LIVE EPISODE · Dec 29 at 5 PM · Arizona National Livestock Show Details →
Episode 137December 2, 202291 min

137: Judging Contest Etiquette

Beyond The Ring Cattle Goats Judging Show Management

Ryan and Dale discuss the dos and don'ts of all the different people that play a role in a judging contest.

Episode overview

Dale and Ryan go through the dos and don'ts for every role in a livestock judging contest, stressing that each person can affect the outcome when contests are often decided by a point or two. Contestants should trust their own placings, never change them after turning in cards, and avoid surveying other notebooks. Superintendents set the integrity of the event, group leaders must stay alert so each contestant gets the same look, and officials should be current, want to be there, and keep phones away during reasons. They prefer having two reasons listeners in one room over splitting groups, thank the people who select classes, and ask for clear class descriptions when animals could be sorted as show or commercial types. They also say handlers should set aside disappointment, and officials should mark cards under the same limits as contestants. The Q&A covers breed characteristics and showing two species with different schedules.

Sponsors in this episode

Leonard Truck and Trailer ▶ 26:38Show Coat Solutions ▶ 26:38Show FresH2O ▶ 24:17

Key takeaways

Chapters

Read the transcript

Automatically generated from the audio, so names and details may be mis-transcribed. Check the recording for exact words.

0:00 Opening: news and current events

0:00Welcome to Beyond the Ring, a podcast that covers all things in the stock show industry from the informative to the insane, starring Ryan Rash. It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt. And Dale Hummel Give me liberty or give me death. Now on with the show. Welcome to Beyond the Ring. This is Dale Hummel along with co-star Ryan Rash.

0:42Hello, hello, hello. Huge, huge current events day, Ryan, especially on an international scale. yeah yeah yeah i have more important current events than you go ahead have at it and i have nothing to do with international they have to do with what this podcast is supposed to be about not you and china oh we're gonna talk about china today i promise you it is going to be this is just an in general fyi i i feel i have meant to bring this up before and i have not but the events of this past weekend have brought it to my attention again. And so, to all my Hog Showman children and my Hog Showman families, there is a new trend in showing hogs that I think would probably need to be a little concerned about or end it. And I don't know how to describe it other than the fact that the kids like bounce up and down when they're walking around in the rain i know you don't judge hog shows much you and i discussed this maybe not on here we discussed it i thought maybe we it's not not been on here but it's really getting bad and i don't know why we

2:00bounce up and down in the rain but we need to stop so that's the end of current events no more bouncing no more bouncing i'm i'm in favor of that and i've i've noticed it a few times and i think when i noticed it i asked you about it and you said no more bouncing up and down so let's go in the main topic because if they'll get started on current events it's gonna be bad oh we're gonna i'm gonna talk about some protests oh you know why the protests began in china because 10 people died in a no 10 and but the best thing and i shouldn't say the best thing we were it's very unfortunate the deaths occurred and that was should not have happened period because of the extreme COVID lockdowns. They have this apartment building locked down. Literally, the people living there cannot get out. There's a fire on the 15th floor, and they can't get out, and nobody appears to be letting them out. Terrible situation. I don't know all the details on that. More importantly, this has quickly evolved into a multiple-issue protest, and they've come out strong against the COVID lockdowns, referencing back to the fire issue and many other issues.

3:07But what I'm excited about is we're starting to see protesters come out down with President Xi and give me liberty or give me death. Historically, this is the beginning of regime change. If we go back in time, how these things happen. Now we're way too early in this. and unfortunately China and the CCP may come down so hard on the protesters it will come to an end soon but we we have to acknowledge that the protesters are reaching out and we have to at least give them support from the standpoint that we understand your cause we're behind you to whatever extent we can the White House did not do that yes that's what I'm saying and Unfortunately, the White House is not.

3:53But let's hope that others in other countries are. It's interesting to me. We can talk about protests in this country, and there are many of them. It's a little different when you protest in China. Ryan, you're aware if those protesters are arrested, and many have been, they're not just sitting in jail overnight and let out the next day. What's happening to them? Life, death. They end up alive, but they died. And that's the reality of it. So now I'm not joking. That's what happens. Yeah. If they come out and are willing to risk that it's a pretty damn important cause. It's not, not let's save the, the, the little lizard and the hills of, of Oregon or whatever it may be.

4:35You're not going to put your life on the line for that. This is about human rights. And I think getting away from the communist party. Well, and I agree with all that. And again, it's in 10, uh, from what I, 10 people died in the apartment building, but But then I also understand that there are protests going on in 10 of the major, more metropolitan urban cities in China. Yep. Actually, up to 15 provinces are now protesting as of today. And that's huge. So it's spreading. Yeah. And I get all that. And I applaud their efforts and their bravery more than their efforts. Here's the thing. and I talked to you about this yesterday and you just glazed over because you don't like to hear reality I do not remember that conversation they have no weapons they have no weapons this is not like America where if shit happens all the people that have arms can actually you know try to do something so they can take to the streets all they want they have no weapons so i don't see how this leads to regime change when they literally

5:50will either be jailed for life or killed and they have no way to defend themselves not trying to be a downer here no i i get it and that's that's always most that that's what's happened in the past this has not happened very often by by the way and i don't remember when it has not happened at all under xi xi ping's reign yeah and and the tiananmen square was a protest of students, I believe protesting specific leaders, not the entire party, and much, much lesser. And once that protest happened, the CCP came down so hard and made this basically, I mean, they're so locked down as far as human rights and anything post that, that this just hasn't even been on the radar. But it's interesting, even what they're talking about. So they don't want their populace to understand what's going on in the rest of the world. So Twitter, the communist government has put up 90% porn to block any real information. So you've got to search through a lot of porn that would probably distract some, and you're going to miss some of that actual information. In regards to the World Cup, obviously they can get it on their phone or somehow through

7:03state communist television. They'll show you the actual play of the soccer, but they avoid screening up into the crowd to avoid seeing that there are very few or no masks being worn. I think that they've tried to control this populace so much by not allowing information to come in. And at some point, and maybe this is the point, they can't prevent all of that. It's impossible. And once they see that the rest of the world is not locked down like this, the rest of world has freedoms and a decent life, that I believe this will continue to instigate these protests. And I hope that not too many people lose their life or go to jail for life or any of those things.

7:48But if these protests continue to grow with or without weapons, I don't know the population of China, but they have enough people there to take over the government. I am confident of that. Would it be easier with weapons? Absolutely. Absolutely. No question whatsoever. So I don't want to say it's encouraging because people are losing their lives, but something has to change. And remember, I've talked about how China is going to rule the world or it's making that attempt to do so. I never talked about necessarily this specifically, that the people of China will rise up and change that. We've talked about trying to take out that party in different ways.

8:24maybe this is maybe this is one of those options and the reason i'm so optimistic about this is something has to happen and this is the most realistic no they i'm not crazy they're they're going to impact our they already are when they shut down production of any of our essential items it impacts our lives and it's going to continue to get worse if something doesn't change and i don't see our current white house doing anything on a 10-year plan to bring back all essential production to North Korea. I don't know why you think the current White House wants to do anything. Do you not understand that China and Hunter they're buddies. They pay each other off, etc, etc.

9:07There's nothing going to happen from the White House. So you need to get out of that pipe dream, sir. This is also why all this money in Ukraine. Do you not remember Burisma? You see, this has been my whole thing with you and your sympathy to all of the ukraine of it all and wanting them to continue to the people of ukraine not not they're dirty politicians that man no you talk good about that man leading ukraine that man is dirty he is just as dirty as putin and jd ping just as dirty just because he has a nice face and gets on camera with a gun does not make him any better he he may be as dirty but not as dangerous how's that and the people of ukraine and again i'm sure there's dirty people of ukraine just like there are here no i'm not talking but i'm just saying you always praise that little leader over there and i'm like yeah he's just trashed he seems to be a brave little soul how's that a dirty there you go then you like it because he wants to shoot people in the kneecap so you like him i yes uh what about elon he's he's catching a little heat over over maybe oh well that's because elon's gonna out why they wouldn't let the hunter by her laptop

10:15story elon's gonna end up you won't talk about people that are gonna end up dead elon's gonna end up dead that i mean i i don't know if you're joking or not but that that's that is i i believe that to be serious uh maybe too high profile to take out i think elon is pressing too hard too fast i mean and i love it but like i was watching this one guy last night and he was like he's like And I kind of tend to go with this, too. He's like, I'm waiting for the next shoe to fall because this is too good to be true. The richest man in the world wants to do nothing but reinstate free speech. Yada, yada, yada, yada, yada, yada.

10:56He's like, I have no complaints about anything he's done so far. But what is the end game? What does he get out of this? And I think that's a very good question. But I don't know the answer, but basically Elon... I don't think it was a selfless act to improve the country. I don't think, yeah. That's what I wanted it to be. Yeah, you're living in a pipe dream because that doesn't happen anymore. But anyway, he is going to release why the whole Hunter Biden laptop story has been censored is the latest thing from what I understand. And people are very, very angry about it because they don't...

11:38And again, I don't understand this. They think that this is going to make people believe that there is censorship in America when there's not supposed to be censorship in America. But there is censorship in America, even though there's not supposed to be. Our former president got kicked off Twitter. All these other things are suppressed. That is censorship. Am I wrong? That is the definition I know. How do these liberals come out – if they come out against being more transparent on Twitter and the things that have happened, when they come out and are very angry against that, is this not admission of corruption and they want it to continue? Oh, you would think.

12:20I just don't understand. He's not saying I'm going to lean more to the right or I'm just going to be transparent and we're going to have freedom of speech and people are furious about it. That is nothing more than admission of guilt, in my opinion. I'm not arguing with you. I just, I worry about Elon's safety. I'm just going to say, like, I appreciate him so much. I'm going to reactivate a Twitter account. And I, you know what else I might do? I didn't think I'd ever say this. I might buy a Tesla just in support of Elon. And I don't want to plug the damn thing in. He might want to like check underneath it for like explosive devices. The next time he gets in, it would be my opinion on the Elon of it all.

12:59because and i and i hear on like car marketplace or wherever there's a lot of liberals selling the tesla so might be a good good buy on them right now oh that one goofy actress alissa whatever she she drove hers back to the dealership and just left it there and went and bought a volkswagen yeah yeah she's the same one that praised elon earlier right that's yeah elon was great now she went dropped hers off at the thing when Volkswagen, but okay. And as the many people on Twitter told her, you know, Volkswagen was created basically by Hitler. So, I mean, where do you draw the line here?

13:42They're crazy, but they're just crazy. So there is no line. It's just all raw emotion and craziness. That's all. And I never even thought she was that great an actress, to be honest with you. I didn't even recognize who she was. I have no idea. She was on Charmed. It was a witch TV show, and she was by far my least favorite one of the three. But, I mean, you know, whatever. What about the crypto crook? I don't even know his name. Oh, the crazy man that's in the Bahamas, Bermuda, or somewhere. Yeah. So, that story's fascinating to me. So he got all these people to include, like, I think Tom Brady and Tom Brady's soon-to-be ex-wife or two of them.

14:30All these other, you know, heavy hitter people, whatever, to invest in this company. And several people went on TV, like on, I mean, I'm not saying like on, you know, national TV, but like on those futures deals, like the Fox Business News and all this other stuff went on there and they're like this company is not legit this is not i mean like they played these clips of these people doing this and everybody still did it anyway and now the money poof be gone bye just a monster ponzi scheme is what it looks like and we're not talking about like a couple hundred thousand dollars we're talking like billions of dollars so well i i I had heard he gave $27 million to the midterm elections to Democrats.

15:19Try $42. $42 million. That's what he's given to the Democratic Party. I don't know how it was split between the midterms. $42 million. Yeah. And that wasn't his money to give, I don't think. But, I mean, he did it anyway. I think there's no money there left. I don't even know where. It's hard to wrap my head around. which and isn't the company called ftd no that's a florist i don't even know what the company's but anyway um something like that it's it's something like that but anyway uh my whole thing is this man has done this i don't think that he's like saying that he didn't do it and they have footage of him like in a home that he used this funds to buy with in either the very nice home yeah either in the bahamas or bermuda or whatever like he he's no consequences at all i don't know i don't know the bahamas or wherever he's at if they extradite to the u.s but i assume that he needs to find him a country that that he cannot be extradited because i i have a feeling they're coming for him and i i think the man needs to be in jail like that is i could go a step further i'm sure you could that's why you like that little idiot in ukraine

16:41But I'm just saying, like, I think the man does not need to be, you know, like hanging out shirtless on top of his balcony, waving at people. I think the man needs to be in jail. But well, I would agree. And I'm and I'm not going to give my necessarily opinion on crypto and whether we should use crypto or invest in or anything. But this little stunt here takes away. I thought you were invested in crypto. I had I had some Bitcoin and we actually had people. Okay. I know you had something at some point. And I'm in favor of some concept, and I don't know what it is, but I think this is total crap that every country around the world can print as much money as they want without gold backing it up, and we have some world bank or the markets dictate, I guess, what the value of that dollar is or that peso.

17:34I think it's a messed up system. I've tried to understand it, and I don't. It just doesn't logically make sense to me. When we had to have enough gold reserves stored, owned by that country to back up the currency, that makes perfect sense. But the way the currency is right now, to me, it's of no more value than the paper that it's printed on. I don't understand how it continues to have value when we continue to print millions and billions or trillions of dollars as well as other countries. and you've seen the value of the peso in other countries just dropped almost nothing, I'm not so sure that can't happen to more developed countries, or I shouldn't even say that, to us, basically.

18:14So I'm in favor of some type of U.S. or world currency that there is X amount, and you do not make more of it. You can increase the value and divide it into smaller portions, but this is it. We don't just make more of it automatically and bail ourselves out of this debt just to put it off into something worse. So I don't know where that is, but I do know that this gentleman, we don't even know his name, really put a big hit on cryptocurrency in general. And again, I'm not saying that we need to move to cryptocurrency, but it looked like some of it was getting some traction for a while. it's at least a concept or an idea i suspect at some point there'll be a the world bank or a government will adopt this type of currency and it will not be in privately owned hands it'll be more government controlled enough said with that what else i don't know that i was very busy i i judged lots of shows this past weekend, like I think 16,000.

19:21So I don't have a whole lot of time. And currently held captive in Cherie's home. Not for long, but yeah, right now I have to record a podcast. But yeah, so I don't know. I thought there was something else that was very strange that happened that I mean, there's lots of strange things going on. We talked about Elon. Oh, you wanted to brag on your Speaker of the House. I did. Oh, yeah. No. Oh, yeah. About forgot that one. Yeah, I did. Dylan Klifton, again, and I said this on the podcast, and they told me I was wrong, and I'm not wrong.

20:06I like to bring that up. Even Klifton interrupted me and said, oh, no. Nope. I was right. They're wrong. So. He pulled the plug on the recording for a short period. When we talked about that McCarty got the nomination from the GOP to be speaker, that does not make him speaker, as I said. They vote in January, and you have to have 218 votes to have the majority of the votes if everybody shows up. Here's the problem. There are five people, and I watched two of them last night on TV, live on Fox News, that are not going to vote for McCarty.

20:48Regardless. Political suicide, if they do not. Political suicide. I believe it's a bluff. I don't think it is. They were on TV last night and clearly stated that they would not vote. So they're going to sustain or vote for somebody in the Democratic Party? They didn't say. They said that, but they didn't say, but they said they will not be casting their vote for him for Speaker. He can lose four votes in the Republican Party and still retain his Speakership or become the Speaker, but he cannot lose five. Five have publicly stated that they will not vote for him, and two of them were on last night. So again I don't know what's going to happen here But by thinking that there's going to be A Republican speaker You better pray a lot Is all I can say Just telling you there's no way it cannot happen I sent you the article Did you not read it?

21:46I did not I lied to you and told you I did Yeah So when all this goes down in January You're going to be like oh shit If there is a Republican representative in the House that causes the Republicans not to hold the speaker position, that to me is insane. Even if they don't like who they're voting for, it's better than the other side. So I just can't. I understand they don't like him. I get that. And I get that they don't want to vote for him. But when it comes down to it, don't you believe they will? I do not believe the two people that I listened to last night will. No, I do not. And that's possible.

22:27And I think that you could have two, three. You said you had to have five that don't. I can see four. No, no. He can lose four. He can lose four votes and still win. Five. In the article I sent you, Joe, you guys say that you refuse to read because you do not like it when I'm right. Five have publicly stated they are not voting for him. That means he no becomes the speaker. Then who does? That's kind of why it's a newsworthy article. Why I sent it to you. FYI. But no, fine. continue to bury your hand in the sand like an ostrich and don't worry about it sometimes i'm a little busy sometimes i have other things going on than to read articles sometimes you just don't want to admit when i'm right and actually no shit okay we're gonna move on off of current events yeah we did get to i appreciate you allowing me to discuss china a little bit i mean maybe it was you just tested a lot i don't know what else you want to discuss about it i mean at this point I would I'm with the people I hope they take him out okay I just think that you're getting your hopes up a little bit I am not going to deny that

23:33I have to have hope because there has to be something that changes I'm all for it I hope they win I hope whatever like I hope they find I think somebody should just like drop ship a whole bunch of like Uzis over there in the streets and let them have at it okay I'm all You know, in all seriousness, just about as effective as dropping weapons down to them is the fact. I think Elon needs to give them Starlink. I think we need to give them access to the Internet so they can see what's going on in the west of the world. More access to unrestricted Internet so they can see what's going on in the rest of the world. And just giving them that information is huge.

24:00 Junior league standings update

24:13And I think it's happening through various methods. Okay. I would like to give a huge thank you to Show Fresh H2O. Their continued support of this podcast is appreciated and it makes it possible for this podcast to release an episode each and every week. If you have not tried Show Freshest H2O, please do so. Available at your local supply trailer or SwampFox.com. Do you have any BTR, JLA? Yes, I do. Thank you very much. Why are you trying to rush? You act like, is there a fire going on in your phone? Is there a fire going on in your phone? I don't think you're going to read any more of the top 10 in those. I thought you mentioned that. Last week was the last age division.

24:53Now I'm going for the top 10 overalls because we're at the final. We're running out to the end here. So doing the top 10 overalls. This will be the last time that we do the top 10 overall GOAT for this year. And this is going to shake up because, again. What about at the very end? We're going to have to do it. I mean, on the podcast. Dale, I don't think you want me to read all of the winners on the podcast. That would be like six podcasts at the end of the year. The overall, I think, would be good. Oh, my God. No, Dale. You let me worry about this. Anyway. Just keep going. You have it. This is going to shake up because, again, we're waiting on Kansas City and Louisville's results.

25:31We have been in contact with them. I had a message yesterday. They are coming. And, again, those points are double. So, this will change. But right now, probably the most competitive division throughout the year was the GOATs. And right now, there's a four-way tie for first with a perfect score, basically, even, I mean, and Colby Wilson, Audrey Poling, Ashley Poling, and Jordan Ashe all have 510 points. Piper Lisko has 500 points. Evan Ditzler has 495. Reagan Rogers has 470.

26:13Paisley Carseland has 440. Kira Rogers has 440. And Michael Rosell has 432. So there you go. Excellent. Congratulations to the top 10. Right. And I would like, because as we are rounding out our year, this is going to be the last few couple weeks, So we can give a shout out to our 2022 sponsors. I would like to thank our corporate sponsors for this year. Show Coat Solutions, Leonard Trucks and Trailers, J.H. Cattle, Minnie Hereford's Minnie Mafia Publication, and Brock Farm Angus. Those were our national corporate sponsors this year. We really appreciate their support, and we hope they will be back for 2023.

26:56Excellent, excellent. Today's topic, Livestock Judging Contest Etiquette. Ryan, there's a lot to talk about here Yes, and this is Dale's topic I don't remember what sent him all into got him all Twitter-pated, but it's a good topic and so I appreciate that he came up with it but I think the best way to tackle this is there are many different ways that people are involved in a livestock judging contest way beyond being just the person that is competing and marking cards And for it to be a successful contest and a well-run contest and an effective contest, everybody that plays a role in it really has to step up and give it their all.

27:42And so I think we should go through the different roles of people being involved and say the things that we think are vital to making their positions as good as they can be. But I mean, we can start with being, you know, the contestant, I guess, because that's what most people feel like is the most important. And so I think one of the things as a contestant that you really need to do is I think you need to have confidence in your placing. And there have been some incidents as of late where maybe that contest doesn't give the reasons takers the placings of the kids.

27:45 Contestants: confidence, honesty, respect

28:35And we just have the honor system. And maybe you switch your placing and do something, talk a different placing than what you actually turned in. That's happened as of late. I'm not going to say when, but last couple years or so. And that's really, really not the way to go. And when, I'm just going to tell you, when you find out that somebody's done that, and it's for sure and for real, and like, for instance, if you're the reason taker and you listen to that kid and they gave you, my placing is one, two, three, four.

29:16and afterwards the livestock official, the judging contest officials come to you and say, hey, you gave this kid a 48 and he placed it 1, 2, 3, 4 and the actual placing is 4, 2, 3, 1. How did he talk a 48 with that bat of mark? It pisses you off. I'm just going to tell you. And that's going to stick with you and that kid and that team forever. Agreed completely. I think you can go even a step further. And I was thinking on a broader scale as well as some of the specifics. But as a contestant, if you stop and think about all the effort, and I know there's a lot of different levels. Here's your local county contest that maybe we kind of throw together in a matter of an hour or so, and all the way up to, let's put it up on a pedestal, the senior college contest at Louisville.

30:08their national contests. So we've got everything in between there. But as we start progressing up from your county to your state to your national FFA and 4-H and junior college and senior college contests, there's a lot of effort and work that's put forth to put on those contests. So I believe as a contestant, you need to respect that. You need to be professional. You need to be very, very respectful of those around you and those that are putting on this event and conduct yourself accordingly. And Ryan brings out that the situation where if the reasons officials do not have the card, that there has been contestant or contestants in the past that may change your placing that obviously is going to improve the reason score. That is unacceptable on every level, period. I can also speak from experience in my years coaching in the junior college and senior college levels historically speaking and it still continues today there are some contestants and ryan said they need to have more confidence in their placing some contestants that uh feel better about taking a survey does that make sense ryan i don't know actually i understand yeah i know what

31:21you're talking about no so that they will they will travel behind the other contestants trying to get a placing off their notebook or stand and this happens sometimes depending on whether the group leader is aware of this or not. But sometimes they call cards in in a certain order, or you're allowed to turn your card into the group leader in any order. But some contestants will make an effort to stand near that group leader. And as each card's turned in, they can kind of take a survey of those placings before they commit to theirs. And this has been going on for as long as I, when I was competing in contests and coaching, and it still happens today. And I'll talk a little bit about that as we discuss some of the roles of group leaders, but it goes back to Ryan mentioning have confidence in your placing. You hear stories about different teammates ending up discussing things in the bathroom or casual contact when they're walking past each other or showing each other notebooks. This doesn't need to happen. It just doesn't. And I understand as contest officials, not, I should say, those putting on the contest, you can't prevent it all.

32:27And I think many do take very large steps to keep it as clean and as honest as they possibly can. But ultimately, the responsibility comes down to the contestants, and they need to appreciate this particular event for what it is and that those things don't need to happen. No, and I do think that the majority of the contest have taken as many steps as they have to keep it whatever. I mean, you know, I can remember when they figured out how to use Apple Watches to communicate. And, you know, you can go back and a hundred different things. They had hand signals or whatever, all this other stuff. But if someone wants to go down that path, just like you said, they can go to the restroom and whatever and all this other stuff.

33:14If that's the way they want to do it, then they're going to find a way. Again, this is like just in a livestock show. this is not the majority. This is by far the minority, but there are going to be people in everything that are not going to want to play by the rules. And so, again, I think that the majority of people in charge of conducts have taken all the steps they can to make it as fair of in as possible. But it goes back to what I'm saying. If we would just have confidence in what our placings are, and do our own work, and go out there, and turn them in, and let the chips fall where they might, because some days you're going to have a bad day, some days you're going to miss a class, etc.

34:04But it is something that I think that that is something that is really out there and real, and I wish that could be different. And maybe another perspective to look at it from that contestant, think about it in this manner that those things usually get noticed by somebody and there's discussion about it in the fact that you're not playing by the rules. Even if you succeed is probably going to stick with you much longer. That stamp, that negative blemish on you as a person is going to stick with you longer than maybe the win of that contest. Definitely agree with that completely. So, so think about that guys, where you're at BB.

34:47I mean, if you're just looking out for yourself, it doesn't work. It doesn't calculate long term. The results of that contest are minimal compared to the stamp that you're going to be or the blemish that's going to be put upon you because of the actions you took during that. So yeah, I think a great, great direction to go. And there's lots to talk about in here, Ryan. What about, and again, we have various contests and some contests don't have a designated superintendent, but the role of it, let's take some of our bigger, larger contests, whether they're 4-H, FFA, junior college, senior college, they have a contest superintendent. And I think a lot of this starts right here, that we need a superintendent that's been involved in those trenches, whether a contestant, a coach, very current in the industry, and have the ability to bring together a team that understands the importance of their role in making this contest to success. And I think we've got some great superintendents out there. And it's interesting to me because to my knowledge, there are very few, if any, that are actually paid for what they're

35:15 Superintendents and group leaders

35:49doing. It's voluntary and maybe their expenses are covered, but it takes a lot of time to put on a well-run professional national level type contest. And for that, I do appreciate those superintendents that step up and do those things. Yeah, and I do think that, you know, and this is terrible to say, but the integrity of the contest and how good the contest is, it all kind of lies on that person there, because they're going to make the large majority of the decisions that affect that contest. And so, and it's just like you said, these people aren't paid. They volunteer, here and most of them are excellent at what they do and we're very very thankful to have them out here but they kind of are the grand poobah as you say and so a lot of whether the contest is a success and the integrity lives and dies in that person they're making those decisions on appointing group leaders that understand their role and bringing officials in that are that are current and take upon the responsibility that that's put forth. So yeah, huge, absolutely huge.

37:02Let's, let's hit group leaders. We kind of touched on a little bit before on when we're talking about the contestants, but I think there's, and we always say, well, we can grab anybody to be a group leader. Well, I think you can, anybody can walk from students from class to class and collect cards, but I also believe they need to be somewhat positive and most importantly, aware of what's going on with those contestants, aware of what's going on with that class. They can make or break a contest for the kids in their group by not paying attention to what's going on, or they can make it a very positive experience by engaging. So we talked about there's always been contestants that are going to try to look off of others' notebooks, and that's a subjective call, whether they are or aren't. That's very difficult. I think as a group leader, you probably bring it to the contest superintendent's attention, maybe give that person a warning.

37:55I don't have an answer, and I think each contest superintendent's going to handle it differently. But let's go beyond that. Let's think about later in the day, Ryan, when you've got somebody driving hogs that just decides they don't want to drive them very much, and the hogs are pretty much in one position. Or you have people leading livestock that are kind of giving up. Anything that that group leader can do to insert themselves and be a little encouraging, hey, let's get these animals moved. Let's get them presented correctly. I think they're the ones there at the class. If there's not a class manager that's overseeing those kinds of things, that can make a huge, huge difference on how they're conducting themselves, making sure that everybody gets that chance if we're to set them up and give them five seconds or whatever it is to handle. Just make sure it's all structured and done in a manner that is fair to everybody.

38:45yeah i think one of the biggest things about being a group leader that can pretty much if you have this quality or trade in a group leader then they can pretty much is as long as they're aware and they stay aware you know they don't zone out during it because i mean however many classes there are however many rounds but you've got to stay aware of the situation aware of the contestants aware of the people that are, just like you said, leading the animals, showing the animals, all those things. Just stay up, stay aware, keep your mind on what's going on, because you may just think that you're a group leader, but you are way more than that. Because in terms of the kids in that group, like you said, unless there is a class manager, it is your responsibility not only to ensure that everybody's kind of, you know, doing their own work, not taking a survey of cards, all that other stuff, but also that those kids who saw the market sheep the very first class of the day get just as good a look when it's the last round or the last class in that round. And a group

40:03leader is a big part of that. And, uh, and so I think just being aware and staying on top of things is something that is really a trait that we need to have in those group leaders. And it's interesting that that group leader, because they are the ones kind of in that trench with that group, they, they will have as much of an impact on whether that is a successful contest and a fair contest for all as anybody. And, and that is, that is saying a lot. And I appreciate those group leaders that go out there and they are aware and they're doing that job to make sure it all happens. There's so many things that come into making this contest good. And Ryan and I are always wanting that perfect. And it may be never going to be perfect, but we sure have to do everything we can to make it as good as we can. And I'll talk about this later because you stop and think about it. When you get to that senior college level at the senior college contest at the North American, your national contest. Those kids may have started out when they began in 4-H at eight, nine, 10 years old in contests and progressed into more serious contests through

41:10senior 4-H or FFA in high school and on into junior college. The amount of their life that was dedicated to improving their ability to evaluate and discuss livestock is huge, especially once they hit that national 4-H, national FFA level on into junior college and senior college, I cannot even come up with a number in terms of how many hours that they would dedicate to this particular event to get to that final point, that national senior college contest. And it's huge. You can't do something half-ass when you stop and think about the time and effort that all of those contestants put in, the coaches, everybody behind the scenes, all of those, I think just stopping and thinking about that, you're going to do everything you can to make it as good as you can.

42:02No, and you are right. And I think that's the purpose of this topic and for the podcast is I think every single person that's involved in a judging contest, whether they know it or not, they have an effect on the outcome of that contest in some way. And so until they realize that, because I don't think many group leaders think that their job is important or anything like that, every single person that is involved in that contest at some point, depending on how well they do what they're supposed to be doing, yeah, it has an effect.

42:46So I think that's why we need to make people aware of this And that's why we need to have this topic. Let's, let's even make it a touch more real and I'm going to take it. And I know I'm leaning on the senior college contest a lot just because Ryan, you're an official there. And I was able to discuss things after the contest with you. And I was present during, during that contest. I believe at the awards breakfast, one point separated the top two teams, Ryan, this year. Is that correct? That is correct. I believe I may be confused. I'm pretty sure. Think about, no, it's one point. It was one book. No, wait, one point. yeah one point one or two two it was a very low number okay yeah so one or two i can't remember exactly in going back to ryan's point every person involved makes a difference whether that official puts a two-point cut or a four-point cut on that class all of a sudden you have a different national champion team and even if it wasn't one point this year it has been that way in the past at times And usually it seems like it always comes down to very few points, even not just individually, but as the team.

43:52And that cut makes a difference. If that group leader or that person driving those hogs decides not to drive them real well in that last round and we didn't get a good look. And that one contestant on one team that ended up second flipped a pair that maybe they would have had the opposite if they'd have got a better look at those hogs. That determines the national champion team. It's amazing that reason's official. that one point or two points on a 47 versus a 49 or whatever it may be, that one small decision, and think about, there's thousands of these decisions being made in a contest. In every contest. But every last one of them, yeah, every last one of them could have the impact on who is the national champion or who wins that given contest.

44:15 Officials: preparation and phone distractions

44:35So it's incredible to me that it comes down to those things that we don't think about. Let's talk about officials, Ryan. Obviously, and I'll state the obvious and then let you jump in, they need to be qualified. They need to fully understand the importance of their officiating. And it's always going to be subjective. Each person has their own opinions. Ryan, I talked about life experiences and your environment and what you're currently doing is going to impact how you sort livestock. And that's human nature. We know that this isn't an absolute, that it is subjective when you go into these contests. But Ryan, tell us the responsibilities of those officials.

45:18Well, again, I think, you know, talking about whoever the manager is or whoever's in charge, picking the officials, I do think that it needs to go beyond the fact that those people are current in their knowledge of the situation or their species that they're being asked to be a committee on. I think it also needs to be that those people want to be there and want to be involved. And because, again, everybody, the officials are going to turn in their cars, and a lot of times it's not going to be very similar. When Brent Jennings was giving his remarks in the Grand Champion Goat Drive at Louisville, he served on the Sheep and Goat Committee. And he said that, you know, that there were six of them on that committee. And this should be so easy to mark four animals. But most of the times, it wasn't easy for them. And I can tell you, I was on the cattle committee. It was not easy for us.

46:14We had several of those classes that we officiated that six people, we had six different cards marked. And so it's not easy. But I think the thing is, if you want to be there and you want to be involved and you want to make the contest the best, that's something that needs to be there in the official. And a lot of that is actually taking place in the discussion of how is this going to work out in the end. these are the cards. What do we think is the best solution? And I'll be honest with you, there was one lady on our committee, Deb Corr, and she referenced several times that we got to keep what's best for the contest and what's best for the contestants in mind when we were talking about how those needed to be. And she was dead on accurate on that. And so again, and I'm not saying that everybody does this, but I have been on committees before because I've been on lots of lifestyle judging committees where nobody said a word. They're just like, okay, whatever. Then you're really not doing your part. And so not only do you have to be current, but you've also got to want to be there and be active. And then another thing that is becoming a problem, and

47:34they brought that up to us at Louisville. After the cards are marked, after the placings are done, and you're going to that reasons room, it is a long, drawn-out process. I don't care what such contest it is. It's a monotonous and it's a tedious process. I understand that. You've got to give your full attention to every single one of those kids. It's not easy. It's not. I'm not going to lie to you. It is a very hard job. But the cell phone texting and stuff like that is kind of getting out of control for officials.

48:15And I mean, they brought it up to us before reasons. And so if you are an official, I am as attached to my two cell phones as anybody in the history of the world to the fact that I sleep with one in my hand. Okay? but I can put them away and listen to those kids just like I can put in my bag and judge a show and all that and then again you know in between sets if you need to check return a text whatever that's fine but even if that phone is just sitting there and it's on vibrate or whatever and it vibrates or moves and the desk, you know, makes a sound or it lights up. Those are all distraction.

49:02And so just got to put it away. And again, the biggest thing is with all of this is they are volunteers too, just like the general manager, just like the group leaders, all this other stuff. And so I get that you're volunteering your time. You're not getting paid for this. and that decisions, whether your business, all this stuff, go on during this time, please still put the phone up during reasons. Absolutely. And Ryan, I think you hit on something very key. They have not only qualified and current and all the things that appear to be obvious, they want to be there and they want to take part in officiating that contest.

49:43And if they want to be there, the likelihood of them putting that cell phone away or not texting during a set of reasons or all the things that you mentioned are far less likely. I think they're going to conduct themselves in a manner that is very professional if they want to do it. If they're doing it because they're asked, they really didn't want to do it, then we're going half-hearted into it, and that doesn't work. This is something that I'm glad you brought up because you just said it. If they're just doing it because they've been asked. Well, you know, we've talked about this in terms of people judging shows. There's not many people that are going to say no. They're just not. I don't know why, unless there's a big conflict and they can't be there, especially if it's one of those bigger national contests, they're not going to say no.

50:33And but so that is something that I think people that serve on committees and all this other stuff, if you maybe you've done it 100 times before, I don't know, but you've really got to want to be there to make it work because there are going to be discussions. There are going to be things that are not pleasant on a committee. It's not like we have a party back there. And you've really got to want to be an active part and make it the best you can be if you're going to serve as an official. No, and I want to let this lead into another part while we're on the reason side of it.

51:00 Scoring reasons: one room or split

51:17Ryan talks about how monotonous. I don't remember how many reasons I listened to at a contest in Kansas here not very long ago, but it was hours and hours and hours. And it is very, very difficult to give your full attention to each and every set, but you have to do your best to do so. I think one of the solutions to that, and I don't see it as much anymore as I used to, but at Louisville it was very very traditional that in both the junior and senior college that they would split reasons and do an A and a B they'd have the two reasons listeners listen to the first 10 sets or or however many of the contest superintendent asked them to together to try to get a bearing on where their scores are and try to get them as similar as possible but guess what when you have two different officials separate listening to different sets one in group A and one in group B, they are not going to be scored the same.

52:13And I'm not saying one official is wrong and one official is right. It's subjective and it's not going to be there. When this would happen, unfortunately, in the reasons division, and ultimately, remember, we're talking about entire teams winning or losing contests by one or two points, depending on which, if you had three people listening on side A and two on B versus flipped, that may have taken you over the top in the reasons division because side A was a little more generous. And there's nothing anybody's doing wrong. It's just the circumstance that is there and it's going to happen. It's human nature. It's subjective. It's all of those things.

52:51So when we have situations like that, it does improve, Ryan. It cuts the people in half that you have to listen to. So you're probably giving more attention or able to easier give more attention to each and every contestant, but you're possibly giving to two different reasoned officials as far as your teammate or versus somebody on another team, whatever it may be. I think it takes, it throws a little bit more into the area of luck or randomness on which reason listener you get to give to and whether they are going to score you a little higher or a little lower. And each and every point affects the contest. I'm not trying to be negative on this because I think it was a necessity at one time.

53:29But if we don't have that many contestants, then we can condense it down to have one or two people in the same room listening, absolutely in favor of that. It might even be a positive, Ryan, to have two people in that room that are independently writing scores down where it doesn't come across. Maybe if you're just giving to one listener, there's one term that just hit that person bad and you get dinged three or four points for it, where it may not bother nine other officials. So two of them in the same room probably gives us a little better balance across the board, and we simply write the scores down. If you come up with a half point, average, bump that half point up or bump it down, round up or down just so you're consistent.

54:10I think that gives a truer, I guess, evaluation of each and every contestant's ability to give reasons rather than splitting into two groups, which was a necessity at one time. So I appreciate where we're going this direction. I can't emphasize enough what Ryan said, how difficult, and there's a lot of people out there listening that have sat through those reasons room and listened to hundreds of sets of reasons. It is just hard to do, and we have to do our best to give our full attention to each and every one of those kids. But that's my rant for the moment. Let's, if possible, let's condense and give to that one or two officials in the same room rather than splitting them up.

54:55And I don't even know, Ryan, at senior college, I believe you had two officials in the room, so they did not split them this year. I'm not sure on junior college. I think some of our numbers collegiately have condensed a little bit, so they're not having to do a group A and B. But I have not been involved in it directly as much here recently. The three years that I have been, which is the last three years that I have been on the North American senior college deal, how it worked is in the first year was rona year so again you know craziness uh but two people listened to the same set of reasons and uh we scored independently after the first five we talked about trying to get our balance but we're in the same room and then uh after the first five independently and then we didn't know whose score would count or whose wasn't but supposedly half my scores counted for half the contestants and whoever I listen with half the scores counted.

55:59And we never knew, you know, which kid it was that our score would count or not. So, and that's how it's gone the past few years. And from what I have been told, because this has been, you know, a heated discussion for several of the officials through out the three years is that the coaches, This is the system that the coaches have come up with and what they want. And so I can see a million different ones. Like you said, back in the day when there was an A and B, you fell on the easier side or you didn't. And that was just luck of the draw. And that was something that you accepted going in.

56:41I get what Dale's saying. And if there's going to be two of them in there, then you take the two scores, you put them together, round up or down, be consistent on that. I can see that being a way to. Another thing is, if you don't, I realize that they don't want to limit the number of officials on those committee because you need as many opinions as possible. to make it a well-rounded contest, to get as much knowledge and different opinions in there as you can in terms of the placings, I'll be honest with you. I think there would be people if you just... Because to be just completely honest, the most fair way is for whoever is taking Market Stairs to hear everybody in the contest on Market Stairs.

57:35I mean, and score them accordingly. I think there would be people that would say, hey, I don't have to listen to reasons this afternoon. I'm here, did this, whatever, that's fine. Louisville's a three-year term. Maybe you don't get to listen to reasons when you're, I don't know, but there's lots of different ways to go about it and do it. I'm not saying what the perfect way is, but that's always going to be something that's going to be up for debate and always need to put new thoughts and spins on it because there's probably never going to be a perfect way to do that. But I'll just throw my two cents in there.

58:15If the contest is not as huge as it used to be like it is now, I had to listen to every single kid for the past three years regardless. I do think the most fair way of any contest, If somebody's going to listen to every set of reasons, then that one person be the score because that person is going to be the most consistent with their own. No, but I think the less we leave to random chance, the better. And that's just what it comes down to. And it is never going to be perfect. And it just is what it is. So I appreciate that discussion.

58:30 Selecting classes for the contest

58:56another part we haven't talked about is there there are people assigned to go out and select the classes and and find those classes whether they're coming off a farm whether they're coming out of the show at louisville lots of different directions they can come but that that person whether they're and a lot of times they they they would prefer that person is not on the official committee because you have biases when you're picking those classes out how you want them and And I get that. But those selections on those classes are going to play a huge role. When we're putting these classes together, there needs to be some form of logic, maybe some relative importance within the industry.

59:35And we understand everything's subjective and animals that may work well aren't always available. So those people out there selecting those classes, that is a difficult job. very, very difficult because you're working with what's available and trying to make that class fit a logical pretense. And it's just not always possible, I guess. And I think probably the most difficult thing about that is, or two things that are the most difficult thing about it. First off, there are some people that they contact and they say, will you bring a class? Of course, Dale didn't do it this year, but years before, you have brought a class of does to Louisville. And so you bring five or six and they put them together and send the best class out there. Now they don't come to your farm and do that. So they rely on you to get those ones up there and pick them out and try to make it logical. Well, not everybody that gets asked to do that is going to send the very best that they can. And I understand that. And so I think that makes it hard because when they bring them in, sometimes it's only six that you can choose from. There's got to be four in a class. I think the other part of that is if

1:00:52they are going out on a show at Louisville and selecting, you know, hey, we're going to have a class of Angus bulls. Well, they're just going around the stalls and they're saying, hey, can we use this bull from point A to point B tomorrow, all this other stuff. Very rarely can they get those animals together as a group and see them like you would see them in the class of four tomorrow. Because I can't tell you how many times that regardless of the contest and people that are in this job, and I think it's one of the toughest jobs that there are, and the most thankless job because just like you said, these people aren't on the committee.

1:01:37Very few times do they get any of the glory or any of the pats on the back or thank you, and this is probably as crucial a job as any. But I've heard it, well, you know, last night, this class made more sense before we saw them all together. And that's part of it. And that's just being honest. That's true. And, I mean, that's going to happen. It just is. It's just all there is to it. Because until you can see them four side-by-side like a judging team contestant would, it's going to be very hard to not to know if it makes sense or not. And I've heard that at almost every single contest, and it's just part of it.

1:02:22And so I do think that the person that's in charge of picking out the classes, they have such a hard job. again, not everybody's going to let them use their stuff, use their stock. I can go through and tell you 900 challenges for that person. And the one thing that I want to say to those people that do take that on, I appreciate you. I understand it's not easy. I understand that you, again, there's lots of people that come up and shake my hand or tell me thank you after a contest for being official, listen to it, they don't go to that person and they are just as integral a part, just as important part and probably have the toughest job of anybody.

1:03:00 Class descriptions and scenarios

1:03:08So from me to you, people in those roles, thank you. Absolutely. Well, well said. There's one that I'm going to, I'm going to throw a personal spin on maybe because it's difficult for me and Ryan can come in and say, well, that's crazy. It's not, it's not that difficult. But if I look at judging contest, the history of judging contest over the past 20 years or whatever time frame you want to look at, for me personally right now, the actual class description and or a scenario that they put on is probably as important to me now as it's ever been. To me, that actual description or scenario makes a huge difference in how we align that class.

1:03:51If contest officials are not giving specific guidance, that contestant needs to make that judgment call. And I think we're in a situation, and it's probably been going on for years, I'm just more detached than I was at one time. But we used to go into a local contest and maybe everything came from a commercial perspective. You had commercial market hogs. There were no show livestock and we kept it a little more real world. we go to a contest like Louisville and everything's pulled out of the show and we're sorting them a little more like show livestock, but there, there is a big difference there. And if we, we stop and think about it, that class description, and I'm not even saying going all the way to a scenario.

1:04:30Usually we don't have scenarios unless we have data, but occasionally you'll have just a, a scenario that's stating what this class is used for without any data going with it. And that's okay because it gives those contestants direction. It puts them all on the same path. So if you walk up to a class of market hogs, let's start with hogs, Ryan, real quick. And they appear they just came off a feeding floor. Ryan, are you going to sort those as an official more like show hogs or more like a commercial set of hogs that are probably going to market shortly? Well, I think, again, that goes back to the individual official. But probably if they look like commercial hogs, you're probably going to tend to sort them more like that.

1:05:10Yeah. And I think that, and there's not as, we don't see as many of those in our collegiate contest, maybe as we did at one time, but we see it in the 4-H and the FFA contest. But if we've got a set of hogs that comes in there that the hair, their clip, the skin and hair is right, all those things are right. Does that not tell you, hey, this is like sorting show hogs? It should give you that indication. So I don't know that we needed an absolute description on, on something like that, but in some situations, and if we move into cattle, you could get a class of feedlot steers. Do they still have feedlot steers at Denver? Do you know, Ryan, in the collegiate contest?

1:05:45They, they used to have it. That was kind of the one contest that, that they, they have this, this feedlot steer class. And obviously we're, we're not looking at them as show steers. So those, those were breaking down their apparent performance and where their carcass characteristics are and all those kinds of things. But if we shift gears, we've got some very unhappy dogs here. I think if we shift gears and we've got a set of cattle out there are a set of heifers, we were going to clearly know if these are clip show cattle or if they're just brought in off the range. And these are kind of some replacement commercial heifers, but it's nice to maybe have that, that class description.

1:06:24if we want to be able to sort those or know where the officials are and all the contestants are kind of on that same page. For example, if we have a class of bulls, they're obviously going to be placed different if these are producing commercial replacement heifers or these are going to be used in the elite show operations to continue the production of junior show heifers. There's a lot of different things we can do with that. And that scenario and or class description, if there's any chance there can be confusion, needs to maybe clarify that to it to a certain degree, at least in my opinion. But the contestant, if it's not there, you can look at those animals and kind of make that designation.

1:07:04Yeah, these are show animals or no, these are a little more commercial based. And I think that's part of it. We have the common issue in goats all the time. And every time I supply a class of goats, I let that person know that's contacting me. These are going to be wether dams or weather based genetics. They're not full bloods or not percentage registered goats. So consequently, you're going to look at them a little bit different. If we have a class of full blood does or percentage does, we're going to put a lot more emphasis on performance and frame size and just how fast they've grown. We're going to look at their horn set. We're going to look at pigmentation, things that like horn set and pigmentation.

1:07:42If you're giving me reasons on weather based genetics, I could care less what that is. It has zero impact on how I'm making a breeding decision, how I'm sorting those animals. So there is a difference. And we walk up to a doe class and it just says does or breeding does. And we don't know if they're wether dams. We don't know if they're full bloods. That's that's that becomes confusing. Some kids will try to decide one way or the other on their own. But those are simple things that I guess it falls back, Ryan, onto the contest superintendent just to maybe a quick walk through or just. clarify that this all makes sense. And I'm probably going further with this than needed, but I know that we run into situations like that that really confuse some of those contestants because they're looking at it from a completely different angle than maybe what the officials are.

1:08:32And Ryan, I don't think, I think it must be in junior college. Did you have any fit breeding sheep or frame sheep at the senior college contest? I know you weren't on the sheep committee, but I don't know if you looked at. I don't think they did. Now, one of the classes, of heifers were fed, but I don't remember. So on the junior college contest, historically, they bring a set of what I'd call frame sheep, breeding sheep out of the show at Louisville. And it's the largest breeding sheep show in the world, I believe. Well, they'd be Shropshire's or whatever breed they may be. And that might be the only contest you truly see that level of frame sheep that have been cut out and fit and all of those things.

1:09:15And you're going to look at those so much differently than you'd look at a class of, say, wether dam use. No question, totally different. And I think the assumption is at most contests in the sheep arena or the sheep portion of the contest, we're placing those more on how they would produce wethers or that side of the industry than we are the true breeding, purebred, frame sheep side of it. And I think it's a little bit because that's what's available to bring that when they reach out to producers or wherever they're at to bring a class, there's more people on that side of the industry. And there's still those elite, really good breeders out there in frame sheet, but they're not maybe as readily available as there are on the weather genetic side.

1:10:02So I was bringing that up just because, and I guess it falls under the contest superintendent. Let's make sure that our class name gives some direction if there's any confusion whatsoever or that scenario. And obviously, if there's a scenario, it's giving a great deal of direction. Ryan, where are you at? We're forgetting all kinds of things, I'm sure. No, I think we've covered almost everything. And the only other thing that I want to address in terms of the fact that, and I don't know if this is at every contest, but I have noticed it at Louisville every single year. And I don't, this isn't bashing these kids at all.

1:10:30 Handlers, class managers, officials' time

1:10:47At Louisville, you know, the people that show the animals are kids that unfortunately did not get to mark cards that day. and you add into the fact that's the very last contest, that's the national contest, all this other stuff, there is 900 million emotions that those kids are filled with right there when you don't get those cards to mark. I don't know what that's like. Obviously, I marked at Louisville, so I can't even begin to empathize with them. I do know kids that have gone through it, and they have relayed to me how it feels, And so I know that just point blank, it sucks. You've put all this into this in the very last contest. That's the one that means the most. You don't get the mark. And so I get that you're disappointed. You're mad. You're pissed. You're all of those things. But now you have a job to do and you have to go out there and you have to show that calf or you have to drive that hog or you have to hold that sheep or whatever it is. And every year, I have seen someone who you could tell they're over it, they're not happy about it, whatever, and it is now affecting how that animal

1:12:06looks in that class. And so all you're doing when we get to that point is you're making it harder for your team to do the best they can do because we're not doing what we need to do in terms of showing the animal. And again, I'm not bashing these kids at all. I don't know what that's like. I can only empathize with them. But if you're going to go out there and you're going to do it, you're going to have to, for those couple of hours, just to squash that inside you and do the best that you can because you're not only hurting your teammates' chances to do the best they can do when you're not showing that animal properly, it affects the whole contest. And I'm telling you, I know as an official, it affects the contest.

1:12:59No question whatsoever, Ryan. And that leads me to, I've got my Christmas wish list here. So if we have a lead cattle class or market goats or market lambs in a stand, we never have enough volunteers for the contest. We always could use more, but I think a class manager, maybe at that lead heifer class that maybe goes around. And if they notice one of those, those participants that's leading the cattle or showing the cattle's letting that head drop or not just maybe go around and say, Hey, let's, let's get this one's head up. Just, just monitor that and encourage them. Hey, when, when they're, when one of them isn't getting the job done, Hey, let's, let's, let's get back in gear. Let's get back focused to what we're doing. I think that that would help. And the same thing when those lambs are in stands, adjusting that headpiece to make sure everything's right, making sure that those lambs are standing square and in the same position.

1:13:48If the more people, the better from that standpoint, as far as not only a group leader there, but possibly a class manager to make sure some of that doesn't happen. But Ryan, you're right. It comes down to when we're talking about these lead classes, it comes down to that showman. And wow, does it make a difference if we've got that head up, we got that head down, we're on the move, whatever it may be, whether we're not setting the legs, whatever it may be, is going to make a difference. And I appreciate some of the referees and or contest superintendent, when I'm officiating contest, they'll want to hold off in giving those official cards and cuts to the scoring room until later in the day, because some of these animals are going to get tired.

1:14:29Some of these animals aren't going to look as good later in the day as they did earlier in the day. And I'm not saying we can change our placing because that's not fair to those contestants that went through originally, but we can adjust cuts accordingly. If we see an animal starting to fall apart that maybe made it up into that top pair or, or anything that we need to do. So that is one thing that I don't know that we touched on, but let's, let's as officials, let's look at them. Not just when we first get there in the morning, get our placing cuts. let's go back and look at a midday and maybe towards the end of that contest just to make sure that everything still looks the same.

1:15:05Okay. So we're going to probably disagree just a little bit here, but cause my final point and all this was is first off midday. And at the end of the day, normally these things are done in rounds. And so you're only, the contestants are only going to see them in that round. So I think the one thing that was kind of my final send-off on this is I think it is very important that the officials should have to mark their card in the same time frame that the contestants do. Because you're asking these contestants to make a decision on the alignment of these four animals in a number of minutes.

1:15:46And I agree. To be fair, I think that the officials should have to at the same time. Because I don't think it's fair for them to be able to go to one class and, you know what, I don't know. I'm going to bounce around to the next class and see if this one's easy and stuff like that. Because that's not how a kid or a contestant goes through that contest. And so if you're wanting to make it as correct and true and right for the kids in the contest, then you should be under the same parameters that they are. Now, do I agree with you on the fact that as that round goes, animals are going to tire out more readily than others?

1:16:30Stuff like that? Absolutely. Do I think after the officials have turned in their cards for that class, They've had the discussion whenever at the end of the round when the coaches are about to be letting in, do you want to go back and look and just make sure, say, hey, maybe we should adjust this cut right here because this one is what. That's fine. I get that and I understand that. But I do think something that we are overlooking in a large majority of these contests is the officials are not being put under the same parameters as the kids are to mark their cards within the same time and the same rules as those other kids.

1:17:14And I think they should. no but i and we agree 100 on that ryan and i and i i'm glad you brought that up and i think that you're also insinuating that they don't need to just wander around up close but maybe stay back within the parameters the exact parameters the kids are given literally i mean i think it should be as close i think it should be as close to what the contestants are doing as possible i mean And I mean, I just think that's what you're asking these kids to mark a placing on these four, given that you're allowed to stand here, stay here, only handle them once all the time.

1:17:57And I'm going to tell you, I'm guilty. I try not to be. Now, I will mark whatever, but I am guilty because they don't put any restraints on you of maybe going in a little closer. Because it's easy. If it's closed. Right, because it's easier. And again, I shouldn't do that because I'm the one saying that this isn't right. I do think this is something that needs to be worked on and needs to be addressed because I think the officials should have to mark the cards under the same duress that those kids are marking them under because it's not easy. It makes it way harder. Way harder.

1:18:37That's the one thing that I think that we need to look at more seriously, I guess. Very, very good point. Well, I think that concludes this. This was a good discussion, Ryan. I appreciate it, and hopefully that this gets out to plenty of listeners. And I know we didn't cover everything, and we didn't miss everything, and I don't want everybody to think that we think the judging contests are terrible or anything like that. I think they're great. That's why I've volunteered my time and all this other stuff. So I just, again, I think there are things that can be done better in every single level. And I do want to reiterate one more time that every single person that is involved in that contest is going to have an effect on the outcome.

1:19:24And just like Dale said, one or two points, I can't tell you how many times one or two points has decided whether a kid wins individual, team wins, not just at Louisville, but throughout contests, whatever. And every single person that partakes in that contest is going to have an effect. And so we've all just got to do the best that we can possibly do to make sure it's the most correct for those kids. Absolutely. Thank you, Ryan. It is time for your favorite portion, question and answer. Rosella gives us the first question. Can't we just not do?

1:19:30 Q&A: breed characteristics

1:20:04can we just not maybe the christmas edition in december it's the holiday season no i i i i took at least five minutes to find these before we started so we're gonna do them rosella hello first of all first of all i would like to thank both of you for this podcast and everything you do for the livestock community if it weren't for people such as you are showing our showing days would have been over when our girls aged out of FFA. Instead, they are looking to make this a significant part of their lives going forward. So thank you so much for everything that you do for the kids and all the future generations. It is greatly appreciated.

1:20:45My question is a little complex. I've heard you talk many times about breed characteristics, and while it's easy to pick out like a Hereford and a Charolais because of their coloring, could you explain in more detail what sets different breeds apart? well i guess that would mean like which like which breed is she discussing because uh i mean i i don't i think i think i think she's referring to maybe specific traits of the breed and maybe there's there's a better way to answer this this is a a topic that ryan and i and actually uh my son chase brought to my attention that he was very interested in breed and we're gonna do it in a couple of weeks yeah and we're gonna break it down rosella in in the entire episode so i think it's a good question but i get i guess like i guess i mean like for instance i guess if she's talking about that she can recognize the Hereford because it's red and white or whatever well i mean you can even go into all the black ones okay of course angus or pulled but there's a Lots of other black animals that are polled to some, you know, and so again, I don't know how to answer this question specifically without her saying, you know, please tell me the breed characteristics of a main on Jew.

1:22:11And then I could kind of, you know, go in there and say, well, you know, they kind of look for this and this and this, whatever. But yes, I'm sorry. The historic, the traditional breed characteristics. Yeah, I don't know how to answer it unless she's without her asking for a specific breed. And again, a lot of this will be addressed and discussed in detail because Chase is chomping at the bit about this lovely little topic. He's very, very, very interested in that one. About breed purity. And without going too far in spoiling the episode, if we were to take, I'm just going to pull some cattle breeds up here. let's just say solid black, main, a semi, a key, and you put those three out there of similar age, similar weight, fit, could you walk out there and tell me definitively this is what each of those breeds are? I would like to think that I would be able to give you a very well-educated guess because while they would all be black and all the same weight, they should look differently.

1:23:16there are characteristics that differentiate them now could i say with a hundred percent that i could nail each and every single one no i'm not going to tell you that because it depends what we when well yeah i mean it depends i mean but you could go find the key you could go find the main and you could go find a simondol that are all supposed to be purebred You could drag them out there, and I think that you would just be guessing because you could find three that look that similar. Now, should they? Probably not, but you could. You know what I'm saying? It would depend on the ones out there, but yeah, absolutely.

1:23:57There are things that are supposed to define them, but they're not always there. And I think at the same time, you could find a key, a simian, a main, and bring out there that are distinguishing into their breed. I think it can go either way, depending on what we pull out. Absolutely. And so that's why this is going to be a great topic here in a couple of weeks. Okay, Rosella, hopefully you can tune in here in a few weeks and you'll get to hear a lot about that particular topic. Kimberly gives us the next question. Good morning. We're in Louisville to watch the North American Livestock Exposition. I have a question. There are many people that show both sheep and goats.

1:24:33So where do these people keep their goats before they move in? And so in this situation, the sheep are the weekend, sheep show over the weekend, I believe, Saturday, Sunday, goat show Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, depending on full blood or whether. There's several, there's at least a couple days separating those. They're not all in the grounds at the same time. For example, at the American Royal, your sheep and goats are all in place in the building showing at the same time. At Louisville, the sheep and goats come in early. They're released. Those same pins then get used by the goat people. So her question is, what do you do if you have both species?

1:25:08What do you do with your goats while you're waiting to move in, while you're showing sheep? I think a lot of that depends on the individual family. Again, I tell you, the kid that had champion sheep and champion goat, Hayden Schrader, his mom and him and some other people were there for the sheep, and his stepfather wasn't there for the sheep show because he brought the goats up while they were showing sheep. And so, again, I think it depends on the family and who can be off work, who can't be off work, all that other stuff. But when it is like that, and it's not just at Louisville, Texas majors, I can't tell you how many times mom and dad have to be pulling two different truck and trailers at once because we're down here with heifers, but the steers move in as soon as the heifers move out, etc.

1:25:59And so you just, there is no easy answer to this question. If you want to do both, you've just got to find a way there. There are people that, again, just from my experiences, there are people that say, hey, we'll stay back with the heifers. Y'all go in with the steers. We'll come in with the heifers and they group up, families get together, help each other out, stuff like that. But it's going to depend basically on what that kid's family can do in terms of who can be away, who can be off work, etc. And that's a perfect answer, Ryan. I think that that covers it well. And Kimberly, I think I guess just to simplify things, I don't there are very few shows that are going to provide pins or something to accommodate something like that.

1:26:46So it is it is your responsibility to figure it out. Some will leave them on the trailer. or if they have a nice show trailer, they can leave them out in the parking lot and attend to them. It may not be ideal, but it's a situation that's real, and you've just got to work through the best way possible. The final question, Ryan, and I think we've had, I'm sure we've had this, maybe it wasn't, maybe it was last year. I don't know when. Ryan and Dale, do you know which Texas majors you will be attending this year? Didn't we have this one before? Yes, we have had this one before. And I'd be honored to commit you to an answer. commit me to an answer i know that i will be at houston i plan on being at san antonio not i will be at houston pretty much the whole time i plan on being at san antonio for some of it maybe not all of it plan on going to the fort worth junior heifer show and the junior steer show as far as San Angelo and Austin it is up in the air right now and it will depend on judging schedule and all this other stuff to be honest with you I'm basically going to live in Oklahoma the month of January

1:28:01because I'm judging four breeds at Cattlemen's Congress so I'm there for the first two weeks and then I go back and judge some county fairs and a big jackpot hog show called The Dynasty that's open to the world so i'm gonna spend a lot of time in january in oklahoma but i do plan on being at the fort worth junior heifer show and the fort worth steer show and that also like steers hogs are there and stuff like that so uh i plan to be at a lot of them but i can that that's what i can tell you right now that's that's pretty definitive that's better than i think last time when it came up and i i can tell you from my standpoint i i would like to attend all dale's not going at all he's not he's not going I I will be at some of the Texas majors now to be as transparent as I can depending on what's going on at home and other schedules my daughter Tara our manager Craig myself my wife it's I mean we we would all love to be there that's not not possible so what we will end up doing here shortly is try to try to figure out I do believe we have clients showing at each of the majors and we do like to be there to support those clients and

1:29:10add guidance or assistance, as much or as little as they would like. So traditionally, I will make at least two or three of them. I would say this year, I couldn't even tell you. I'm pretty sure I'll be at Angelo, depending on our schedule. And if I'm not there, either one of our representatives or our manager, Craig, will be there. It seems like I do end up at San Antonio every year. Last year, I did attend Houston. Because he loves Mexican food. It has nothing to do with the goat. This is true. Now, the one that I attended every year for many, many years until COVID was Fort Worth, and I kind of missed getting to Fort Worth, so maybe I'll try to get there as well.

1:29:49But as it gets closer, I'll be more than happy to give you more definitively, and I think Ryan will be able to on Angelo and Austin as well. But as of right now, I'm going to try to make all of them, right? And how's that for a New Year's resolution? There you go. Dale's going to go to all of them. I'm not. I'm just going to. I don't think I will. I don't. I do not. But there you go. Okay. Well, I appreciate your time, Ryan. Great topic that we were able to discuss. And hopefully it benefits those out there participating and sponsoring and putting on the Livestock Judging Contest across the country. Until next week, be safe. Y'all come back now, you hear?

1:30:39you

Enjoying the show? A quick rating helps new listeners find it.

Review on Apple Podcasts Rate on Spotify

More like this

Ep 260Apr 11, 2025102 min

260: Showbreaking 101

Ryan and Dale have a lengthy discussion about the methods, myths, tricks and tips of getting animals show broke.

Sponsors: BW Final Drive Show FresH2O

Ep 6May 22, 202081 min

06: feat. Dan Hoge

In Episode Six, Ryan and Dale get inside the mind of Dan Hoge to discuss topics from a judge's perspective.