees are the same, the animals all start looking alike and we have no variation. And there's a lot of people talking about, well, if we don't have a diverse genetic base, we can't make change. Well, in the show industry, I'm sure trends will continue to change. I'm not going to pretend we're going to stay where we're at, even though in the moment, we always believe that we're not going to change, that we've got them just like we want them. It will change. And even with a limited genetic base, selection pressure within that base is going to allow change.
16:43If this was the commercial world and we were narrowed down to just a few sire lines in cattle or sheep or goats or pigs or whatever it is, I would be hugely concerned that we've narrowed that genetic base and what we have to pull from way too much. I'm not as concerned about it in the show ring or the show industry, I should say. I mean, I thought this was a topic that was worth discussion. But my big thing on this is, if you look at the cattle side of the show world, obviously, even using flushing and embryo transfer, artificial insemination, all this other stuff, cattle can have less offspring in a year than any other species.
17:15 Hot sires rise and fade
17:33Do you agree with that? Yeah, the generational turnover is very slow. Correct. Okay. So let's just take that as the example. And I will go to the Showsteer Club Cafe Industry. So there for several years, everything was a heatwave. Even if it wasn't a heatwave, that's what you said was a heatwave. Now there are no heatwaves left. so yes do we get on something where one bull is the hot one that sires all the winners yes but eventually as you said because of trends because of lots of different things that bull will become more and more obsolete or everybody's used him so much they can't use him anymore even though they tried because of the inbreeding coefficients or whatever it doesn't work anymore. And so eventually, the heat waves will die out. I can remember Sugar Ray, Heat Wave.
18:29I can name several of these. And guess what? They aren't used anymore. And at that time, they were used as heavily as what cattle are being used. Right. And Sugar Ray was a long time ago. Long, long time ago. And he was everything. Full throttle, whatever you... I mean, I can name thousands of them. Or not thousands, but several of them in the club calf steer industry that nobody even knows who they are anymore. And so it does eventually change. So am I super concerned about it? No. And because it does eventually change. So why everybody on social media, I thought this young lady brought it up to me is, you know, jumping up and down, huffing and puffing. I'm just going to be honest with you, I think it is what it is and eventually it will correct itself. I don't think that we're ever going to go back to a time where, you know, like take for show cattle breeding industry where you would see a different bull sire, you know, different champion female at all the big shows.
19:47That's probably not going to happen. I mean, look at the Angus industry. There's like For years now, there's been one or two bulls that sire everything that wins. Nobody's complaining over there, unless you don't own those two bulls. I'm sure there's people complaining, but I get the point. I mean, but it corrects itself or that bull or that sire goes out of style or like I said, they can no longer breed to that one because every animal in their herd is out of that one. And so I think this is a bunch of people wanting something to be upset over. That's me. I think it's good that people are discussing it.
20:30And I think in a real world sense, this is an absolute concern. But the show industry has proven to drift from the real world and that it doesn't overlap anymore. Even though I will fight every day to try to make it more real world, at least on the cattle side. I'm very guilty of taking the goats to a point that they're impractical. They do not function on their own. We could turn our show goats from many of the top breeders out in a pasture or wherever and just let them try to survive on their own. And it's not probably going to work out real well without some management from our intervention or more than you'd want to on a commercial sense.
21:10There is a legitimate concern that I can think about and maybe we're seeing it right now. when we continue to use these elite animals and we're using embryo transfer, artificial insemination, IVF, whatever, whatever direction you want to want to say from a reproductive advancement or technology standpoint, that there are more similar genetics. So you're, you're seeing a separation where you have really elite show animals across species. and then you have a mid-range and kind of a bottom there, I think there's more separation there than there used to be.
21:54I'm trying to paint a picture here, Ryan, that wow, the really elite ones are really good and maybe there's more of them, but then we drop quite a bit to that mid-range and we drop again to that next range. And I'm not sure if the lower-end animals, that those breeders aren't accessing some of the genetics that are available or unable to for whatever reason. But there does appear to be, continue to be a lot of separation from the elites down to just the average. I think that's true, but I mean, I don't know what point you're exactly, I mean, I agree with what you're saying that the separation between the very top and then the middle to the bottom and whatever.
22:36They're concerned about that. And I guess I can think of one question that I saw come in. I don't know if I put it in question and answer. They're concerned that the very elite will bring more money than ever online, but then those average ones, nobody wants them because you're having to compete against the elite. So it's more of a pricing structure. Okay. I don't care if nobody could use the same bull twice. That's going to be the same. The very elite are going to cost way more than one. So that's kind of a stupid point to me. but I am also going to interject this. When I have seen great ones out of several bulls and I've seen ones that have been dead last in class out of the same bull.
23:15 Elite versus average, and sire odds
23:26So nobody brings up that point. So I think maybe there's some confusion. You can do this across species. And I mean... The ones... Go ahead. In the market side of things, I say this and I mean this. When I'm looking for steers, I don't care what they're out of because I just want the animal that I want. But in the breeding side of things, all of those things have papers. And so if you trust that the breeders are being truthful in what they are, I'm telling you, on almost every show, you can find an animal. If you go back and look at the results, the animal that won the show, you're going to find one sired by the same thing that was dead ass last.
24:07Maybe a very similar pedigree, even on both sides. Right. So why is that even, that doesn't even make any sense to me. These people are clearly not observant. I can take it a step further. Think about those really popular bulls, boars, rams, bucks that have been deemed elite and they're being used so heavily. So if we have a club calf bull that covers 5,000 cows or flushed to more donors than anybody else, more times than not, we're going to see on social media. We're going to see at the backdrops, the ones that turned out, but you're not going to see the rest.
24:49In statistic analysis alone, or just look at the numbers game. when you breed, you could take a dozen other bulls, not the most popular one, breed them to that many cows, and you're going to come up with some good ones. So more times than not, I'm afraid what's happening is there's hype behind a given animal. That given animal gets bred to more animals, not only more animals. That sire gets bred to some of the most elite females out there. And big shocker, there's some good ones that come out of it. Well, guess what? you could substitute another lower, not as prestigious sire and put him in those same cows and that same number of females.
25:31And guess what? You're still going to get quite a few pretty good ones. Sometimes we forget that. And I think when we're swinging for the fence and we're using those outliers that have the crazy freak pieces, I think we actually are seeing the absolute great ones come out of them. but I think you're probably seeing a higher percentage of them that just don't work because each of those gametes from the female and the male have to come together just right to allow that great one to happen. I think that is the other side of this coin that nobody talks about or is concerned of. And of course, they don't because it's not positive.
26:12But yeah, the more people that use the same sire or the more people that flush the same or female, there's a higher probability for those animals to have great ones. There's also a higher probability for those to have average or bad ones. But nobody talks about the average or bad ones and they don't make it to the pulse that says sired by, out of, all that. But they're still there. And they're still in the show ring. And they're not doing that great. But just because nobody recognized that or talks about it doesn't make it untrue.
26:56And I think that that is part of this. That because it's not brought out, that goes back to my thing. This will all eventually work itself out. because there's just as many bad to average ones getting made by that sire or that female as there are great ones. And that's just the truth. And think about when artificial insemination first came on the scene with cattle, you thought, well, wow, we're going to ramp up so quickly and only use certain sires. At that point, everybody's saying, well, this will ruin things. I mean, it's a continual cycle. and history tells us that we'll work through it.
27:38And at this point, when it's the show industry separated from the commercial world, we can get away with doing some pretty stupid shit in the show industry and with some selection emphasis, even with a limited genetic pool. You can make that shift. I had an Australian gentleman here yesterday looking at a couple cows that we had and just visiting about cattle genetics. And it was interesting. I brought up the topic to him that he's going to be going to Palermo in Argentina this summer. And I explained to him, you're going to see American bulls, some Canadian bulls in the pedigree one or two generations back. And all those cattle that are down there showing in Palermo.
28:19And even further back, and if you look at what they call their Argentine genetics, which all goes back to some American at some point. But if you have a vision of a certain, and I use Angus as an example, that this given Angus bull produces such up here and most of his offspring look a certain way. You go down there, it may be completely different, even though, yes, he was used and that genetic base is in play. But because they've had different selection pressure from that original genetic base, those genetics now are siring something completely different. So even though we have the same genetic base because we have such variation in what gametes actually come together, there's still room for selection pressure.
29:07There's still room to make exact or very similar genetic animals look much differently. And I've been a proponent of line breeding and doing it probably more so than anybody in both companion animals to sort out genetic abnormalities, in the goat world to try to narrow that base where if I continue to line breed to a certain degree, I sort out anything that I don't like and only keep the absolute best to move on. I'm narrowing that genetic pool or that gamete possibility or that gamete window where I'm going to produce a more consistent product. And from a business model standpoint, if I can produce a more consistent product top to bottom, I can sell 100% of those kids as show animals versus the top 20% of show animals and the rest go to the sale bar.
29:59But as we narrow that gamete pool, there's less chances for those outliers that maybe we don't want And as we continue to select and only use those elite ones to continue to breed on, you're doing just that. In a broader sense, in the show world, we're kind of doing that, but not nearly as concentrated because it just takes a lot to get to that point. When I say a lot, we're talking years and generations of narrowing and narrowing and narrowing to get to that point. I don't think we're going to see some of those things. So the genetic diversity side of it, with selection pressure, I think we can still go any direction we want to go. Even if you, all of a sudden, there's five club calf bulls total that anybody can use, 10 years from now, depending on which way we put selection pressure, those cattle could still look different.
30:30 New sire options keep appearing
30:50So I'm with you, Ryan. I'm not overly concerned about that. Well, and then here's another point on this. if this was truly a crisis in my opinion every day when I get on my little phone or phones I should say and scroll through social media or anything like that I see a new club cap bull a new pig sire a new whatever that they're promoting that I've never seen before and so it's not to the point that people are still not that it's gotten so narrow that people are not trying to put options out there now granted most of them probably aren't going to become the next heat wave but they're still keeping those intact mails and promoting them as sire options for the livestock show public and the people that are going to breed and whatever. There's more semen companies and all species out there than ever before.
32:03So clearly those people aren't going out of business. And these people are not putting less options out there for people to consider. So until you stop seeing new sire options out there, then again, I think people are blowing this up a little too much. And from a breeder's perspective in the show livestock world, the tighter genetics, just like I talked about, gives you more predictability in the offspring. And that's a good thing from a breeder's perspective, for sure. And I even think I'm down to the people that are buying those show animals.
32:47When you think about market efficiency or what people are looking at right now, and you can take this either direction, that those popular sires, and Ryan would be the exception to this, but if you have that sire that's done very well in your pedigree and you're selling that animal, there's going to be a segment of the population that are going to be attracted to that animal because of that sire. not you Ryan but it's there it's real right but I'm also saying every year you send me a picture of something of one that you're considering to keep a buck and there are new options out there every single day yes absolutely if people did not think that they could make money off keeping these males intact as a sire option than they wouldn't. They'd cut them and sell them as a market animal.
33:50There's still plenty of options coming out. When we have less and less options on that side being made available, maybe I'll get more concerned, but that is not the case at all. I think they're going to make the argument that a lot of those new options coming out are going back to some of the sires that are very popular. But you're right. But it's not the exact same one. It's a different... Even if there's same genetic base there, it is still a different animal. It's not the same one. Correct. And likely the sire different. Right. Because you can talk to me about all this other stuff.
34:31I don't care what y'all say. You can put the same bull, the same boar, whatever, on the exact same female and one of them may be great and one of them may be terrible. I mean, I have seen too many flushmates, full sibs, whatever you want to call it, that one of them is, and the other one's like, eh. And that goes back to prove those gametes that actually come together from the male and female side, And there's still so much randomness in that and so much variation, even when what we call more tightly bred industry, it's still there.
35:19And your point is exactly right, Brian. And so don't tell me that just because this new sire option is out of the bull that has sired all the winners, but still has a different genetic makeup to some extent, that one can sire great ones or whatever. That's there. I mean, you can look at two clones and cloning is supposed to be, you know, all this stuff. Clones don't even look the same. in terms of a show ring setting for me. And you don't want to go down that path with epigenetics because it would take hours. No, but I'm just saying, but two clones don't even look exactly the same.
36:04We're neglecting in this argument that environment still plays a role every step of the way prior to them being born. Once they hit the ground, all of those things. So there's still going to be some variation there. So I'm with you. And I want to reiterate that we're complaining about inbreeding depression and the coefficient creeping up there on causing fertility problems and growth problems. And I'm not saying it's not possible and you can do that in an individual sense if you really line it up hard for many generations. But in the big picture within the show industry, we're not there. We're not that tight yet. And we would never want to be that tight in a commercial sense. We can probably absorb some of that because some of the negative that comes from That inbreeding depression is actually turned into a positive by today's show standard.
36:45 Genetic defects and the spider gene
36:53So yeah, we've got to be careful with some of those things. Genetic defects. If we happen to have a bull or any sire, I should say, that has a genetic defect that is used that heavily, yeah, that's going to be a problem. But it also allows you to expose that problem more quickly. And I'm going to use an example, the spider gene in sheep. And this runs a course. This was first coming out when I was in college a very long time ago. But so I can, I can, I've witnessed the entire cycle of it. The spider gene allowed sheep to be, I shouldn't say allowed. They came out with extended bone length, particularly their legs. And they couldn't oftentimes stand up.
37:35They're very fragile. It was a problem. Most of those without, it was very difficult to keep a true homozygous spider lamb alive. The University of Illinois did so for research purposes, but it comes out to the fact that at that time in the sheep world, we were selecting for taller sheep, taller, taller, taller frame sheep. And you could just about go into any show and that's just how it was. Nothing else mattered, but shoulder height or hip height, whatever the heck they measure. And the spider gene was indirectly selected for. So we didn't want the homozygous spiders, but guess what? those heterozygous that fall somewhere in between. And I'm sure I'm simplifying this too much and some people are going to be upset about it. But I am confident that those heterozygous carriers were the bigger sheep and the bigger sheep continued to get used. There was a buck by the name of Walking Tall in the Suffolk breed that was a spider carrier. And he got used so heavily.
38:34I mean, it contaminated the breed. It really caused a lot of issues, but it also made sheep bigger. And guess what? It starts in the Suffolk breed and the next thing you know it, you have spider sheep in almost all the breeds because of the crossbreeding that's taking place at that time primarily to make all the breeds taller and bigger. But guess what? Even as bad as the spider gene was, it was able to be identified and we've gotten through it. And Ryan, I'm going to guess that you don't hear anybody talk about it anymore. I studied it in college. And that's the last time you've heard about it, I bet. Yep. It's gone. And that was as big a deal and probably touched as many show sheep as any specific genetic defect in history.
39:20And yet we've gotten through it fine. I'm not saying you want to get into something like that again. Absolutely. There's a lot of genetic defects that have been noticed in the club calf business. Using the THPH free stuff, I mean, there's going to be those battles. But like you said, We've gotten through it. Yeah, and I think we have the technology to identify them. And if you want to steer away from them, you steer away. But guess what? Some of the very best animals out there are those carriers. I'm not saying it's a good thing. I'm just telling you in the show ring, we tend to lean to those creatures that are way out there. And some of those way out there ones may carry some of these problems.
40:03Historically, they have at least. You're not wrong on that at all. And you're talking about in genetic disorders in general. Yeah, that's an issue. But like you said, spider lamb syndrome, all the other ones, as bad as they have been, it hasn't wrecked everything. We've gotten through it. We've persevered, all this other stuff. So while it's a concern, and I'm not saying, I mean, all of this is a concern. But I just keep going back to, I get the concern. I understand the concern. I'm not against talking about it, obviously, because I brought it up to you when the shinglady brought it up to me and all this other stuff. But I guess from my standpoint, I am not as wound up or worked up about it because everything still keeps going and clicking and all this other stuff.
40:59And like I said, eventually the heat waves go away and there's a new one. Now, if you're going to be upset because there aren't 15 hot sires in every species, I'm going to tell you that your panties are just going to have to be in a wad forever. I like it. It's your choice. I don't know what else to tell you. I promise you that there's more than 15 sires available. you don't have, as a breeder, you don't have to go use one of those 15 hot sires. No, but it's 15 hot sires that everybody, you know what I'm saying? Like, I don't know how to get your panties out of wide because I don't think that's ever going to be a thing.
41:42And I can go back to when I was a little kid showing. I don't think there was more than 15 then. No, I don't think this is anything new. I think social media has brought life. Literally, that's what I was getting at. I don't think this is a new concept at all. I just think that this is a new topic for people to talk about. Agreed 100%. And we're maybe taking the other side of it than where most people are. And partially on purpose just to show you the other side of it. And I don't, it doesn't matter to me whether everybody uses the same sire or doesn't use the same sire.
42:23That's their choice. They can do whatever they want. But yeah, there are things that will happen by doing that over a long period of time. But people, unfortunately, we're talking about the show industry and what we're selecting for in our priorities in the show industry does not align with the commercial world. So those real world production issues that you may find if you ever even get to that point of an inbreeding coefficient getting too high, I don't know that it matters in the show industry. And I don't think we're seeing that in such a low percentage that it's not relevant, even though in our mind we're thinking, oh my gosh, these things are too lined up.
43:04I promise you there's nobody out there that's done more line breeding or inbreeding than I have across species, period. And I have a pretty good feel on how far you can go before you've gone over the edge. And it is much further than what any of the textbooks are going to tell you. So it's good. I'm good with this. So I appreciate people talking about it. I'm glad that they're thinking about it and I get it. And if this was happening in the commercial world, I would say this is not good. I do see it happening to a certain degree and I want to bring this out. Let's use the commercial swine industry as an example. Many years ago, all of the hybrid pig companies would go to different purebred bases to build their grandparent stock, their fundamental base genetics.
43:30 Purebred diversity in swine and sheep
43:51and you would pull from the Durocs for a certain thing or Hampshire for a certain thing and all these things. At this point, within the purebred swine industry, we don't have the genetic diversity within the individual breeds that we used to have at all. We don't even hardly have, if we were to try to find truly purebred Berkshires in the show world or Tamworths or whatever you may be, let's use Berkshires because the traditional Berkshire did have a high degree of marbling or their ability to put on marbling was very strong. And that was something that was sought after.
44:32We talked about a Berkshire Gold program, I think, in one of our previous episodes long ago, that you'd get paid a premium for those hogs because they would marble better. And that enhances eating quality. If we were to go and find what we call truly purebred Berkshires now, I'm not saying they don't exist, but they're pretty darn hard to find because we now have animals that are marked like Berkshires, but look like the trendy show hogs. And Ryan is primarily the reason that we have that. He's responsible for all of that. But we'll talk about that later. He will use a Berkshire, a Tamworth, a Hereford that looks like a crossbred and a great crossbred every single day.
45:13If you're wondering what kind of hog to take, that's it. And that's okay. But we've gotten to the point where there is no question in the swine industry, we don't have that genetic base to pull from. And you have fewer hybrid hog companies out there maybe than we ever had before and kind of monopoly on it. And I'm not saying that their geneticists aren't keeping different genetic lines for maternal traits, for terminal traits and all those things. Because they are. And I'm sure they're doing a good job of just that. but all of a sudden we're restricted to basically crossbred hogs that are maternal, crossbred hogs that are terminal. And that's fine.
45:51It almost becomes that line becomes its own breed, even though it may not have distinct color markings that we're used to seeing. But it's forced them to do that because I don't know at this point if we want to grab from the purebred swine base, the seed stock purebred traditional swine base and incorporate it into the commercial world, finding those pieces that they did at one time doesn't exist. Those companies do not share genetics from one to another. So that big hybrid company has to have developed a line for those specific traits and keep those separate and clean so they can pull from them and recreate that, what we call that grandparent stock.
46:34I'm sure that's very confusing, but I'm trying here. So there are situations. I'm not, it's life. The trends keep going. And it is what it is. I think the cattle world with DNA testing, I think they're probably more on track with what's purebred, full blood, whatever you want to call it, more than ever because of the way they're registered. I think the National Swine Registry, and I don't understand it as well as I should when they have their parentage testing or their purity testing, I should say, and they can determine what percent is allowed to be a hamster. You have to be over 80% or 85%. I don't know what the exact numbers are, so please don't take that literally.
47:15I think that's probably a good thing, but it hasn't gone down to the minor breeds that I'm aware of. The sheep world, in the full-blood sheep world, in the show ring, it's a mess. There are no purebreds. I'm positive of that. In the commercial world, I think there's a far larger separation that there are still commercial sheep out there of various breeds, particularly the hair sheep and maybe the texels and some of the other newer breeds that have been used commercially that are truly pure and you can pull from those genetic bases. The frame sheep to commercial overlap, it's been gone for longer than we can imagine.
47:57No question. So I don't know. And I always want to be the first to admit in the goat world, I am making freaks. I'm making creatures that will do very well in the show ring, the hard to make kind. The big featured, big legged, shallow chested, round ribbed, freak necked, big backed, big ended goats that look really cool, but would never function in the real world ever. The only thing they contribute to the real world would be muscle because they are slower growing. We don't eat hair. We don't eat bone. We don't care if they're shallow chested. We don't care if they're freak necked. We don't care if they're cool colored. None of those things matter in the real world, but they would add some muscle.
48:39Because I knew the hypocrite thing was coming from you, by the way. To my point, the commercial industry and the stock show industry have no equivalents. But anyway. And I've got to let that go sometime. I still hold it, you know, in the capital. I still try to make it. You're not the only one. And I'm just like, I mean, you just. Well, just like you said, the little Australian man that was at your house. I mean, he might not have been a little anyway. The Australian man said, I don't understand why y'all don't talk about this, this, this, this, this. And all you talk about is look and whatever. I'm like, dude, didn't pay attention. I talked about that with you personally, right?
49:14Right. Yeah. Okay. So I want to use that example. So this gentleman from Australia is here, and we were talking about the show ring. And he showed me a picture of one of the steers that when he returns to Australia, he'll be showing here in the near future. And this was a beauty. You would call him more of a feedlot calf. I mean, he was muscular. He was fat enough. He did not have a lot of hair on him, but they were going to show him and then they would look at his carcass and get those parameters as well. I'm sure he's going to do very well and he looks like a calf that would make money in the real world every single day. We started talking about a steer show and he was actually competing in some livestock judging contests and is either given or listened to reasons on the cattle side.
50:02And he says, we have market steers here in the U.S. that somebody will be judging a show. We could use Ryan as an example. Or give them a set of reasons, and they're going to talk about how big featured they are. They're going to talk about how structurally correct and sound they are, if they happen to find a sound steer. How long neck they are. What their trendy appearance is. maybe talk about some muscle, but not talk about actual carcass terminology like a bigger ribeye or would likely hit a more desirable quality grade that the true purpose of a market animal is not being discussed. And that blows his mind. And I get it. I'm not arguing that we're going to change and go back to that, but it is very hard for me to accept this is a market animal and we're not even projecting them to the market.
50:50So what you're saying is I probably don't need to judge in Australia Yeah, remember you say the Canadians don't like you? Yeah, they'll like less in Australia. Oh, I think yeah, it just wouldn't work and yet you continue to get shows in Canada People, those in Canada listening I am far more suited to using the kind of cattle you would like than Ryan I should probably not judge the cattle shows in the US and judge more in Canada I'm just saying I've had several people approach me about Australia and it's just never worked out but I have also thought in the back of my mind Canada's closer to the US than the rest of these countries and I know how it works out when I go to Canada I may not make it back across the water at one of these other shows I think you're harder on yourself than Canada than you should be but I know you're not selecting the type they're used to but they know that when you come so it's okay no it's and I tell them every time I get asked to judge in Canada that I will come and I will do this I said but there are going to be more people upset than happy and I just want you to know
51:58that up front because I am not going to change what I'm going to look for and etc and they're like oh we just want you to come I'm like okay and then every time I go up there's some little disgruntled Canadian person has to get in get up in my stuff and I'm just like talk to the people that hired me because guess what? I told them this was going to happen and I'm going next week. You've had those discussions at ringside. Literally. I really need to go next time. They're sorting up there soon, right? Next weekend. Yeah. I really want to go and just observe and be hide among the crowd and just listen to what they're saying about you. I bet the crowd hiding in the crowd and listening to what they say is probably the most entertaining.
52:48Oh, it'd be the best. I get to listen when you're judging here on occasion that I'm at. That's good enough, but Canada would be way better. Way, way better. You had that conversation about that guy or whatever, and I get what he's saying, especially if you live over there, but over here, it's just not a thing. That's just part of it. There's still people that you get troubled by it, and there's a few other people that I I won't mention they get troubled by it, but it hasn't been a thing for a while. And that's just how it is. There's one more example that I wanted to point out to everyone.
53:15 Thoroughbred and dairy lessons
53:29And this, I'm not trying to make a case for or against anything, just giving you some facts. So I had mentioned the thoroughbred industry, I believe, last week or two weeks ago, how I believe the sire has to be on the same farm or there's no AI. and I had gotten several responses. I don't remember exactly what they were, but basically, yes, you can't have in the US, I don't know about other countries, but those thoroughbreds, it's much more difficult. You're not getting that one thoroughbred semen and sending it all over the country to be bred to a bunch of them. Even with that in play, and they did this intentionally to try to keep value on stallions and maybe avoid the narrowing of the genetic base.
54:10But even with that being done, because they're selecting so hard on those few individuals, there's 97% of the thoroughbred pedigrees go back to Northern Dancer. And he was 1961. There you go. That's crazy. So that's with limitations on AI and not embryo transfer that I'm aware of. Even with restrictions in there, it's still going to happen over time, I guess is what I'm getting at. So I don't ever foresee. That's a great example, though. That is a lot. And there's an example, and I don't have it in front of me, so I don't want to quote the numbers.
54:53But in the dairy industry, there's two bulls. If you go back almost to the late 1800s, which I can't imagine they'd have accurate pedigrees all the way back there. They knew how to write then? They did know how to write then. And it's really, I mean, and you go that far back, obviously there's no issues with it. There's other genetics coming into play. But it's amazing to me in the dairy industry, we have a quantitative factor there in terms of milk production that we can actually weigh. It's not a subjective measure. And with that in play, you're going to continue to select for those animals to produce more milk. And consequently, it's amazing to me how those go back to specific sire lines or specific dam lines or genetic lines in general that keep showing up because they're the ones producing more.
55:45And it's not like our world where we're so subjective out in the show ring. It's a measurable unit. And those genetics simply produce more milk, period. And we see the same thing in ours. It's a certain look that certain sires give us that have made them very popular. We're going to continue to use those because as breeders in the show stock industry, you want to use what's going to sell and allow you to be profitable and allow you to stay in the business. I can assure you, we've probably held to using our own bucks and the goat thing more than anybody until recently. And we reached out for some outcrosses to make our own bucks. It would be half our lined up genetics, half outcross, come back on our lined up does and basically three quarter HL, a quarter something else.
56:29and that has proven to be a huge sweet spot for us. And I can't even, and to maybe further a point, I can use a variety of outcrosses, good, bad, popular, not popular. And by the time I make that three quarter lined up kid, it almost didn't matter what that outcross was. It just opens things up a little bit and works. So there's a lot, this was a big day, right, for me. This is good. But anything that you have to add to this prior to going into question and answer? No, I've said my piece. I'm good. So, I mean, I think in summary that the stock show industry is chasing what we consider to be excellence or a trend.
57:12That is a subjective measure and different judges are going to have different opinions. But in general, we tend to go a certain direction. And I don't see that changing. and I don't think it's going to change that those animals that are producing what's winning are going to continue to be used. We're going to continue to move the needle, even though everybody living in the moment right now thinks, wow, this show barrow, that's as good as they get. We're not going to stray from this for years or that show lamb or whatever. We will, maybe not as drastically, maybe not as quickly as history has in the past, but it will happen. So keep an open mind for all those things.
57:45 Listener questions
57:52Question and answer. Andrea, this one kind of goes back to me. Did Dale ever get to do an episode on the history of livestock shows? It was mentioned very early and I can't remember ever hearing that. I'd also love to listen to both of your opinions on the benefits and drawbacks of stock shows moving from primarily only an adult industry to virtually exclusively youth. I don't think I ever did a livestock history one did I the show I'll go back and look but I don't remember I would have to bring Tom Burke out we had Tom Burke we had some history on there so maybe his we talked about more of that it's like in the first five but I love talking about the livestock show history I would give anything to go to Chicago International and just watch a show and to judge in a ring like that with, with that many people there with it had been amazing.
58:55Palermo is the closest that I can confine to that at this point. Okay. So what about the, we we've talked about this before the movement primarily from an adult showing industry open show, I guess I would call it to almost all youth. I mean, there are still open shows, Ryan, you attend some open shows. You're, you're still allowed to go in the ring at some shows, correct? Yeah. Lots of them. jackass. What I'm saying is I'm not engrossed in that. I guess we, I mean, in the full-blood Boer goat world. The full-blood Boer goat deal, there's thousands. I don't go to those. I know you don't. I guess maybe the swine industry, remember we used to have all of those type conferences and so forth.
59:43I'm not sure I'm seeing many adults in that arena. Maybe I'm missing something. No, I mean, I would say it's probably less in the pigs than it is the other, but there's still open shows for pigs, not as many as they're used to. And I think the adults could go in, but I think it's just more youth doing it, is my guess. Any open show an adult can go in. That's why it's called an open show. Correct. I'm saying that even though it's an open show on the swine thing, not many adults are going in. No, and I mean, I don't know about the little limited exposure I've had to like the ABGA, the goat stuff, the full blood stuff.
1:00:28I see a lot of adults. I would still say that it's probably like half and half. I have not had that much exposure to open sheep shows to tell you what the percentage is. I would say in... That's still high. In the frame sheet, I think at Louisville, there's more than youth showing significantly. Right. And I would say in the cattle, it's probably about half. I mean, and to be honest with you, when I say half, now I'm not going to tell you that there's not like the majority of the adults are of the younger deal because they just didn't want to quit.
1:01:09And they have these animals and so they still keep showing them. So when I'm saying, you know, they're probably 20s to 30s. Yeah, but I mean, it is. But I understand what this person is saying, Andrea, that used to be when you went to an open show that it was all adults because I can remember vividly and we had Jim Williams on here several episodes ago. I mean, I don't remember. It was over a year for sure. But he and I talked about that his two daughters and I were like the first kids in the U.S. to actually show in the open shows against the adults.
1:01:53And that's just what it was. And so it has been a drastic change here recently that the kids show more in the open shows than they do adults. But why is that? what is the positivity of it? I think that we realized that as the adults realized that their time in this industry made them better, more successful people, so they wanted to get their kids involved. And so that's why you saw the junior shows take off.
1:02:34And even in the open shows, the juniors out there more. And I think that just sums it up. This is a great place to raise kids in a family environment and teach them a lot of things that other industries don't. And so that's why it's so junior-focused. That's the shortest answer I can give. I love it. And right there, that last statement that Ryan just made, we did not talk about this entire episode. We focused on what type of animal is going to be in the show ring. And you know what? we will all agree that, or Ryan and I will agree that this is about building better adults, building better human beings, and we use animals to do so. That if we keep that focus in mind, I don't know that it matters if all the animals in the ring look the same.
1:03:27It's still, we're still, there's always going to be some variation because of environment, period, no matter how genetically similar they are or anything. And we do need to remember, wow, yeah, there is a situation that's going to be different maybe in what type of animals show, but it's still about building better humans. Excellent answer. Jacob, love the podcast. I'm hearing rumblings about slicking the leg wool off sheep for a Texas major once again. Do you guys have any insight on such? I've heard this a lot again. I mean, it's back out there whether they do it or not. I don't know. I hope they don't. And I'm going to say again, and I was in the middle of this.
1:04:12I don't know what the reasonings are for them doing this in the sheep deal, but I can tell you that when we slick-shared the steers in Texas, they genuinely thought that this was going to change who won everything. And I assure you, it did not. It made those of us that were winning win even more. And so I don't know what the reasons behind this are, but I go back to this. And we've gotten over it in Texas because it is harder to keep skin and hair on a slick-sheared animal looking great than it is to grow hair on a steer.
1:05:00But the people that have the shaggy leg wool and all this other stuff, those people are working at it and they're doing everything they can to get it and they're working hard for it to be more competitive. If that bothers you, I don't understand it. My thing would be is if you don't want leg wool to be an advantage or to be something that's in consideration, how about you use a judge that isn't going to prioritize that feature or can see through it instead of penalizing everybody else for trying to get it that just makes no sense to me this is one of the best answers you've ever given i love it and the fact that you're bringing out and most people would think about that so show officials if you're doing this to try to take away what you believed to be an advantage and allow different people to win more often.
1:06:03It's not going to happen. It isn't going to work. And Ryan just gave you the perfect example on the steer side. What I get angry about is Ryan made the comment to take care of that leg wool and to make it look as good as it does. That takes time. That means those kids are in the barn. They're working harder. They're putting more hours into it. They're learning to be very specific on what needs to be done and following a protocol. All of those things I thought last time I checked people, that's what we're trying to instill. Exactly. That's my point. So what the hell are you thinking by slicking the legs off?
1:06:44Because you believe, and I don't know this, I assume you believe it's going to change who wins. And it's not. And it's not. And then the steer game, when you slick those steers, I'm with Ryan and I have not fed a slick steered shear ever, but I've listened to Ryan and I've observed. I guarantee you by doing that, you've made the gap between the elite feeders and managers and the rest of the world even wider. Oh, there's no doubt. And I'm not saying that's going to happen if you slick the legs off the sheep, but I'm telling you, I can't, I would love, please, listeners out there, show officials, whoever you are, if Ryan and I are missing a good reason for doing that, please tell us because I can't think of it.
1:07:32Would it be easier in some situations if we didn't have great big old shaggy legs to evaluate what that hind leg and that movement and that flexibility is like as a judge? Yeah. I can assure you, and I don't judge a lot of sheep shows, but the few that I do, if those legs are so big that it's even on the move inhibiting how I can evaluate them, I'm not giving them the benefit of the doubt. Period. That's not the point. If the issue is you don't want that to be an advantage, the simple solution is to hire judges that are not going to prioritize it and can see structure and see actual foot size and bone shape through all that instead of doing this other.
1:08:18That's the simple solution. And I don't even know why you, and I agree, and I would prefer that. But even without that, you're still trying to strip away what we're trying to do in the industry by getting kids in the barn more. Yeah, no, that's what I'm saying. Don't do that. Just hire, if this is your issue, then hire somebody that's not going to prioritize. And has Legwell gotten out of hand on a few lambs that I've seen in the ring? Sure. But I'll tell you what, as a judge, like muscle hasn't got out of hand on a few, everything in a ring or as a judge, I discount that it's not when you have legs that huge that are somewhat unkept.
1:09:01I want it to look big legged, but still the natural set to that rear hock in those things. And I understand mine is just one opinion, but I'm, I'm accounting for all of those things as they come in the ring. It's very simple. And I'm just like, because I had this conversation with somebody just a couple weeks ago. And they were like, they just, nobody read structure anymore. I said, I get it. I understand your thing. I said, then you need to hire a different judge. Because if you're telling me that there are no judges out there that can read structure because the leg wool, I said, that's a bunch of bullshit.
1:09:41And when they're with as good a showman as they are and a really good fitter on that leg wall, when they're propped up, yeah it might be hard to read just how they are but as soon as you put them into motion and that top goes up and the pin drops or we're shuffling around the ring, kicking shavings or the hawk is locked, all these other things. Everything. All the indicators were there. Right. So don't tell me that. That's what I told us then y'all aren't hiring the right people because it's bullshit. People can still read structure. They do it every single day in the cattle world. People still talk about structure, place on structure, all this other stuff.
1:10:22And there are animals out there that have way more leg hair than you can ever get on a sheep. And it's glued up. And all this other stuff. So yeah, I ain't buying that bullshit. If disorders that y'all are choosing choose not to read structure, blame them. Not the people and the kids that are working hard to get the shaggy-legged lambs and all this other stuff. I'll be honest with you. We talked about trends on this thing. This has become a trend, and it has. It's here. The only way to change this trend is to hire people that aren't going to prioritize it or can read through it.
1:11:08And y'all all need to sit there and think about that. If this bothers you so damn much. And please reach out and give us. Clearly, people have reasons for pushing this. I want to know what they are. I'd be happy to debate the other side of it because I can't come up with it. I can't find it. I'm clueless. Okay. That one was good. Thank you, Jacob. Drew, what are your thoughts on the show cattle trend, which we keep saying we're going to do a trending episode soon. What are your thoughts on a show cattle trend on the female side becoming better built in some resemblance of muscle shape? I'm not watching enough, but I would say probably going that way.
1:11:54You would be more in tune than I would. I think that they are getting better built, no doubt. I see less structure problems on the cattle side than every year than what I saw the year before. I think the person is living in a tree if he thinks that there's muscle. Maybe people are talking it more. I think the reason they're getting better built is because there's less muscle. Especially on the breeding side of things. Because when you put a less muscular animal out there that should be able to walk better. It's when you get more muscle and more mass that it makes it more difficult to walk.
1:12:39And I am the first person that if you have watched me judge or hear me judge or anything like that, they don't have to be the stoutest for me. And I am getting more and more concerned that on the breeding heifer side of things and cattle, that these things are far too flat. You're the last person that would be concerned with it. Correct. Yeah, that's a problem. And what we believe to be muscle is probably fat and hair. Correct. Yep, I'm there. So Drew, I wish that was the trend to a certain degree. And I'm not saying make these things massive or Belgian blue-like, and I'm not saying take muscle to where it inhibits movement and longevity, none of those things, but a little would be good. I, I remember Ryan, you, you were very, I'm not offended. I don't know the show down South we did together. And I might've been in the champion Angus drive, the speech I gave you, you did not think it was appropriate. Those were called them dairy animals. They were very light muscled. I'm just, you didn't call those animals.
1:13:46You called the breed dairy animal. Yes, I believe I did. And, and I, I stand by that, that there's got to be some point. I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just going to say if you're going to raise that breed and you want to be successful, you might not want to refer to them as dairy animals. That's what I said. Got it. A little muscle shape would be nice. This was good. This was enjoyable. Was that three? Yeah, that was three. Yeah, that was three. Thank you, Ryan. Hopefully, this opened some eyes. I know we kind of went against the grain on what you're seeing on social media that everybody seems to be in a frenzy about it. And I think it's great discussion.
1:14:24I think it educates people. I think it's good to stimulate those type of discussions. But within the show world and the show industry being separate from the commercial world, and it pains me to make that statement, and not seeing inbreeding coefficients, it would be so hard to get those high enough that it's going to impact anything, particularly what we're selecting in the show world. guys it's it's it's all gonna work itself out until next week be safe y'all come back now you hear you
Enjoying the show? A quick rating helps new listeners find it.