LIVE EPISODE · Dec 29 at 5 PM · Arizona National Livestock Show Details →
Episode 186November 10, 202393 min

186: Qualifications to Judge

Beyond The Ring Cattle Goats Judging Show Management

Dale and Ryan go deep into what most people assume should or shouldn’t qualify a judge to sort stock shows.

Episode overview

Dale and Ryan point out that judging a junior livestock show requires no formal certification, unlike many other animal show industries, and that the community is divided over what should count as an assumed qualification. They weigh the common claims that a judge must raise animals every day or must have competed on a collegiate judging team, agreeing neither is a hard line: team experience builds communication and evaluation skills but does not guarantee good judging, and neither does being a breeder. They discuss the bias risk when a judge's income depends on a breed, the criticism aimed at judging team coaches, and the pressure younger judges feel to please committees. Their proposed qualifications are honesty regardless of personal or financial consequences, accurate and justified reasons, treating exhibitors with respect, and the opinion of the exhibitors who attend. They also advise show committees to do due diligence when hiring. The Q&A covers clinic requests, livestock tours, and how supplements claim to target fat in specific areas.

Sponsors in this episode

Basic Animal Health — Code BTRJLA at checkout ▶ 1:21:32Leonard Truck and Trailer ▶ 1:21:37Show Coat Solutions ▶ 20:45

Key takeaways

Chapters

Read the transcript

Automatically generated from the audio, so names and details may be mis-transcribed. Check the recording for exact words.

0:00 Opening: news and current events

0:00Welcome to Beyond the Ring, a podcast that covers all things in the stock show industry from the informative to the insane, starring Ryan Rash, You have got to want it more than you are afraid of it, and Dale Hummel, The best way to predict your future is to create it. Now on with the show. Welcome to Beyond the Ring. This is Dale Hummel along with co-star Ryan Rash. Hello, hello, hello.

0:40A lot of elections this week, Ryan. You mean yesterday. Yesterday. This week, yesterday. Same. I'm trying to superimpose the fact that we're dropping Friday. Why do you want to bring up negativity? I think it's important that we talk about the elections and the polls because they're counterdicting each other to a certain degree. No, not really. I believe yes. I believe. No. You just read the polls differently. You don't read in English. Maybe that's correct. I was excited prior to yesterday that every Republican candidate, including the one that's going to win the primary, Mr. Trump, was beating Joe Biden pretty handily.

1:22but as was Haley and was my boy, Mr. DeSantis. I didn't know if they did any further than that. But all of them were beating Biden. And as Ryan had mentioned long ago, he assumed or stated they were going to bounce Biden out at the convention and bring somebody new in. I told him I don't know that they can get away with that. And I believed that at the time, but I think at this point in time, desperation takes over and joe biden will not be running against donald trump just won't you are you are correct in your earlier statement and i think you're starting to see that wave push in terms of pundits and those with influence in the democratic party giving joe that nudge i don't think joe's coherent enough to catch on that he's getting a nudge but we'll see how it plays out The thing is they are now past deadlines to where you can be put on the ballots for the primaries and the caucuses in these states.

2:27And there's nobody on there but Biden and some congressman that I've never heard of before. Because, again, RFK bailed out and he's now an independent. And so at this point, I don't know when all the deadlines are, but we are now in November and we're going to, you know, primaries and caucuses start in January. So there's no way he's not going to win those. Like, it's impossible. And so what they're going to have to do if they want a new candidate, and this is what I said months ago, and Dale told me I was a lunatic, but now he thinks I'm right, is somewhere between after the primaries and the caucuses and the Democratic National Convention, he's going to have to have some epiphany and bow out.

3:28And then they're going to go to their convention with it being open and nominate and select whoever they want to. But I think that's their only chance. And they realize that at this point. And polls can change between now and then. If they were set in a position where Joe was ahead, I think they'd run him. He's behind in every point. Yes. I'm just saying if things – To Trump, to all of them. Well, maybe not to Viagra. But to DeSantis, to Haley, to Trump, he's behind all of them. Yes. I think you are correct. And this is the perfect scenario for them. Joe is going to have to come out and blame it on a health concern or something.

4:10Or he gets impeached between now and then. Yeah. And obviously that's – so if he's impeached, does that disqualify him from running? I would think so. I mean, technically, Trump was impeached, but it wasn't. No, but if he actually gets removed from office is what I'm saying. So I don't. Is there a difference? I really don't know if you were truly removed from office from an impeachment if you're eligible. I don't know either. I don't have that answer. But, I mean, something's got to happen. So they could throw that through the, I mean, there's a paper trail, and I'm sure our listeners, if they've watched the news, You can see the checks cut from the Communist Chinese Party to the shell company of Hunter, from Hunter to his aunt and uncle, from the aunt and uncle directly to Joe at, I think, $40,000 and one at $200,000.

5:04They have the checks. On the checks from other members of the Biden family, it states loan repayment. Well, that's interesting to me. Very, very interesting. It's a paper trail that you cannot deny And he's still setting an office, Ryan You keep telling me that every day And I'm like, well, I don't know what to tell you It's just what it is But I think something's going to happen I don't know what's going to happen exactly But somehow this is He's going to go And then I don't know who they're going to put in But what I don't understand and you cannot give me any clarification on, is I thought the purpose of running for office was to get votes, to convince people to vote for you so you could get elected.

5:56I thought that was the whole intent and purpose. Very few of the Republican presidential candidates understand this concept. Did you know that? I would agree with that. They do not. They do not understand the concept because now all they are doing, because nothing else is word, is now they're going to bash Trump and they get booed off the stage and then they get angry and yell at the people that are booing them. That is not going to win them votes. No. And I saw a couple of independents being interviewed this morning on Fox News, not the Garage News.

6:38and they were pretty much united in the fact that they were leaning towards a Republican and obviously Trump if he's a candidate, but they did make the fact that they're voting against Biden, not necessarily for Trump. And if they had a better, another, not a better, another option or alternative to Trump and the Republican party, it would be easier for them to vote for such. And I think that's probably true with a lot of the independents right now. I think that's fine. I mean, that's great. I get it. The problem is there is no other option. No, there isn't. And there will not be. And it's just not going to happen.

7:19The fact that it's interesting to me because everybody says how everybody's voting against Trump. Well, I think the sentiment at this point is the you cannot deny the inflation, the interest rates, the southern border, the numerous issues that we have under Biden. they're going to vote him out. I mean, I believe that to be true. I am concerned, Ryan, if they go through with your described plan, either he's got removed from impeachment, which I don't think he would run at that point. That's a terrible look for the Democrats, by the way. It is. So the other one is a health concern and he cannot run for president. The open convention and they bring somebody in and I continue to hear your boyfriend's name way too often and he's posturing himself way too much to not be in the shadow campaign he is there's no and there's there's one and i don't that one doesn't fear me as much but if you don't look into him you just look at your his what you would say is pretty face and he can speak and don't look at the history of what's happening in helifornia yeah he might he may get some votes but you know who scares me the most is is michelle obama sweeping in a convention being nominated

8:32And the support that she may have behind her Scares me I agree I'm not saying you're wrong But it'll be very interesting Again We have all of these things going on I don't even know if I would love to take a poll and see how many people knew there was election yesterday before it happened. I think if it wasn't a governor's race in your state or many state offices, and I don't think it was many, but you bring that up and it did not go well.

9:22Mississippi, I think, is the only highlight that I saw. And would you not expect a Republican to win Mississippi? Yeah, and they said it was close. Yes, that concerns me. I'm going to be honest. I don't know how there's a Democratic governor in Kentucky, and he's wildly popular. I mean, he is wildly. They say the most popular governor out there right now. Literally, like in the top three approval ratings of any state in the United States. How? I believe he's a very moderate Democrat, but he is a Democrat. I just, I'm shocked. You know what I think hit hard Or what appears to me And again we were Not we And that man I do want to say The man in Kentucky Brashear And if I pronounce your name wrong I'm sorry but He ran away from Biden He did He said the administration Is a disaster All this other stuff He didn't embrace any of Biden's policies or whatever So maybe you're right Maybe he is moderate or whatever.

10:25It just still blows my mind that Kentucky is a Democratic governor. I would agree with that. What appeared to be what came up on many ballots, and I think the fact that it's on the ballot does have an impact on who they vote for. But abortion came up on many things, and it was stated. One in Ohio. And it stated something to the. Big. Yeah, and it wasn't just are you in favor of abortion. It was worded where are you in favor of controlling your own reproductive rights and a couple other. I mean, it was worded in a manner that you would want to say, yes, I want to have that control. However, it is a very heated topic. I am not going to dive into it because this is one topic that we are split as a country, and there appears to be no compromise.

11:12There's not really a middle ground. And I'm going to say that Kentucky, Ryan, when you brought that up, they were running ads. and I just saw a short blip, I believe of a nine-year-old girl and a 12-year-old girl that in the ad, and again, I don't know if this is a true story or not, but in the ad, they were a victim of incest and they were not, they would not, if they were, let's make it hypothetical, they would not be allowed to have an abortion in Kentucky if this passed. So I think, and again, And I don't think there's very many outside of a few very extreme Republicans that are going to go that far with it.

11:55But it's such a sensitive topic. People don't – they're just one side or the other, and there is no compromise. And it appears that that is the only thing the Democrats have right now to push. And I'm sure they're going to push it in the presidential election as well. And that impacted more voters yesterday than what was predicted. All I know is people need to get their shit together before next year because, okay, Youngkin in Virginia is very, very popular, right? So he had a goal to make the Congress a majority Republican.

12:37That failed miserably, by the way. But, okay, I'm going to give you an example. And this race is too close to call, but there is a Virginia congressman race where the Democrat is a woman. Her name is Susanna Gibson. Her and her husband had sex on the Internet and asked subscribers to pay for it like OnlyFans. Okay, people? Oh, my. This is a state race. Yes, this is. But it doesn't matter. It's a state race. But yes. this woman won the primary this comes out she didn't bail out of the race she stayed in it and it is too close to call we have a woman having sex with her husband on the internet and it is too close and getting people to pay for it by the way and it is too close to call how did this woman not get slaughtered I just do not understand it y'all got to pull it together y'all got to pull it together The public's uninformed or just don't care.

13:42I mean, y'all have got to pull it together in the next year. Somehow. Somehow. I don't know. But somehow. I saw a piece at one of the council meetings, city council meetings, I believe in Chicago. They're wanting to put Chicago status as a sanctuary city on the ballot. And it appears as though most people in Chicago are out on the sanctuary city status. That's a big move. I don't know why anybody would want to be, why Chicago would want to be a sanctuary city or why they would want any people seeking sanctuary would want to go. You'd get shot. That's a good point.

14:24Very good point. They're claiming they're spending, I don't know if it was $20 or $40 million a month on basically immigrants that have come to Chicago. and it's it's that that city is so corrupt and there's so much money going to so many pockets there's just not a lot of money left i mean the majority of the time when we weren't entertaining small children at the humble lotsa me and tara talked about our fear for dylan dying in chicago and that he needed to move i'm i'm not gonna argue that and i i've told him i think he has a there's a an opportunity to go to florida go to arizona somewhere with his company and he needs to do that chicago is not not a good place whatsoever and i know we're running long or whatever on all this election nonsense that didn't matter but y'all have to pull it together before the next year but i have been a bad person and i have not watched much news is is there any change on the wars wars plural that there you don't want me to go on to this and i was going to avoid it today. There isn't. Israel's not going to listen, I believe, to Joe. I think Joe's trying to reel

15:37them back a little bit. They don't appear to be interested in that. They're determined to take out Hamas. If that destroys a lot of the infrastructure in the gods, it just does. And they've accepted this and they've accepted there are going to be casualties and they're going to try to limit it to the best they can. But they're moving forward. We're sending a lot of military troops that general direction. I believe China is testing Taiwan even further and pushing their luck. There's no question, all of this has been orchestrated. And we're too ignorant as an administration to understand that we are dealing with World War III. It's begun. It just hasn't got to the conventional mode yet. The cyber attacks, the bio warfare, all of that's already happening. China's attacking us every day. Russia's attacking us every day. Whatever Iran and North Korea can do to attack us every day, they will, but it's not something out in our face. The proxy wars, Ukraine, Israel, and in my opinion, soon to be Taiwan, same thing. We're just avoiding that absolute, yeah, we're at war. When I think essentially we are. They want to destroy

16:53or take down the United States. They're doing everything they can to do it short of conventional sending missiles in or nuclear weapons or anything like that. So it's not good. It's a very bad place. And I was doing well today, not thinking about that, Ryan, by the way. Sorry, sorry. One last bit of whatever. So Dale believes in the garage news people. He likes them. I don't watch them enough, But I do approve Because they say all the things that Dale wants to hear And none of it's true But I mean they still say it So he still likes it Even though it's literally made in a garage But anyhow So do you know what I saw from your garage news company this week I think you see it more than I do Because I get notifications You do not get notifications I don't go to it But I did go to this one So the garage news company Put out that Putin is dead and Russia is being run by a body double.

17:57That he died of a heart attack last week. We don't know he didn't. And Russia is being run by a body double. I'm half convinced some days that whenever Biden's coherent, that's a body double. I don't know how people – there are going to be people that believe that. And is there not a chance that it's true? Oh, my lord. There is a chance. I quit. I quit. I don't know. I quit. Let's go on to something more positive, like BTRJLA news. Oh, my lord. Okay. Top 10 overall cattle as of today.

18:00 Program news and show announcements

18:40And again, we're getting close to the end, folks. The point share ends December 31st. I just answered a Facebook message wanting to know when the top tens would be final. It doesn't even end until December 31st, so don't get ahead of the game. There's a lot of showing. But if I was winning right now, I'd want to pull the plug. I think that was this mother's point. They were winning and they wanted it done now, but that's not how it works. As of right now, top ten overall cattle in the nation. Todd Danley is first. Sarah Danley is second. They are both from Texas. Taylor Poff from Ohio is in third. Dallas Ritchie from Indiana is in fourth.

19:23Tyler Lindsay from Mississippi is in fifth. JW Powers of Idaho is in sixth. Lacey DeSmith of Arizona is next, followed by Jalen Krimmel of Texas. In ninth is Faith Campa of Arizona. And 10th is Gus Hooper of Idaho. So that is our top 10 in the cattle right now. Anybody who's been on Facebook this morning, we posted the all-around banners that Classic Leather Designs made for 2023. They're beautiful. I want to thank Oldwood Limited for being the all-around sponsor for this year. One of the nation's largest manufacturers of custom-wide plank flooring and other unique reclaimed building materials.

20:09Our products will turn your project into a one-of-a-kind masterpiece that will last for generations to come. Made right here in America. Visit us online today at www.oldwoodlimited.com to create your dream home. And I'm going to do two because I just did that one out there because we posted those banners today. And I also want to thank Show Coat Manufacturers for being a corporate sponsor of the BTRJLA. Show Coat manufactures the best award-winning livestock grooming products for show cattle, goats, horses, sheep, and swine. No matter where you are in the country, no matter what species you have in the barn, if you're looking for the winning edge, the advanced shag strategy developed by Show Coat Solutions will change your hair growing routine overnight.

20:56They have step-by-step instructions, partnered with free product application videos, game-changing customer service, and we appreciate Showcoat for being a sponsor, corporate sponsor for the past two years. Dale is a big believer in their products, as am I. So please go to showcoat.com and for all your shag needs. Thank you, Showcoat. Thank you, all the sponsors, and congratulations to those top 10 cattle. I'm assuming right now with those that are close on points, Ryan, they are digging and searching for shows everywhere to go to. You know what it is? It's time for Badger Brawl.

21:38Mark your calendars and plan to attend the Midwest's premier steer and heifer show. This is one that I consider, Ryan, to be run well, managed well, focuses on a good exhibitor experience. It will be held December 1st. You just like them because they let you judge last year. Yes, it was great. And as far as the shows I've judged, it was probably as well run as any that I've done. And well attended, just good. So Badger Brawl, December 1st through the 3rd at the Alliant Energy Center in Madison, Wisconsin. You can find the schedule, list of judges, hotel block, all of that information at badgerbrawl.com or on their Facebook page. Just like previous years, there'll be multiple shows over the weekend.

22:21check out badger brawl badgerbrawl.com I had an interesting experience that ties into show fresh today okay hold on one second I do not want to be called a hater I have never judged the badger brawl but I judged the badger kickoff and then it became the badger brawl and it is a wonderful show I'm not saying it's the same thing no but it was the replacement for it when the badger kickoff closed down but anyway I just have to make fun of you because I think the only reason you like them is because they let you judge cows Well, I appreciate them sponsoring the episode. Thank you, Badger Brawl. It's just done well. I mean, Ryan, you and I talk a lot about getting classes in and out and the organization and the facility.

23:03I don't need to talk about shows and organization right now, okay? We need to move on to something else. Everything's good. Okay, I'm going back to my show Fresh H2O, being American-made, backed by real science. If you want to improve your show's success via hydration, give them a try. I visited the Show Fresh H2O booth at the National FFA Convention. I can't go. I'm a terrible storyteller, but I'm going to try to incriminate myself a little bit. So while at the booth, some people had come by, and I was visiting with them, and I was introduced to this young lady. I don't know how it – I don't know. I don't remember the specifics, but I was a little bit speechless, Ryan.

23:46You would not have been. You would have handled this much, much better. I'm sure I would have. I handle most things. This was just a very simple comment, I think, introduced me. And she says, well, yes, I listened to you in the shower. And for some reason, that got me a little bit. It should probably not have, but it did. I mean, I'm sure my face got a little red. I didn't say much. Katie was standing there next to me, and I think she noticed that I was a little uncomfortable. That would not have bothered you. No. No, I didn't think. I thought about that. during the time. No, I mean, it would have had to be way more out there than... More detailed.

24:24Well, no, I mean, no. It's just like, people listen to podcasts, listen to music, listen to all kinds of things. Yes, I get it. I don't know why it hit me a little odd, but it just did. It just did. So, it was a good National FFA convention, and I just had a little time to go over to the booths in the college area. I didn't. I didn't. And for anybody that emailed Or messaged I went to Dale's We did the judging contest And then I flew out the next day I never went to the convention So just because I was there In the Indy during it And I posted about it Did not mean I had a boo Did not mean I was there I'm so sorry You were right there downtown For two nights But in the first night I don't even think they hadn't even moved in yet Again, I left Thursday morning It was their Wednesday for the Judging contest festivities And then I left So I am so very sorry If I disappointed anybody But I never went to the convention So it wasn't that I was avoiding anybody I never went I had to go to the Louisiana State Fair Next It's time for the main topic

25:30 Judges have no formal qualifications

25:40judge qualifications uh-huh i believe you threw this one out a few days ago to me yes i did and so no one will listen was not opposed to it yeah it's actually one of the few that you never opposed you also sent sarcastic bullshit about it but anyway i forgot about that yeah what did i say something let's not let's not you can just wait i thought it was really funny yeah that she wanted to bring a commercial packer and a rancher in or something be a guest yes it was great okay and you were opposed to it i believe by your response that that is not i am not opposed to anything that is the whole purpose of this topic what are the qualifications to be a judge do you know what they are now there are none absolutely zero that it depends if you're talking about like No, I'm saying a criminal court judge Or a district judge No, I'm talking about a livestock judge There are none Zero Absolutely zero Do you also understand Before everybody gets all this twisted I am not saying That we need to take a test Or all this other stuff There needs to be a certification

26:56Certification theory There are some Do you realize that any other type of livestock show, you have to be certified? Horses, dogs, do you realize that? ABGA Borgoats. Again, and I'm not suggesting that, but I'm just saying we have no qualifications. Okay, time out. Do you think those in the horse side and the rabbit side, and I'm not very familiar in there, but I have experienced the ABGA side a little bit when we show with them. Do you think that any of those certification processes are successful or beneficial?

27:36I have no knowledge in the horse industry or in the dog industry or any of those, so I don't know. But I'm just saying we are out on this island alone is what I'm saying. And all these other people that have animal type shows, there is a process. There is a certification. There's whatever. I mean, again, I don't think it's probably going to change a lot. But do you not find it strange that we have zero qualifications? Literally none to judge you. I find it strange.

28:17But at the same time, I could not. It would take a much more creative mind than mine to come up with a manner to do anything that would be of benefit. I'm not. I do not. Again, I am not, you know, rallying for certification process. I'm just saying I find it interesting. Yes, I can agree with that. Other show industries that involve animals have a process, and we have none. That's my first point. Secondly, what I really want to talk about is not that we don't have a certification process.

28:58I just want to bring that up. I want to talk about that now more than ever, I think even though there are zero qualifications to judge a show, I think we are more divided in this industry than ever on what those qualifications should be, even if we had them. Would you agree with that? Maybe on what we call the assumed qualifications. The assumed qualifications, yes. The assumed qualifications. Because there are none, but yes. It's all over the board. Everybody has a different opinion. I think we are more divided than ever. And so, again, you were talking about bringing a rancher and a commercial person in, whatever, all this stuff.

29:42And you can go on social media and you can see all these things. And there is a certain section of our population in this industry that thinks that if you don't calve out 500 cows a year, then you should never step into a ring. Or the same with any of those species. If you're not raising them every single day, then you have no business judging. I mean, that's out there. And I can come in on that. And it definitely is. And I hear this not only out there or on social media, but you hear it visiting with people. And I get it.

30:00 Raising animals versus judging team background

30:23I think those that are in the trenches raising those animals are obviously knee deep in what they're doing and have opinions. and some would say those are the only opinions. And I think you could point a finger to if you've never competed on a collegiate livestock judging team, you should never judge. I think there's a lot of those, but I think that is... Well, that was my next one, but I'm just like... That is the most... That is one you hear the most about. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I see value in that. I do. I understand it. I get it. Part of it. And so that's there, but I'm not, I think the whole purpose of this topic is, I think we are so far divided that I could never just say, you know what, and we have 250 cows out in my front yard, okay?

31:19So, I mean, it is what it is, but I don't understand how that mindset works that if you are not raising them, then you have no business being a judge. I also, on the same token, do not understand the mindset that if you were not on a collegiate judging team, then you have no business being a judge. I don't understand that either because and I catch a lot of flack for this but I'm going to say it more and more and I'm going to offend some people right here with this I love the livestock judging team thing I think it's great and I wish I had taken more advantage of it younger but it taught me things that I have taken with me the rest of my life and changed my life in that single experience changed my life more than any other experience that I have ever had.

32:23Okay, I am telling you that, and it is the truth. It also did not do one damn thing to prepare me to step in a ring and judge a show. And that is the truth. And we've had this discussion many times, you and I. And Chris Mullinex is going to be ready to kill me after this. But I'm just telling you, it's just... And I think that you've presented a very accurate statement. I'm going to take the other side that I've coached collegiate judging for a good portion of my life. I think in your situation, with your show experience, with your personality, with your ability to speak, everything that you are because of your life experiences, that probably did not do as much for you.

33:09I think some of those young people, maybe myself, that are not as comfortable or were not as comfortable at one time speaking in public and things like that. I think any experiences like judging and presenting oral reasons, I'm not saying the technical side of it as much as just making yourself get out there and speak or give reasons. I think a lot of those things develop you as a person that will help you once you get in the ring in terms of communicating what you're seeing and so forth. It does not make you qualified to do it or not qualified to do it. But I think there are definitely, in my mind, there's no question. There's aspects of having to make those decisions and having to speak at least in front of one person in that reasons room or convey to your coach or other teammates what you're seeing.

33:58I think those things undeniably help you communicate better and help you get through that, maybe that fear of speaking out and just talking about things. So, again, I'm not trying to argue with you that I learned something from a technical standpoint that is going to make me the better judge out in the show ring. But rather the multitude of experiences that go along with that and part of it being traveling the country and seeing different operations. I think as judges, what we're doing out in that ring is nothing more than a product of our environment. And our environment is maybe what we did, calving those cows out at home or raising goats or whatever it may be.

34:39Maybe it was that visit to the South Texas Brahmin cattle operation. Or maybe it was, in my example, spending a summer in Australia working on Angus cattle operations while I was in college. visiting with some of those breeders over there, all of those things definitely impact why I have certain beliefs and why I select certain things in the show ring or in just breeding cattle or everyday life. So I think there are experiences on the judging team that contribute to them being more comfortable in the ring and maybe presenting themselves a little bit better. Can we agree on that. I get what you're saying. I want to bring it. I think the whole oral reason thing. Okay.

35:22I think that is the reason that part of the judging process where you have to go and I don't think it does anything for you speaking in front of a crowd because it's just one person. Okay. So I argue that part, but I think what you were saying is where you have to convey why you place this class the way you did to somebody. I think that is the reason that forever and always it has been a thing that you have to be one of the assumed qualifications is that you needed to be on a livestock judging team. So you can, once you get out in the ring, on the mic convey that to the crowd and the exhibitors that are there. I think that's why that is an assumed qualification.

36:12I understand what you're saying. I do think that that is beneficial, even though I don't think it does anything for a public speaking type part thing, because talking to one person and talking to a hundred way different. But and I don't I don't believe I don't believe it should have to be a qualification. I'm just saying that. No, I do. But I'm saying I think that part of the livestock judging team process is why it has been an assumed qualification. Agreed. Completely. Because placing four in a class in a judging contest is not anything like placing four in a class in an actual show or anything like that. But I think the all reasons part is there.

36:54And there is a section of the population, just like we talked about on the other side, that believes that it has to be that way. If you did not go through this, then you have no business in the show ring. I can't see that as a hard and fast line anymore than you have to cav out cows every year or spit out piglets or all these other things to judge. I just don't see those as lines in the sand, I guess. I think, again, lifestyle judging changed my life. It didn't do anything for me.

37:36Judging a show, I think you bring up some valid points. I'm not the typical person, obviously, but I also want to bring up that if, because I'm going to say that collegiate, there are more people that have gone through the livestock judging team process that short shows more than any other. Would you agree with that? I would, and not always just because I went through that, but that's just the section of the population that we're bringing in to judge shows. But yes, and no question there. And I want to come back before I forget because I'm capable of getting distracted easily. I think in your situation, Ryan, the fact that you went to so many shows from a very young age before you ever started any livestock judging per se or at a serious level, that you had already comprehended people describing livestock at shows, watching them short-sort shows.

38:32Not only did you attend, but you've made the comments on here when you're not back there getting cattle ready or whatever, you would actually watch and listen as a young child. So I think that's way, way different than the majority. So I think you already, I think you had a lot of those things about how people are talking livestock at a show and the mechanics. Everything about a show, you already had your mind pretty well set before you even started seriously in a livestock judging team, where I think a lot of people that maybe don't travel to as many shows or even just people outside of Texas, you can almost say in some situations, where they're getting the livestock judging experience prior or more of than they do getting out to shows and listening and things.

39:21So I think there's a lot of reasons there, but I am not questioning that it has not impacted. It has not changed anything you're doing in the show ring, nor necessarily benefited you. No, and I realize that I am in the less than 0.1% that when I wasn't washing, drying, whatever, within I showed all species, I was up at the ring watching anybody. Whether I agreed with them, didn't agree with them, whatever, I was the weird child that all I wanted to do was watch the show, and not because I wanted to watch my friends because I didn't have any, but I wanted to see what that person out in the ring did and what they had to say and why.

40:05And again I am still It is a curse to this day Because Dale has been with me at shows When I have nothing No reason to Watch or anything else I am still that person That if I'm going to be there Then I'm going to pay attention I'm going to watch and I'm going to listen And sometimes it is very bad Very bad for me So I understand that And I appreciate that point But we were talking about how the fact that you and I both believe that a larger percentage of people that judge shows do come from the judging team background.

40:46And I'm not saying that's correct, but it is part of it. And a lot of people that have a desire to judge shows are in that path. Yes. And I think that is correct, too. do I think people that are successful or go down that path get more opportunities yes because I'm telling you coming from Texas I can't tell you how many times that they will call the livestock judging team coach at a university and say send me the names of who you think would be the best to judge this county fair this jackpot show at all this so that is a big part of how they get those opportunities. But on the same instance of you've got to raise these things or you can't be in the ring or you have to go through the collegiate livestock judging process or you shouldn't be out in the ring, if either one of those were the fix, okay, then we would not have the issues that we have with the other side. If it was collegiate lifestyle judging is the answer, then you would never see someone that competed on a collegiate team step out in the ring

42:02and do a bad job. And I'm sorry. I've seen it. It happens. Same way with being a breeder. if that was the fix if that made you absolutely qualified beyond all doubt then you would never see someone who bred sheep go out there and do a bad job i've seen it what about do you think it's important and we're just talking all species market breeding just throwing it kind of all together do you believe it's important to be able to evaluate say composition fat versus muscle as a judge out there see the difference yes i think it's in in in either breeding or market yes i think it's very important what about skeletal integrity you're asking the wrong person because i believe it's more important than almost anybody out there doing it i just want i just want to bring this up to to go back to thing i i believe i'm not believe i am positive that during my coaching career as a coach and as a judging collegiate judging student and participant some of those things and I can remember a contest that we would have at Madison Wisconsin that we

43:19would have to actually estimate rib fat quality grade yield grade look at some of those differences and instead of an official just saying well that's this fat and it's such and such very subjective those would be harvested the next day and we'd get the actual measurements and because of activities like that and hopefully activities from that coach out there going through class after class and describing those. I think some of those kids on collegiate judging teams, not all, because some of you are not going to absorb information no matter how you present it, but there are some that probably benefit in those areas that because they did that, it made them better.

43:58Not necessarily better than that person that never went through a collegiate program, but it made them as individuals better at evaluating composition or skeletal integrity in terms of flexibility of joints and how those animals got around the ring. So I think all of those things may enhance that person's ability to see differences. And I think that's important when they get to the ring. And that's just one part of the accumulation of their life experiences that will eventually determine what type of animals they're selecting in the show ring. and I think that's how it should be, that accumulation, and that's why we hire different judges, and Ryan, you're one that says that everybody's going to have a different opinion in there. One may be closer to another, and some may be way off, but that's just part of it, and that's a good thing, and I agree with that as long as they're described accurately, and there's justification for such. So all of those things come into play, and again, I don't think it qualifies or disqualifies anyone, but I think some of those things, and I'm just going back to defend a little bit on the side of the judging team,

45:05I think it brings some of those. Dale, I saw the shrine to your judging team coach days at your house. I understand. You're dyed in the wool there. I get it. I get it. I understand. And again, I'm not against it. I'm just trying to bring out information to talk about here. Do you know what would have been the worst experience ever? What? I feel for Dr. Skaggs. I feel for him. oh i'm he's bald because of me there's no doubt but i mean i can't change that that's it is what it is he won so there because you know you know he he's a little like me on that real world side and in wanting to know what the carcass is going to be like he has no problem telling people i'm the most difficult person he ever had to deal with again the results were there all right so like move on it was worth him losing his hair but another thing that like i want to bring up here and this is a this is me this is this something like i i think i am of the belief that i don't think that if you are i'm not against breeders judging in any species but i also think that if you are an angus breeder maybe you shouldn't be judging angus cattle all all species and all

45:45 Breeders judging their own breed

46:27breeds and maybe maybe summarize it as if you're going to benefit financially on how that show ends up that that is my I guess disqualification or or we need to put more thought into it and and because when you will benefit financially in a positive or negative way depending on how those animals you line up end up doing in that show I'm not saying it's impossible but it is very difficult for you to give a non-biased subjective opinion and that's my belief too and i stand behind that and again i think there let's just take any species you want there are competent capable established judges in every single breed of every single species there's enough around that you should never have to use one from that particular breed because of what you're saying subconsciously or consciously, it is going to be very difficult for that person to be completely unbiased because they know people in that breed. They have relationships with people, good and bad, with people in that breed. There is obviously their livelihood, their income is affected from the sale of that breed, all those things. So I don't think a person of that breed

47:44should judge their own breed i am in the very few minority on that and because obviously more and more of these shows use their own breeders to judge their own breed i'm not and i also want to state i do not think that everyone in every breed cannot go out there and do as unbiased a job as possible and do a nice job. I think it is more difficult. Yes, I think that it can be done. And it has been done too. And so again, I'm not saying it's a qualifier or a disqualifier. I'm saying that this is something that is out there, just like the judging team thing, just like you have to raise them, all this other stuff, that that's a part of it. And is it a hard line in the stand? No, it's not. But that's also a part of this whole equation of judge qualifications or what qualifies you to judge a show that needs to be brought up.

48:47And I love where you're going with this because I agree so much. Ryan, I think I'm going to take it further that, and I'm just pulling on my past experiences and watching shows and evaluating what's going on. There are breeders out there that can go in and judge their partner or somebody they've sold animals to or whatever it may, it can be done. But I'm telling you, even if you think you're out there doing it subconsciously, it's going to be hard. And I think when it's tied to one's livelihood, feeding their family, it is just about impossible to go out there and do an unbiased job and throw out the window that you know if you use this one, it's not going to be positive for your operation or that genetic line or whatever.

49:34or we're going to burn this relationship with a very valued partner that benefits us financially. Let's be real about it. You just, it can't, I'm not saying it can't be done, but it is highly, highly unlikely that those other assets or facets of your life that affect you financially are going to impact what you do. It just is what it is. And I'm not saying it's a disqualifier. I'm not saying that an Angus breeder should never go judge an Angus show. I'm not saying that. And I'm saying it, and I think it's even becomes more important at the state and national level, the bigger shows where it is going to have more of an economic impact, maybe on their own operation.

50:14At a county show or a jackpot show that the world isn't watching, probably not as big a concern for me. I'm not saying we don't need judges to go in there and get those things right, but there's going to be less pressure by that person judging that also maybe happens to be a breeder. They're going to benefit less or be harmed less irregardless of what they do. There are qualified and capable people in any of these areas that can go out there and be unbiased, fair, do a competent job, and there are just as many that will go out there and be political or do a bad job. I mean, that's just that, and I think that is kind of part of why there are no hard, fast, drawn lines in the sand rules on what qualifies you to judge a livestock show in our industry.

51:00 Criticism of judging team coaches

51:06And again, I'm not saying that's right or wrong, but that's kind of what it is. And I have one more of these things to bring up, and then I'm going to kind of go into a different take on this. But I think, and again, this is going to make some people hurt. There is a lot of backlash right now about judging team coaches and why they get to sort as much as they do. I know, I think, and I'm not defending, I'm not qualifying, I'm not disqualifying. I think that when you, or the judging team coaches that I have known throughout the years.

51:50I think that they are very capable, by and large, of going out there and doing a very nice job. And so I don't know why there is so much backlash against them, but there is. I'm going to say the same for them as everybody else. Obviously, if they're training kids on animal evaluation, they have a background. They didn't go pull. I use this analogy a lot. They didn't go pull a used car salesman off the local lot in the college town and ask them to be a judging team coach. Okay, they got into that position for a reason. Does that mean that I think that if you are a judging team coach, you are automatically qualified to judge a national livestock show?

52:41Absolutely not. but more times than not if you're in that position everyone assumes you are would you agree with that dale absolutely and and i i don't think that's right either but i also don't like the judging team coaches suck they should never get to judge what i don't like that part either so there you go agreed i think part of what and you do and it's social media is where i see some of the yeah the badgering of oh i know i and i hear it in person too i mean a lot more now than ever i think even even more than i hear against judging team coaches per se even more than i do kids that are on a livestock judging team you see what i'm saying i i do i think part of it is they're an easy target they can come out and say well that that judging coach never calved out cows or fed fed out a bunch of feedlots tiers or whatever. But you can say that about a lot of people judging a lot of shows. But I think because of that, that's the route they take. They're in education. They're not in the real world. Well, I promise you, if they're teaching, which most of them will,

53:57or even just coaching that livestock judging team at the level of competition it's at right now, they're spending day and night trying to train those kids. There isn't time to do the rest of to be out lambing or kidding or, or calving that, that is their job and that's what they're doing. So it's almost impossible to assume they can do everything. Maybe in their, their past, they grew up on a cattle operation. Maybe they were multi-species, whatever it may be. But I want to compliment Ryan. There's a reason that they're in that position. Yeah. This is what I said. They didn't go to the local used car lot and pull this guy off the lot. I want to take it just a little further.

54:35And I think I can tie it right in here. Ryan, there's something that we have not mentioned yet at all on judging qualifications. And it is, we haven't talked about what type of animal they're selecting. Do you want to know why I haven't talked about it? Oh, God only knows. I think, again, it goes back to those life experiences. Everybody, depending on what part of the United States you've grown up on, how many different operations you've visited, whether you've been in the trenches or more academia. I mean, there's so many things that impact what type of animal you may want that you believe in. Whether my experience personally, traveling throughout the country and seeing the different environments, and I'll use cattle as an example.

55:18The same type of cattle that work right here in Illinois are not going to work in South Texas. The same type of cattle that maybe are very popular in Australia may not work in Scotland or New Zealand or Argentina or all the different places that I've been so privileged to go and visit with breeders and get their philosophy, all of those things come into play in my mind. And there is no one exact animal. And you don't want to relate it to the commercial world at all, but there isn't that ideal in everybody's mind. We cannot agree on ideal. And it just is what it is. But if we can go out there and sort animals consistently, describe them accurately, be cordial, especially in a junior show to those exhibitors and get on the microphone and convey our message, not only to the exhibitors, but those out in the crowd, the parents, grandparents, enthusiasts, whatever they are, and do it consistently and honestly and take it with a sense of responsibility that you were hired.

56:17this is a privilege to come in and do something like this. Let's do the best job we can. Let's take it seriously. Let's make sure we're presentable. We show up on time. All of those things are done. And at that point, even if that is different than the type I would have used, if it was justified on the microphone and consistent, I believe you and I are both okay with that. No, and this is how you know, Dylan, I don't discuss anything before the thing because He literally just took where I was going to go. So, and you have very valid points. And so what my kind of conclusion on this was, we've talked about all these different things that they don't qualify you or disqualify you.

57:00 Proposed qualification: honesty

57:01So if there were qualifications to judge, what should they be? I don't think it should have a damn thing to do with the fact if you're on a judging team, a judging team coach, a breeder, a homeless person. I am going to say for me, and I will state this out loud, I don't care what race you are, what gender you are, what sexual preference you are. I don't ever want to judge a show because I'm gay. I don't think that should matter. I also don't want to not be allowed to judge a show because I'm gay. And that happens more than it should. And I would think that the other minorities that are in this industry that want to judge, I would hope they would want to be picked to judge shows for the same reasons.

57:55Not because they're a woman, not because they're a certain race or anything else, because of what they do when they get out there. I would hope that would be the same for everybody. So I don't think any of those things that matter. If there were qualifications to judge, I would tell you what I think they should be. First and foremost, I think you have to be honest. And I think that is probably the biggest qualification that we are missing right now in a large majority of situations. Not all situations. And again, I think there are some people that can go in in some circumstances and be as honest as anyone, and then you put them in a different situation in a different circumstance.

58:46Guess what, Dale? What? It's not going to be the same thing. Agreed. And that's the kicker. I think the first qualification is you have to go out there and be honest regardless of the situation, regardless how it's going to affect you personally, financially, all this other stuff. You talked about a financial level earlier. Do you know how many friendships that I have lost over the way I sorted the show? I don't think anybody would ever guess. No, and I've witnessed some of it, Ryan, and not even that you and I have discussed some of it, but I've just sitting back and watching and understanding the industry. It happens. And I don't judge that many shows. And I promise you that I've had the same situation and take that times 50 or 100 where you're at. And it's tough. It really is.

59:44I think you gain the respect of those that are paying attention, but at the same time, you lose more friends because you're not going out there and allowing that bias to come into play. I can tell you some days after you judge a goat show, I really don't want to talk to you. I've realized that. I mean, when I do, I don't hold back. I say, why, why in the hell would you beat a good goat? Because it was ugly headed. And we've had these discussions. I'm thinking, good God. No, I don't get it. I don't think people focus on the personal part of it enough. There's a large number of times when any sorter is out there, and I guarantee the thing running through their mind is, oh my God, what is going to happen if this person doesn't win that I've been a friend with for however many years or all this other stuff?

1:00:36And that affects someone's opinion just as much as the bottom line and the financial part. And so I think one of the qualifications should be is that you've got to be honest, unbiased, unpolitical, unwhatever. And I have said this before, and I'm going to say it again, and this isn't politically correct. But if you really want to do this and you want to be that person that is completely unbiased and unpolitical, you got to have a whole lot of I don't give a you know what.

1:01:19And it is hard. I'm telling you, it is hard. And I don't talk about this enough, but you're never going to gain a friend from judging a show. but you can lose a lot. And I'm telling you, I have lost people, people that will not talk to me still to this day that helped raise me over the way I judged the show. And I think there's not a whole lot of people. They have enough, they have enough justification on that alone. Not the judging the show, just having been around you. That's it. Yeah, that's it. Anyway, but there's not a whole lot of people in multiple circumstances that are willing to go there. And that part's hard. So being honest, regardless of situation, financial, personal, I think that's probably the biggest qualification.

1:02:13And Ryan, we didn't, and I want to, I want to tack onto that, that I never thought about this one prior. Sometimes, whether it's a show superintendent, manager, committee, show committee, if that person judging the show knows who was responsible for bringing them there, and they're tied to animals in the show, it is of the opinion if those animals do well, you may get asked back or recommended on to the next show. Or again, recommended to another show. That doesn't mean you're friends with them or not friends with them, but there's another influence that we didn't talk about that needs to not be. Yeah, you may have no idea who that person is, but when they call you and they ask you to judge XYZ, and it's a state fair or national or whatever, that is and then they have animals out there then nobody has to say anything but i guarantee you in the back of your mind and anybody that doesn't say this is lying well if they get along or if they get along maybe i'll get asked again or maybe they'll recommend me to the next one or whatever and we're all human that's part of it i mean and i think on the younger judges those that are just

1:03:25going out there getting started i think doing things that they believe will get them the next show whether it be that or use the same animal that won a previous show or whatever they deem might be popular to get the next show sometimes compromises their ability to just sort the livestock and i understand that's their goal they want to judge more shows so they're going to do what they believe politically will get them more shows and it's a hard hard battle to fight it just it's present, it's out there. I think we need to be conscious of it. And as a young person out sorting shows, it is that much harder to do everything that you and I have talked about, Ryan, from a confidence standpoint, maturity standpoint, all of those things. And we haven't maybe approached that as much as I thought we would touch on. But when those animals have that show record that they've done really well, it may be app. And most of the time it's probably well earned or well-deserved, but sometimes that ball starts rolling and the snowball effect takes place that when they come into a show and somebody's going to just truly sort them honestly, and there's

1:04:33an issue there that has been overlooked because of the track record, sometimes those people are going to catch heat for it. And vice versa, some will catch heat for using the same one when it's maybe not thought to be as good. But there's so many factors that come into play. It's difficult. it really really is and we expect these judges to be able to do all those things and gosh i i i hope by just putting this out there and and getting people talking a little bit more i hope it gives a push that direction on all the all the things we're discussing no and so honesty is that first one for me that it should be the biggest qualification i think And Dale touched on it earlier.

1:05:15 Accurate reasons and hiring judges

1:05:15I do not give a shit how you place the class. I swear to God I don't. I mean, if I'm last, am I going to be super happy? No. But I honestly do not care how anybody places the class until they open their mouth. And you can line that up anyway, and then I'm going to stand there, and I'm going to listen to you. And one thing that bothers me, and I'm going to put this out there, there are so many people that don't listen that the art of reasons is lost because I am so sick of the number of people that just go out there and say the same things over and over and over again.

1:05:57But nobody listens, so they don't feel like they have to try. But that's another podcast. But I'm going to listen to you. And if you can tell me accurately with some justification on why you lined them up that way, and I can't sit there and say, like, if you say that the one in first is the soundest and it's bucked over, then you're done with me. I mean, stuff like that. But if you accurately describe those animals and give a little justification over why you placed them, even if I'm last, I'm okay with it. because judging is an opinion.

1:06:37People forget that. It is an opinion. It is not a mathematical equation. It is not a science. It is an opinion. And we all have a different opinion. And that doesn't make the judge right. That doesn't make the judge wrong. It makes the judge official on that given day. But if you cannot get on that microphone and accurately describe those animals and give some justification on why they are lined the way they are, then yes, that's when I start caring about how you line them up. Because the stuff that's coming out of your mouth has nothing to do with how they're lined up or the animals out there.

1:07:22That's when it gets bad. And again, unfortunately, that happens more times than it should. And the flip side of that is there's a lot of people that can go out there and line up animals to appease the majority of the spectators, exhibitors, whatever, and then what they say makes very little sense to do with the animals. So my second qualification would be, I don't care what your opinion is, but you have to be accurate when you describe those cattle or sheep or pigs or goats or whatever.

1:08:04You have to be accurate. And I think accuracy is a truly lost art in reasons right now. And I could go on about that for three hours. But anyhow, Dale, your thoughts. I agree with that completely. And to take it just a little bit further on, you can use different types of animals because of your experiences that that is what you like and that's accepted. And just as Ryan said, if you're describing them accurately and justifying, these are the differences and this is why I line them up and such. No complaints here. And I don't think from most of the people that truly understand the show industry, the livestock industry and attend quite a few shows, I think they'll accept that.

1:08:48And I think the Texans have done it better because they've had more opportunities with five majors adjusting what animals they take to what judges, realizing that all judges aren't the same. We're starting to realize that more here when we have rings A and B back to back. It shows up here and we realize that that one judge is going to change. It just is. everything is not going to be the same and there are differences and it's okay if they're justified and described well. So I am all in on just that. If there's one thing, Ryan, that I can insert to leave with our listeners and most importantly, those that are hiring judges, hopefully they get a chance to listen and absorb this and agree or disagree, at least open their minds a little bit.

1:09:31when you hire that judge, I think it's hard for you to fully comprehend just how much time, effort, dollars, everything that's gone into so many of those animals that are going to be coming through the ring with those young people, that that decision to hire a judge that you believe can do those things we've talked about. And I don't think there's anything, Ryan, that we've talked about on here in terms of describing animals and being honest and all all the positives that we talked about. I don't think anybody's going to disagree. That's what we want in a judge. So as a committee, as a superintendent, as whoever that may be, that's hiring that judge, do your due diligence.

1:10:12Think about those things. Does this judge is, is what he does today or tomorrow when that show is, is that going to affect their livelihood from a financial standpoint? Is, is that judge in the path, have a track record that they've actually described livestock? Well, and it's been very popular with the exhibitors and especially the youth that come in the ring, is it a positive experience? There's a multitude of things to look at and sometimes I think decisions to hire judges are made for the wrong reasons. And not saying that they intentionally want to bring a bad judge in, but because they have this person in their ear or that person in their ear, we're maybe not researching and doing our due diligence to the level that I would like to see.

1:10:55And I think this is with everything, All of us, every decision that we make, we have to make that decision, but let's make it as informed as we possibly can. And again, I have two other points, and I know this is getting long, but this is an important topic. But I have two other points, and then we'll wrap it up. So the last qualification that I see is how you treat the exhibitors as a judge. and again I think this is the most overlooked thing in the world from a judge's perspective and Dale brought up like if you're on a committee you don't realize how much time effort money all this other stuff I don't think most of the judges take in consideration how much time effort money energy all this is that it took for that family that exhibit to bring that animal to you to that show. And as Dale says, it is a privilege for you to be there.

1:11:15 Treating exhibitors and exhibitor opinion

1:11:50It is also a responsibility or I look at it as a responsibility. And so anything you can do to make all the exhibitors in the ring or the people attending the show have a more enjoyable experience because there's only going to be one winner in the end. There's only one. There's one Supreme. do those things and it's not that hard it really isn't and time after time after time after time and dale said it's more important in a junior show than an open show and i agree with that at some point but i also think that it's important at all the times because the open show people pay just as much money as the shooting may be more than the junior show people do and i think they deserve judges that have energy and are excited to be there and are glad that those exhibitors are there. But if it's just as simple as asking how they are or any of those things, do whatever you can as a judge to make it the most enjoyable experience for everyone there. Because you're

1:13:08not going to make everybody happy with your placings. Very few are going to make everybody happy with their reasons. So this is an area where you can go out of your way or do some little things that will have an impact and will make a lot of people happy. And it is not done enough. And it is so overlooked. And I don't get it because it's so simple. Agreed completely. Of course, Dale has nothing more to say about that. No, I mean, all of those, I mean, I touched on it earlier, but I watch so many shows, Ryan, and you do as well, that I just, I mean, it doesn't take, and maybe we don't understand it.

1:13:51Maybe judges don't understand it as much as they should when they're in the ring. but with maturity and reflecting back and watching others judge shows and my kids at the in the show ring and what they tell me afterwards those few words that you may say to that exhibitor or that comment you may make on the microphone about them those things mean more than what we can imagine yeah they matter and and i i understand the point that i think i think and again i'm gonna hurt somebody's feelings and step on somebody's toes here. If they don't realize those things, then they have not shown enough. Because if you've been out there enough showing and you've been treated one way by one judge and then the others don't, that's why this other person is your favorite judge or that's why you want to go show to them. Because the vast majority don't treat you that way but that person doesn't maybe you were third but by god they were cool with you or whatever all this other stuff so those that don't see this as important they simply have not shown enough or they have not had exhibitors and animals out in the ring enough to understand

1:15:04that that is as important as anything and it is the way the only way to make a large portion of the people there happy. I want to shed a different, come at it from another angle. And I am so happy with how you're putting that together and presenting that to our listeners. Think of it in this manner. We all talk about how the junior livestock show ring is an educational tool to raise our kids better, to build all the things we talk about from work ethic to responsibility, to fostering a sense of competition, all of these things.

1:15:49So we talk about that and that the actual animal is simply that tool and maybe how that animal places. Yeah, we want to succeed. We want to place higher. That fosters our competitive nature. But all the effort and so forth that goes into it is what we're benefiting from as much or more with how we place. And I'm not saying we don't want to not to go to that show trying to win that class or division or the entire show or whatever it may be. But as a judge, the impact we have on each of those youth or each of those exhibitors is as important or more important because there's only going to be one that wins and several that maybe are happy to win a class or division or whatever it may be. It is as important, our interactions and how we treat them, the sense of responsibility that we put forth into making that a positive educational experience to encourage those kids to move forward, to get them excited about going into the ring at the next show that they go to.

1:16:50All of those factors come into play is more important than maybe getting that pair right between third and fourth. And sometimes we get caught up in, let's make sure we get these lined up right or correctly, which we need to do that we block out that this needs to be a positive experience for these kids and we focus solely on the animals i think you can do both you need to do both make it positive and so then my last statement here and this is not going to be anything new but i hope that people listen to the end in my opinion the most overwhelming biggest monumental quality in what qualifies you to judge a show is what the people actually out there in the trenches showing at the shows thinks about the job you do. Because that's the customer and that's the opinion.

1:17:48And they, unlike somebody that sits in a boardroom for five minutes or a manager of a stock show or whatever they see multiple judges throughout the year in different circumstances in different whatevers and again we're the only industry that does not believe in the customer is always right which i still baffled by that but that that's the biggest qualification who do they think does a good job who do they want to show to who do they want to take their kids to who do they want to spend their entry fees for that should be the number one qualification as a judge it's because those are the people that are making the shows work and attending them because without exhibitors you don't have a show and there's a lot to their their opinions should matter more than anything else anything more than what dale and i have to say any more than what someone who's paid to run a major stock show or a board of directors has to say, their opinions should matter way more.

1:18:58And one thing that we don't think about, this board of directors that decides these whatever, they don't have to show your breed. They don't have to show that species. They don't have to show spot pigs if you keep picking shitty spot pig judges. They can move to Duroc or something else. and none of those people in those instances seem to grasp that but i am telling you it is the opinions of the actual exhibitors and the actual exhibitors family that should be the overwhelming majority and biggest qualification of what makes you able to sort a show absolutely and i think ryan you see it a little bit in texas because there are more shows in texas that you can go to but I think you're going to start seeing exhibitors voting basically with what shows they attend when they have opportunity to attend more shows they can pick and choose in our part of the country.

1:19:56There aren't as many shows. So in the past you're pretty well stuck with whatever it is. If they run the show in a, in a negative manner, they get shit judges. That's one of the only shows we can go to. We're probably going to it as they become, as there are more choices. And I believe there are more and more, especially jackpot shows popping up. We can't increase state fairs and maybe some national shows we can, but for the most part, there's X amount of county fairs and state fairs, but jackpot shows there's becoming more and more of those. And I think people, if they, if they think that shows run well and they have a qualified judge, they're going to participate.

1:20:29If you, if they think there's one of those factors that's, that's missing, they don't need to go. They can go to somewhere else that weekend. And I, and I hope that continues to happen that that makes everything better. Are you ready for, question and answer oh my well i thought this was a wonderful topic i see it i thought my topic nobody will like it but i thought it was great what what i liked is i don't think you and i even we were very it's felt very down to earth we didn't even argue as much which maybe makes it less entertaining no because i let you off the hook because i saw your shrine to your judging team days i just let you just go ahead and vent so we didn't and there's going to be another topic that we didn't address in this one and that is the basis there i it is my belief there has to be a basis for everything we do in the in the show ring in terms of just something to keep us a little bit on track and i always go back to the real world except for goats um but we'll we'll have that topic later but that will that will stimulate plenty of argument between us plenty how about

1:21:00 Listener questions

1:21:32a sponsor for question and answer do you have one of those yeah yeah basic animal health uh the Leonard family with Leonard Truck and Trailers, but Basic Animal Health, their company, is the question and answer sponsor to the Beyond the Ring podcast. If you will go to www.basicanimalhealth.com and buy one of their products, which is Get Health Show Focused or Trailer Ride at the checkout, out if you will use the code btrjla we will get a portion of the proceeds of that purchase to help pay for btrjla awards so please again use the code btrjla when you are purchasing products from basic animal health at their website and we appreciate the leonard family and basic animal health for their sponsorship of the question and answer portion of the podcast thank you basic animal health. Are you ready? Sure. I did pull these questions up as we were. I was distracted a couple of times in that I was trying to find questions. The first one, Ryan and Dale. I had the privilege to attend the National FFA Coaches Clinic. I am so appreciative that you guys took

1:22:48the time to answer questions and give your insight. I forgot to ask if you are available to do something similar at state ag teacher conferences. This is for you, by the way. I get this question about several different things, whether it's showmanship clinics or speaking, whatever, all this other stuff. I have a die hard and fast rule. And if I can't do it for everybody, then I'm not going to do it for anybody because I just don't understand any other fair way to go about it. And so I like doing what we did at the National FFA Judging Contest. Honored to be there.

1:23:29Had a lot of fun. But there's just no way that my schedule right now would allow me to include state FFA contests. So for me, regrettably, the answer is no. Unfortunately, and I wish more time, And I try to do these things as many as we can. But Ryan mentioned it in terms of getting asked. And an example would be the FFA tours that we put on here. I've had multiple calls and emails about, oh, can we come and tour next week or next month? And we have our local community that would like to come out and visit.

1:24:10There's a certain point where we just can't. We can't do that all the time and still get everything else done that we need to do. And Ryan's schedule is much different than mine in terms of he's out judging shows all over. I'm here trying to help run some of our family businesses. So it's hard. If there's something that can be done, I'm very open to try to do that. When at the same time, I start thinking, well, that weekend that I finally have open, do I need to go judge that show? Or do I need to go do this event? Or do I need to spend time at home with my family when we're busy doing other things a lot of the time? So lots of things come into play, but I appreciate the fact that we are honored to have that opportunity.

1:24:55And the best thing to do is maybe shoot Ryan or I a text or a Facebook message. And depending on what the event is or where it is, I will at least entertain the idea. And if I cannot possibly suggest somebody that that would be good, that does have does have the availability. Next one comes from Janet. I love the podcast and I was excited to have the opportunity to see both of you during our Homo Livestock tour before National Convention. Ryan, did you see any kids during National Convention? 26,000. No, there wasn't that many. I loved everything about the tour and visiting with you both. Will this be offered in the future? And how far in advance can this be scheduled?

1:25:37This is kind of for you, Ryan. That depends on who you ask. Yes. Are you willing to come back next year? I don't know. I'm going to have to consult with Tara and Craig on this first. So, Janet, yes, we were excited. I don't know, Ryan. You were here for part most of the day on Tuesday. Most of the day, 10 hours. You left before. it was halloween there were at least two tour buses and several vans that came after i announced on the podcast that i would be there from eight to five and i was there so okay so with that i don't know how many kids we had come through we we did have a sign-in sheet not everybody got 26 000 no there was not 20 it was a lot of of chapters that were able to come through i am so appreciative that you wanted to stop and thankful that you did.

1:26:30It was a very big day. I don't know that we can physically handle any more people from a parking or just from the logistics of it, but we will schedule that. Ryan, I'm going to commit for him that he would love to be here next year. And I usually, I'm not very- I have to have a round table discussion with Craig and Tara and then I will get back with you. I am not very good about scheduling things in advance, but for the most part, we will set the day or two aside just prior to convention. I know a lot of schools wanted to come after convention because of our schedule. It did not work, but we will do our best to set one or two days aside that in advance that, that we're happy to accommodate whatever we can. With that, the final question. And this one, actually, I found, Klifton sent this one to us. It must've came in through email.

1:27:19The one that I don't check. This one comes from Jordan. Hi, Hi, my name is Jordan and my children show both heifers and show pigs in South Texas. The more we're looking into supplements, we're noticing that certain ones so they can fix certain areas. For example, Fitter 52 can slim the neck of a heifer. How does it know to slim the neck and just the neck? And with pigs, there's a few supplements to gain fat. And I was told that two different supplements can gain fat in two different areas. How is that possible to contain where fat is gained or taken away in localized areas? Thank you for your time. I'm just going to be quiet here. Did you see that question when Klifton texted?

1:28:02And I just left it alone because I knew it would just send you into orbit. So I'm just going to let you go out there into the stratosphere and just orbit around all of them. These are your questions. I have made this very, very clear. On supplements in general I just Don't believe in a great deal of them And so Again I don't I want to say I have had no experience With any of the ones That this person asked about So I'm not I am not condoning them Or Saying they weren't Because I have had no experience I'm going to be honest I had never heard of that one.

1:28:51I've had limited experience with some. Some of them. I meant these individual ones. Yes. That was listed. So anyway. But. And I will say again. That I do think in general. For supplements. That if they target a specific thing. That they're supposed to do. More times than not. That's probably more believable. and Bible, then the cure-all, fix-all that's going to fix everything. But I think this person has answered their own question. How does that happen? So, again, Dale, you like this question way more than I do.

1:29:36And I couldn't help myself if I tried. So just go right ahead. Okay, and I'm going to keep it very short. Where is Fugate when we need him? Mr. Fugate, come here. He believes in all the supplements. He believes in them all. Okay. And I don't want to use individual supplements, but there are some. I believe Fitter 52 or some of our cattle supplements to slim the front end or fresh and feminine or any of those things that burn some fat. I think the concept there, and I can't speak for all of them, and I'm just generalizing here. But if we bump the lysine content, we're burning the extra amino acid lysine, and that's causing us to use up some energy.

1:30:17So it's going to probably pull some fat. It's going to put us closer to a negative energy balance where we can pull some fat off an animal. The concept is good. And biologically speaking, we deposit fat in different areas of our body. Let's say in a situation you may deposit fat subcutaneously before intermuscularly, before you would deposit them around your internal organs. All of those things are different in different species and even a little bit within the individual animal. But for the most part, there is an order of fat deposition in terms of how they put the fat on. There's also an order of how they're going to pull that fat off their body in a time of negative energy where they need to pull on those body reserves.

1:31:00So just be careful. I think it's hard for a supplement to only put fat on one part of the body or contribute to fat in one part of the body. If it so happens, that is the first biological portion of the body that fat is likely to be deposited in at a higher rate. Yeah, maybe, maybe. But guess what? Any form of energy would probably do the same and the same thing we're trying to pull it off. So there is some, there may be some relevance to that, but I think Ryan had pointed out the more specific and the more things that some of them say they can do, it's harder for me to accept that they're doing all those. are there supplements out there that help in individual areas for different things, whether it's attitude or hair growth or muscle deposition, and there's science behind it, and there's logic that, yeah, that makes some sense, especially if we don't have it already in that diet that we want to add a little more of this or that to it.

1:31:59It's possibly good. So Jordan, I think Ryan was right. You've kind of answered your own question. And if we just insert a little common sense, we can answer some of these questions for ourselves. So nothing by any means, I'm not trying to be negative on the supplement industry. I'm just trying to make sure that people feed and do everything for a purpose and make sure that purpose is justified and real. Because we can talk ourselves into a lot of things. I enjoyed today's episode, Ryan, very, very much. And I appreciate you didn't fight you on the topic. I think it was one of the more down-to-the-earth episodes, so I'm sure we'll have fewer downloads than normal.

1:32:37But it was good. Well, it's my topic, so nobody can listen to it. So it's fine. Until next week, be safe. Y'all come back now, you hear? you

Questions answered in this episode

Enjoying the show? A quick rating helps new listeners find it.

Review on Apple Podcasts Rate on Spotify

More like this

Ep 61Jun 18, 202170 min

61: Beat The Heat

Dale and Ryan discuss keeping show stock cool while hauling and showing in the heat of summer.